| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
bennyaus
Australia1833 Posts
On March 04 2011 18:45 doihy wrote: There's a reason why you don't cast live events / live online tourneys. I'll let you find the reason through introspection. That isn't really helpful discussion, if you want to criticise at least tell him why. | ||
|
Alabasern
United States4005 Posts
| ||
|
emythrel
United Kingdom2599 Posts
On March 04 2011 18:44 iNcontroL wrote: wait people think husky and I have beef? WTF  It's impossible to be critical these days without everyone thinking you hate them lol Geoff, perhaps you should try swapping around the critique and the compliment...... normally you start with "i like this guy, hes great" and finish with the constructive criticism..... if you did it the other way around perhaps these morons would use their selective memories to focus on the good thing you said instead of the criticism you gave...... but then again, this is the interwebs...... and of course just like in real sports, being professional (according to said morons) is never saying anything funny, inciteful, critical or true......... I have never once heard a football commentator pick apart a players mistakes or given an opinion.... oh wait.... and @husky, your casts aren't my cup of tea but then I'm sure my casts wouldn't be your cup of tea either! Keep doing what you are doing, so long as you find it fun. | ||
|
doihy
668 Posts
On March 04 2011 18:49 bennyaus wrote: That isn't really helpful discussion, if you want to criticise at least tell him why. There's no need for my criticism. It's really just a matter of opinion, you don't see Husky casting any live events or online tourneys... because the people who run them never request him to be there. So it isn't really my opinion/criticism that matters, it's the tournament runners' opinions that do. To illustrate this...Take MLG for example, you have Husky one time and the rest you never see his face again. Also, if Husky really wanted to help esports with his youtube popularity I would like to give him some suggestions. 1)Make an introductory video for those who are completely new to starcraft or competitive starcraft 2) Plug gomtv, mlg, nasl with a specific video. (don't just be like "ohhh hey check this out" right before or after a starcraft replay cast) 3) HDH2 | ||
|
Space Invader
Australia291 Posts
On March 04 2011 18:44 iNcontroL wrote: wait people think husky and I have beef? WTF It's impossible to be critical these days without everyone thinking you hate them lol you probably closed his music video before it finished one time on stream and everyone realised you actually just hated him | ||
|
gregnog
United States289 Posts
| ||
|
Sorkoas
549 Posts
Something that I really dislike about both yours and HD's videos you put up on YouTube is that most of times (from what I can remember) you don't mention where you got the replays from. As in which tournament, who their sponsors are and if it has been casted before. Many times I go to YouTube and try find a game I remember seeing on some other cast and I find a casted version put up by you or HD and it feels like you are both taking content and viewers from the original casters who might even have been an official caster for that tournament. So yeah, I wish you could give some more credit to the guys you got the replay from and even mention who did cast it originally. I'm sure it won't affect your own viewer count with your already great amount of fame/popularity. | ||
|
Bloodash
Netherlands1384 Posts
tyler and incontrol = ricky gervais and steve merchant, and painuser is the (somewhat less funny) carl pilkington + Show Spoiler + | ||
|
gray-fox
Finland62 Posts
On March 04 2011 17:12 turdburgler wrote: couldnt agree more. im not gonna jump into the dt vs banshee debate except to add in a few more stupid arguemets along the lines of those used in the show you cant combined 2 banshees into a battlecruiser and you cant warp in a banshee in their base?!?!!? about as useful as the comments about dts cant fly. but it is really dull hearing 2 protoss players out shout 1 terran player in a comparison that doesnt even make sense. i dont think anyone really believes banshees and dts are similar enough to compare, and since the armies they fit into are different, even if they were the same they would still fill different roles. i think everyone on the cast understands this but since all they wanted to do was shout, a whole hour of the show got wasted and overall i was really bored with it. Don't people have any sense of humor in the Starcraft community? Seriously. Stop watching the show if you don't see a difference between serious discussion and joking. | ||
|
Alabasern
United States4005 Posts
HDH2 would be great publicity, guest appearances on DJwheats casts, TSL guest appearance with Chill and DJwheat, or helping connect the east to the Western E-sports scene. BTW being a good player is f...ing hard and that's a big reason why day9 gets respect! Plus Nick opened the door for the Plott brothers being on countless vods over in Korea and plenty of WCG footage with him and Djwheat! | ||
|
grevenchile
Chile118 Posts
i hope when idra returns to the usa, he get a spot in the show as a regular, he is pretty much already a pilar of the show. | ||
|
Cri du Chat
Germany606 Posts
On March 04 2011 18:58 emythrel wrote: Geoff, perhaps you should try swapping around the critique and the compliment...... normally you start with "i like this guy, hes great" and finish with the constructive criticism..... if you did it the other way around perhaps these morons would use their selective memories to focus on the good thing you said instead of the criticism you gave...... The best way to go about it, is the good old sandwich strategy. Start with something positive, then the negative stuff and finish with a nice compliment :D. | ||
|
dunc
Netherlands1105 Posts
On March 04 2011 19:47 grevenchile wrote: i hope when idra returns to the usa, he get a spot in the show as a regular, he is pretty much already a pilar of the show. I really hope he doesn't. We already have pretty much every personality on the show. Idra is like a much more extreme version of Incontrol, really don't need that clouding the useful discussions that go on on SOTG. | ||
|
Husky
United States3362 Posts
Buuuuuut going into detail on that will just bring up the next talking point.  | ||
|
Horse...falcon
United States1851 Posts
On March 04 2011 17:00 EnderCraft wrote: Because idra only releases replays to artosis. That question is dumb. Any replay someone posts with idra on ladder is most likely going to be an idra loss. Actually your response is the common explanation that I've heard over and over again. IdrA played 12 games at IEM on day 1 and won 8 of them. All replays where released yet the only 2 casted games are Idra's losses to Ace. Don't be a fool and just accept that "the only replays available are losses" as the sole excuse. I know there was a bit of bad blood between the casters and IdrA after the HDH final and IdrA hasn't been shy when discussing his disdain for the casters. I'm just wondering if this is still impacting which games Husky and HD decide to cast. I'm not a hater, Husky and HD have done a great job promoting the community. I understand that drama attracts viewers and watching IdrA lose is good for viewership. But It's disappointing that the rhetoric and storyline propagated by such important members of the community seems to be fueled by personal grudges. | ||
|
dark fury
Sweden426 Posts
| ||
|
Voros
United States222 Posts
| ||
|
Skrelt
Netherlands306 Posts
On March 04 2011 20:17 dark fury wrote: i hope that terran player (painuser?) wont apear on more casts. annoying voice and generally ignorant and unwilling to see things from other races/players perspectives (banshee discussion, im pretty sure no other top terran player would side with him in that discussion) ignorant? cause he doesnt have the same opinion? i think he made some good point why HE like DT's more than Banshee's. It is his opinion. I can understand people not agree with him, but to call him ignorant because he has his own opinion? xD more people should need a own opinion. | ||
|
Husky
United States3362 Posts
On March 04 2011 20:06 Horse...falcon wrote: Actually your response is the common explanation that I've heard over and over again. IdrA played 12 games at IEM on day 1 and won 8 of them. All replays where released yet the only 2 casted games are Idra's losses to Ace. Don't be a fool and just accept that "the only replays available are losses" as the sole excuse. I know there was a bit of bad blood between the casters and IdrA after the HDH final and IdrA hasn't been shy when discussing his disdain for the casters. I'm just wondering if this is still impacting which games Husky and HD decide to cast. I'm not a hater, Husky and HD have done a great job promoting the community. I understand that drama attracts viewers and watching IdrA lose is good for viewership. But It's disappointing that the rhetoric and storyline propagated by such important members of the community seems to be fueled by personal grudges. I didnt know IdrA was going to lose those games. I just got a lot of messages saying Ace was playing insanely well and I wanted to see the games (if you notice I cast 3 sets of Ace games) Opened the replay pack and saw IdrA's name. Thats all there is to it. I'm not trying to smear him as a player or make him look bad. The majority of his games ARE from ladder matches uploaded by people who beat him. If people are honestly that bent out of shape over it they are just making a big deal out of nothing. Yes, IdrA does make fun of me a lot and say im worthless/in it for the money or whatever. Thats IdrA's persona. It doesnt affect which games of his I cast, I'm not 6. | ||
|
phuzi0n
United States308 Posts
On March 04 2011 16:44 HuskyTheHusky wrote: In the end, haters gonna hate. However, this ghetto phrase keeps coming up lately and is totally dismissive of anyone providing legitimate criticisms. Ignore the nonconstructive criticism but don't say things like this that dismiss all criticism. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 RotterdaM StarCraft: Brood War 1011TKL  411IndyStarCraft  260SteadfastSC  196ProTech140 BRAT_OK   96JuggernautJason70 SKillous 53EmSc Tv 15Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Grubby5056 FrodaN954 Beastyqt682 ceh9522 KnowMe235 ArmadaUGS159 C9.Mang0156 mouzStarbuck146 Pyrionflax125 Hui .105 Trikslyr53 MindelVK15 |
|
RSL Revival
GSL
Afreeca Starleague
Barracks vs Leta
Royal vs Light
WardiTV Map Contest Tou…
RSL Revival
Replay Cast
The PondCast
KCM Race Survival
WardiTV Map Contest Tou…
CranKy Ducklings
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
