What If We Don't Need Blizzard? - Page 11
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Epishade
United States2267 Posts
| ||
|
Kal_rA
United States2925 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:04 See.Blue wrote: Yeah man fight the power man. Why all these OMG LETS GO BACK TO BW threads all of a sudden >_< Cause betas out and its a definite change to the game. People are trying to push what they know and love. Kinda moot complaining about wol units 2 years after release when theyre not gonna change anything dramatically. All the latest wol patch notes have been subtle. | ||
|
Yorbon
Netherlands4272 Posts
On September 12 2012 04:49 FeyFey wrote: I almost completely agree with this!BW had just the perfect timing to come into existence. (and bnet which no one else had). If it was today, we would be having the same discussion here and saying Warcraft 2 was just perfect and BW is just bad and Blizzard can't do anything right. Seen a ton of balance suggestions and how to increase game depths, most of them are just preferences of one person and far from any improvement for the game. If someone would be really dissatisfied, they would actually bother trying to do it better or just don't care and move on. And if they actually would make it better, we would have something like dota1 if something is really good it will be used. (Custom map or vanilla, blizzard gets the same money) There was this esport rts rush before sc2 was announced, with alot of rts coming out with a focus on esport and investing into it. Well yeah ... warcraft 3 was not impressed. I am really satisfied with how WoL turned out, though they patched to much at the start, so a few nice units got crippled. It is a nice challenge and is fun to play and view. And personally playing bw or sc2 or watching both. I don't think they are far from each other. Warcraft 1 isn't better then 2 or the other way round, same goes for 3. The focus is shifted abit, but overall it is Warcraft. And i wouls say WoL feels like starcraft. (But Blizzard shouldn't have balanced so eager at the start). There were some funny comments in this thread though, like bw didn't need Blizzard. Had to think about BW and what would have happened without the bnet. ("BW ? whats that ooooh starcraft1 yeah the campaign was nice") But the Valve thing made me laugh and i had to think about f2p bw2 with a unit called the keyling you can buy for real money, where you can open random boxes with where superunits come out, but the keyling dies afterwards. Sc2 has to live up to a Legendary game in a world where everyone knows better then the other with no argumentation needed called the internet. I am impressed they actually tried and didn't just make a single player game and make the multiplayer part bw, with better graphics. But i am glad they didn't. But i have to admit that i have a custom game setup without multi group selection and a few other changes haha and a few interceptor changes (because it is way to easy to fungal interceptors when they launch). PS: everyone should dream of butthats Well, my bw fanboyism doesn't allow to see things like your first point, i don't have any arguments to back that up. | ||
|
dUTtrOACh
Canada2339 Posts
Blizzard also has different priorities now than it did in the 1990s. Revenue streams like World of Warcraft and to a lesser extent, D3 are sensible priorities to them. They want to keep people playing these cash cows. Starcraft 2 almost seems like a pet project by comparison. People buy the game and that's that - no more money without more content (expansions). I don't think they really give a shit about perfect balance or the viewing experience for fans of eSports as much as they do about preventing piracy of this 'one-time-revenue' type game and honestly, people's constant bitching won't help change a thing. We'll have to see, once the content stops rolling in, and if they decide the completed product is sufficiently balanced and patches end, what they will do to keep servers online - servers that they can use for their money titles. For this we need Blizzard. We need them to finish making the game. | ||
|
Inex
Bulgaria443 Posts
The game has to be exciting to watch - huge ball of units vs another ball of units, where one player either wins, or loses. That makes the game easy to understand for the viewers, whereas multiple small engagements on various places on the map are hard to follow, even for the commentators, and it's not very clear who is winning/losing. The game has to be easy to balance. Simple unit design, with A counters B formula accomplishes that. The game has to be accessible. I don't have to explain why that is important, but base management is not exciting. Two armies fighting IS and that's why macroing in SC2 is easy. More fighting makes the game more enjoyable to watch and play. I am not a game designer, but there, I pointed out some of the reasons why SC2 is not BW and why it will never be. We need Blizzard, because if the community was left with the design of this game, we'll most likely end up with a bastardised version of BW, which no one will play, except for those who made it. | ||
|
MattBarry
United States4006 Posts
No seriously, what esports games has valve made? Dota 2 is a copy paste of a fluke custom map. Counterstrike was a mod for Half Life. Their only attempt to make an esport themselves was CS Source which fragmented the community and failed. What exactly makes you think Valve is so qualified? Their games are pretty casual. Not only that, but their attempting to make another CS which from what I've heard is doomed to fail again. | ||
|
SmileZerg
United States543 Posts
On September 12 2012 06:43 Inex wrote: The game has to be exciting to watch - huge ball of units vs another ball of units, where one player either wins, or loses. That makes the game easy to understand for the viewers, whereas multiple small engagements on various places on the map are hard to follow, even for the commentators, and it's not very clear who is winning/losing. You think one engagement between two deathballs and a GG is exciting to watch? There's a very good reason why you're not a game designer. | ||
|
Perscienter
957 Posts
| ||
|
emythrel
United Kingdom2599 Posts
On September 12 2012 07:09 MattBarry wrote: Why would anyone think valve can design an esport? No seriously, what esports games has valve made? Dota 2 is a copy paste of a fluke custom map. Counterstrike was a mod for Half Life. Their only attempt to make an esport themselves was CS Source which fragmented the community and failed. What exactly makes you think Valve is so qualified? Their games are pretty casual. Not only that, but their attempting to make another CS which from what I've heard is doomed to fail again. Well CS:GO is for the most part just 1.6 with an updated look and engine, much like dota2 is just WC3 dota with updated look and a better engine. the reason source failed was because it took what 1.6 was and made it worse and didn't look any better (same engine and basically same gfx). SC2 is not BW, its not just a clone, its like WC3 is to WC2. Similar but different. We have SC2BW and not that many people play it, no one plays it competitively because guess what... its does what BW does but worse, it just looks better. It is impossible to make SC2 into BW with better gfx, it simply wouldn't work. BW was a "fluke" just like Dota, it found balance in imbalance, it found epicness is unintentional game play & bugs and found a home in Kespa where it could flourish. There is no way to reproduce the bad pathing exactly or how muta micro worked. Reavers SUCK, they are terribly designed but by some amazing random chance it turned out that they were amazing when coupled with shuttle micro. BW is full of things like that and they took YEARS to figure out. No matter how hard you tried you could never reproduce it exactly for that very reason, you could build all the bugs in intentionally and new ones would arise that break the game in some other way. We can change SC2 by lobbying Blizzard, they've already started using tournament standard maps on ladder (well nearly, no neutral supply depots, but one step at a time) and they have listened to players and the community about things that may need a nerf or buff and they've even started to let the game balance itself through innovative maps and gameplay. This game isn't finished, it won't be for years... once its finished and blizz stop officially supporting and patching etc, if we still feel like the game needs tweaks then we can do it, or more likely maps makers and tournaments will do the balancing and tweaking for their own benefit, until that time can we please allow blizzard to do their work. The beta has been out a week, the warhound might not even make it in to the game, tempest might be completely reworked, we have no idea, neither do blizzard because THAT IS WHAT A BETA IS FOR. | ||
|
Xiphos
Canada7507 Posts
Not only it is a vicious cycle, but also a Domino effect where one piece collapses, the entire infrastructure goes with it. So do you or do you not want to keep your precious pro scene? If so, suck it up. | ||
|
Nimic
Norway1360 Posts
On September 11 2012 22:20 Ursad0n wrote: Sc2 just got a lot of fans cause it was new, like wrath babies in wow, or even worse fans of star wars episodes 1,2, and 3 I'm an "older" gamer (compared to most people on the internet, these days), but even I think that's a pretty idiotic way to look at things. Yeah, fuck those guys who just came into things and now like them. You like BW? Such a BW-baby. I played Dune 2, that's a proper RTS, and you should feel bad for not being around to play it then. Or maybe you did, since you talk down to fans of the new Star Wars movies. Which can only mean you were around when the first Star Wars movies were made, right? | ||
|
Gamegene
United States8308 Posts
SC1 most of it was based in Korea, one of the smallest countries and densely populated (WE'RE HERE LIVE HERE IN SEOUL SOUTH KOREA, THE MECCA OF ESPORTS!). SC2, you get the point. | ||
|
ref4
2933 Posts
I swear 99% of TL posters have delusion of grandeur syndrome. Yes SC2 is far from perfect, yes BW was better in terms of spectator-bility, but seriously, Blizzard is working hard on bettering SC2 and making it living up to the name of Starcraft. How many companies beside Blizzard (and Valve) listen to the community and actively patch their games? | ||
|
Assirra
Belgium4169 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:43 YMCApylons wrote: If Valve makes a pro-gaming friendly RTS, I'd be all over that. At this point, we need someone else to make a serious RTS to keep Blizzard honest. I think you people seriously underestimate designing an RTS. Valve has zero experience in this and you want them to make one that has better balance then sc2 from the gate and rivals BW in complexity. Do you have any idea how unreasonable this sounds? | ||
|
Gamegene
United States8308 Posts
On September 12 2012 08:15 ref4 wrote: Yet another thread on why Blizzard sucks and how the OP can out-do a multi-billion company. I swear 99% of TL posters have delusion of grandeur syndrome. Yes SC2 is far from perfect, yes BW was better in terms of spectator-bility, but seriously, Blizzard is working hard on bettering SC2 and making it living up to the name of Starcraft. How many companies beside Blizzard (and Valve) listen to the community and actively patch their games? that would be every company that has a game with a relevant population and multiplayer | ||
|
stichtom
Italy695 Posts
I don't think so, blizzard is doing a fantastic job with the WCS. Wcs are better than the international because with the Wcs blizzard is helping e sports to grow everywhere. I think the Wcs are so underated and people don't follow these series as much as they should do. | ||
|
Toyman69
Canada100 Posts
On September 11 2012 23:17 Barrin wrote: + Show Spoiler + LET THE FIRE BURN WITHIN THINE HEARTS! lol So glad ppl are keeping this possibility alive :> No, we don't need Blizzard. Yes, we do need someone to rival Blizzard in the RTS genre. Big companies are not interested in the RTS genre most likely because the casual/hardcore dichotomy is particularly strong. If we want Brood War 2.0, we need to make it ourselves. We're hardcore after all aren't we? --- This is what I'm looking for
Other than these things I don't really care about any certain unit or it's behavior. I don't want BW anymore, and with just a little bit of imagination you can see that BW is only one of many ways of conforming to the above list. This is just good RTS design philosophy if you want to facilitate deep/rich/complex/dynamic gameplay. If you tell me to just go play BW I will eSlap you. --- We have two choices really. Do we create a whole new company or do we just go with a Promod? Someone's gotta step up to the plate, and it's up to them how far they wanna take it. I think someone with ambition would make a whole new company. If we were to make a promod that conforms to the above list it would be such a drastically different game (some units don't even make the cut) that we might as well make our own game. What it comes down to is that SC2 as it is now (and as it will probably be in the foreseeable future) is just too much unlike the kind of deep game we're after to the point that most people who play SC2 as it is now would not (and often already do not) like or even understand the kind of gameplay we're after. Many of the kinds of people who appreciate the gameplay we're after quit SC2 a while ago and never looked back. We need a new player base IMO. Perhaps a promod is feasible, I just feel like it will only ever be feasible as a shadow of what it should be. Maybe I'll get over that and make it myself someday. BTW right now we have two things that are kinda like this (but not close enough IMO): a mod called SC2BW and a mod called STARBOW. I would only add moving in formation/pathing cuz seeing everything auto ball up whenever u right click is atrocious for making splash units balanced. Thank you, finally some1 who can actually see the difs between the 2 games. I hope a mod or another game like this comes out. Tired off this checkers like game when I know it can be could be amazing with features like this added. | ||
|
sLideSC2
United States225 Posts
| ||
|
Xiphos
Canada7507 Posts
On September 12 2012 08:20 Assirra wrote: I think you people seriously underestimate designing an RTS. Valve has zero experience in this and you want them to make one that has better balance then sc2 from the gate and rivals BW in complexity. Do you have any idea how unreasonable this sounds? Valve have some really smart and innovative developers. All they need to do is re-watch one full season of BW ProLeague, figure out the nuances that made it so evolutionary in terms of spectatorship, and emulate it with captivating units that goes to w/e lore their direction may point into. And quite honest, a lot company can do so but it is a very daunting tasks and brain stimulating activity for a coherent analysis to take place. One thing I would like to add is that since BW's graphic is traditional on a 2D plane with less pixels, Valve can simply alters its definitions to a higher caliber to appeal into the visual reliant gamers. That being said, the workload on the modeling department of the project would be rather minimum. This directly translates into the development's pace. Nowadays, many companies are spending the majority of their time to create stunning visuals. The new RTS would definitely take little time to spread its wings. From there, we got ourselves 2 criteria filled, the gameplay + visual. All that is left are the fanbase to support it early. With Valve's reputation, and because of the low budget inquired, thus could be made free to play, thus furthering its accessibility. Secondary component and backbone consists of it being 2 dimensional so people with the lower echelon of computer spec have the opportunity to partake in it. | ||
|
Forikorder
Canada8840 Posts
basically point out a single group of people who have a better track record at balancing then blizzard | ||
| ||