On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS.
Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them.
Far, far easier said than done. Not only is the RTS genre less populated as far as fans and playerbase go (competitive RTS especially), mostly since it doesn't cater that much to casual gamers, but there's also the fact that RTS games need quite a lot of depth if they want to not fade away pretty soon. So if we're talking recent RTS games that are balanced enough to be competitively viable, StarCraft 2 is the best there is. Wether or not that actually means anything is a bit hard to tell, I think.
Also I have to agree with what wangstra said above on the previous page.
I agree with OP, hopefully the community can make their own balanced RTS from the default Sc2 game.
Warhammer 40K:Dawn of War had a mod called Dawn of War pro which was alot better than the default gameplay. The creator (Korbah) is a high level RTS player and would consult other top level players to balance and add gameplay changes (like tech tree changes etc). The hardest thing about it was making it popular enough so enough ppl jump on-board. But the idea itself was highly successful, Dawn of War RTS improved and balance was much better.
We should start a revolutionary group called the Liquid Panthers to fight the power of the man and defend the rights of players that dont want more 1a ftw units!
just compare blizzard with valve and what they do for the game it takes blizzard over 2 years to fix battlenet2 and add stuff like clansupport, shared replay and stuff like that when im in the DotA2 lobby i feel like in heaven cuz everything is worked out so perfectly and its still in "beta" sometimes im so dissappointed in how long it takes for them to finaly implent or fix stuff that EVERYONE wants.
The pros play the game for alot of money and they do it as a job. Mods will, at best, be played in some small just-for-fun tournaments or by casual players. I don't see the pros moving over to something much more unstable, something that isn't supported by Blizzard, isn't based on the gameplay and units from the single player, and that has no proper ladder.
On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS.
Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them.
Red Alert 3, CnC 3 and CnC:Generals and SupCom were all pretty solid strategy games, that I know off. Also CoH and DoW are said to be pretty good as well.
Also Dota games don't have a healthy rivalry. Though I haven't seen/played HoN yet, LoL, Dota and Dota2 are basically the same game.
That's like saying RA3 and SC2 are basically the same game.
I can imagine most if not all of them are written by the average adult gamer in his/her thirties who grow up with the classic Blizzard games (BW, Diablo I & II, WC2 / WC3) and just feels the nostalgia of his early years, when playing was hardcore because graphics were terribad, and UI was not even a word.
Sure, I also miss my good old games in the Doom 2 game and the Hexen, but you know what? last night I played them for free on a ROM player and I got sick. I don't understand how could we play those games 20 years ago. Come on man, shrinking sprites?
As Dustin said in the last Blizzcon "BW is a great game, go play it, but this is SC2 and it is a different game"
Same with Diablo III and even the last iterations of WoW. Diablo III is fun and you don't need to grind 24/7 to change your hero abilities just because you want to test another build. WoW is improving and adding content every expansion and changing classes so you have to adapt and learn new strategies and tactics.
Blizzard is a great developer. I have spend many, many hours playing almost every game they have made, and I have never regret doing so.
Stop saying we can do it without Blizzard, because if there weren't for them, we won't be here talking about this, and wouldn't be watching amazing GSL games right now.
On September 11 2012 18:24 wangstra wrote: Jesus fucking christ. Most people here completely fail at reading comprehension.
Where in that post did he suggest making a BW remake? He specifically addressed creating our own community developed fork of StarCraft 2 using the map editor. As in, the changes we find particularly galling that Blizzard makes, we modify on our own and create a community around that.
Some of the more non senile answers here pointed out that Blizz has specifically taken steps to stem this kind of community work such as LAN removal and preventing things like iccup.
The changes don't have to be things like bringing back BW units in particular but addressing issues that come up over and over in these forums and making changes as we see fit regardless of what Kim et co are up to. Changes like removing carrier that saw less changes than BCs or even the mothership.
I'd love to see the pro scene that exists without Blizzard involved. It would shrink awfully quickly when those difficulties arose. You would also have to convince all of the pro players(Particularly the Korean ones to play) before having ANY chance of success. He specifically said that everyone could go to BW if Blizzard shut it down too btw but read what you wish.
On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS.
Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them.
Red Alert 3, CnC 3 and CnC:Generals and SupCom were all pretty solid strategy games, that I know off. Also CoH and DoW are said to be pretty good as well.
Also Dota games don't have a healthy rivalry. Though I haven't seen/played HoN yet, LoL, Dota and Dota2 are basically the same game.
That's like saying RA3 and SC2 are basically the same game.
Play RA3, and you'll see it's way more different than SC2. Apart from the classic westwood techtree, that was copied for Terran.
On September 11 2012 18:58 Eviscerador wrote: I feel totally ashamed of these kind of posts.
I can imagine most if not all of them are written by the average adult gamer in his/her thirties who grow up with the classic Blizzard games (BW, Diablo I & II, WC2 / WC3) and just feels the nostalgia of his early years, when playing was hardcore because graphics were terribad, and UI was not even a word.
Sure, I also miss my good old games in the Doom 2 game and the Hexen, but you know what? last night I played them for free on a ROM player and I got sick. I don't understand how could we play those games 20 years ago. Come on man, shrinking sprites?
As Dustin said in the last Blizzcon "BW is a great game, go play it, but this is SC2 and it is a different game"
Same with Diablo III and even the last iterations of WoW. Diablo III is fun and you don't need to grind 24/7 to change your hero abilities just because you want to test another build. WoW is improving and adding content every expansion and changing classes so you have to adapt and learn new strategies and tactics.
Blizzard is a great developer. I have spend many, many hours playing almost every game they have made, and I have never regret doing so.
Stop saying we can do it without Blizzard, because if there weren't for them, we won't be here talking about this, and wouldn't be watching amazing GSL games right now.
You do realize this isn't the same Blizzard that made those 'classic' games? That Blizzard died a long time ago. SC2 pro-gamers don't play that game over BW because it is better, they play it because they become more famous and get more money in the west. simple. The only thing that could save SC2 is a total boycott by the community that would force Blizzard to make a better LotV... and no, that will never happen. So something like this mod would be much appreciated. EDIT: and no, I will not be buying HotS... maybe if there is a pro-mod... *sigh*
On September 11 2012 18:58 Eviscerador wrote: I feel totally ashamed of these kind of posts.
I can imagine most if not all of them are written by the average adult gamer in his/her thirties who grow up with the classic Blizzard games (BW, Diablo I & II, WC2 / WC3) and just feels the nostalgia of his early years, when playing was hardcore because graphics were terribad, and UI was not even a word.
Sure, I also miss my good old games in the Doom 2 game and the Hexen, but you know what? last night I played them for free on a ROM player and I got sick. I don't understand how could we play those games 20 years ago. Come on man, shrinking sprites?
As Dustin said in the last Blizzcon "BW is a great game, go play it, but this is SC2 and it is a different game"
Same with Diablo III and even the last iterations of WoW. Diablo III is fun and you don't need to grind 24/7 to change your hero abilities just because you want to test another build. WoW is improving and adding content every expansion and changing classes so you have to adapt and learn new strategies and tactics.
Blizzard is a great developer. I have spend many, many hours playing almost every game they have made, and I have never regret doing so.
Stop saying we can do it without Blizzard, because if there weren't for them, we won't be here talking about this, and wouldn't be watching amazing GSL games right now.
...
Have you even read half of the posts you're talking about or are you simply trolling?
You bring up the same trite argument of graphics and UI when it's not even remotely relevant. We're talking about the fact that the units are designed poorly in that almost all of them are not conducive to sick micro play because of how efficient they are on their own. Even at the top of play, you don't really *have to* micro that well in order to secure a victory and some units don't allow for more than just focus fire and retreat micro to avoid death.
You either have not read the posts in this thread or you haven't even tried to understand what we are trying to say here. In either case, you have no idea what you're talking about. And yes, if it weren't for Blizzard we wouldn't be here, but the Blizzard that existed in the 90s and early 00s is not the same as the Actiblizzard we have today. Actually I think it's a bit of the opposite of what you're trying to say, if it weren't for Activision, we would still be here today, but instead of discussing design flaws we would be talking about insane plays from the recent GSL Code S.
It's not Brood war guys. If blizzard see the scene want to put them to teh side, they can just shutdown the game and we don't have LAN to play it without their concern.
lol wtf are these reactions here. His point is excellent, just because he mentioned BW doesn't mean you have to go full retard :D There is so much balance whine or general complaining about sc2 and now hots, which to be honest looks like total shit in it's current state but everybody is too lazy to do anything about it. Pro mods are the norm in fps games like quake or enemy territory and basically 100% of the competitive scene played them.
On September 11 2012 19:10 REDBLUEGREEN wrote: lol wtf are these reactions here. His point is excellent, just because he mentioned BW doesn't mean you have to go full retard :D There is so much balance whine or general complaining about sc2 and now hots, which to be honest looks like total shit in it's current state but everybody is too lazy to do anything about it. Pro mods are the norm in fps games like quake or enemy territory and basically 100% of the competitive scene played them.
Yes but EVERY single thing has to be changed if there was a pro-mod. As far as I know a mod of that scale is illegal according to the TOS, Blizzard would never let it see the light of day
On September 11 2012 19:10 REDBLUEGREEN wrote: lol wtf are these reactions here. His point is excellent, just because he mentioned BW doesn't mean you have to go full retard :D There is so much balance whine or general complaining about sc2 and now hots, which to be honest looks like total shit in it's current state but everybody is too lazy to do anything about it. Pro mods are the norm in fps games like quake or enemy territory and basically 100% of the competitive scene played them.
You know what I'm actually going to stop posting in this thread. It seems like people forsake reading comprehension in the favour of ravenous blind fanboyism of "omg it's not the same game why can't you accept that 1!!111oneoneone" ... By that token we're not supposed to compare any two video games ever because "they're not supposed to be same game" and thus any criticism ever, no matter how warranted or well argumented, is invalidated.
I'm kind of sick of people keeping making that argument. People bitched about sc2 during the beta, and now the game is amazing. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but sometimes it seems that saying you prefer sc2 over BW is like spitting on your grandma and raping babies.
Well, you can do whatever you want but I will stick with SC2. GL with your idea. Even with all whining I did to Blizzard but I still trust them more than you guys to make a game that i will enjoy.
It seems to be the flavour of the month to suddenly bash sc2 in favour of bw. When in reality SC2 has always been like this. hey op check out SC2 promod. It was developed by a bunch of people with the same idea as, it stricked the middle line between both games but hey GL with this though