On December 16 2022 18:42 Acrofales wrote:
Regardless, I'm going to throw the B into the running.

Beckenbauer, Beckham, Bergkamp, van Basten and Batistuta seems like a pretty good base to build on

and Buffon, Baresi, Ballack, Busquets, Benzema, Bale

Acrofales

Spain18375 Posts

December 16 2022 11:47 GMT

#1122

On December 16 2022 19:53 Charoisaur wrote:

Show nested quote +

and Buffon, Baresi, Ballack, Busquets, Benzema, Bale

Yeah, both Baggio brothers, both de Boer brothers and de Bruyne as well. B looks like a contender for the second place.

Acrofales

Spain18375 Posts

December 16 2022 11:59 GMT

#1123

Maybe it should be a team thing. Pick an 11-player team by letter. In that case, M might be in trouble to hold onto first place, because it's ridiculously stacked with forwards, but I can't really think of a stand-out Goalkeeper with M. They got some legendary defenders tho. Maldini and Materazzi come to mind. But with a front three of Maradona, Messi and Mbappe (third spot is up for grabs, can be Müller, or di Maria for the Argentina synergy) I'm not sure you need a legendary goalkeeper

Both B and C have excellence across the field. R seems to have a defense problem. Rüdiger doesn't seem like he's going to cut it.

Harris1st

Germany7320 Posts

December 16 2022 12:27 GMT

#1124

On December 16 2022 20:59 Acrofales wrote:
Maybe it should be a team thing. Pick an 11-player team by letter. In that case, M might be in trouble to hold onto first place, because it's ridiculously stacked with forwards, but I can't really think of a stand-out Goalkeeper with M. They got some legendary defenders tho. Maldini and Materazzi come to mind. But with a front three of Maradona, Messi and Mbappe (third spot is up for grabs, can be Müller, or di Maria for the Argentina synergy) I'm not sure you need a legendary goalkeeper

Both B and C have excellence across the field. R seems to have a defense problem. Rüdiger doesn't seem like he's going to cut it.

Mane? Luxury problem detected ^-^

Liquid`Drone

Norway28866 Posts

December 16 2022 13:02 GMT

#1125

The offensive lineup for M (someone like Mane isn't even in contention, imo), as well as defense (Mätthaus, Maldini, Marcelo all immediately spring to mind) are broken, but there are weaknesses. Gonna try to make a full lineup of 3-5-2 or 4-3-3 or 4-4-2 and see how stuff stacks up. So far I'm leaning M B C R as the top 4 at least, but I'm sure there are other contenders.

Harris1st

Germany7320 Posts

December 16 2022 13:43 GMT

#1126

On December 16 2022 22:02 Liquid`Drone wrote:
The offensive lineup for M (someone like Mane isn't even in contention, imo), as well as defense (Mätthaus, Maldini, Marcelo all immediately spring to mind) are broken, but there are weaknesses. Gonna try to make a full lineup of 3-5-2 or 4-3-3 or 4-4-2 and see how stuff stacks up. So far I'm leaning M B C R as the top 4 at least, but I'm sure there are other contenders.

Just looking for some German players for your lineups:
Sepp Maier
Per Mertesacker
Andi Möller
Thomas Müller
Lothar Matthäus

Michael Ballack
Franz Beckenbauer
Oliver Bierhoff
Jerome Boateng in his 2014 form
Guido Buchwald

Acrofales

Spain18375 Posts

December 16 2022 18:00 GMT

#1127

On December 16 2022 22:43 Harris1st wrote:

Show nested quote +

When I said Müller as a striker for M, I meant Gerd Müller. Also, Möller and Mertesacker? Setting the bar quite low there

Liquid`Drone

Norway28866 Posts

December 16 2022 20:49 GMT

#1128

M is like, Messi Maradona Modric Matthaus Marcelo Maldini Mbappe/Müller (gerd).. there's a goalie missing and two/three midfielders/defenders, but the team basically contains two of the top 3-4 players ever, and every other player on the list has arguably peaked as number one in their particular position.

Even going with a macherano level dm and a relatively mediocre gk (before my time but sepp maier seems like a solid pick) I still think this is a winner.

GTR

51650 Posts

December 16 2022 21:11 GMT

#1129

Do you guys reckon Haaland/Mbappe will eclipse the CR7/Messi rivalry?

aseq

Netherlands4009 Posts

December 16 2022 21:20 GMT

#1130

Eclipse? No. Match? Maybe close...but I read somewhere Haaland will need to score 46 goals/year until he's 38 yo to match Ronaldo's total. A lot can happen before then.

Liquid`Drone

Norway28866 Posts

December 16 2022 22:12 GMT

#1131

Unlikely, but there's a possibility. I dunno if they're likely to end up in rival clubs though. I don't picture Mbappe going to England, could see both be in Spain at the same time though. But then maybe with RM getting both. xD

And yea, injuries.

Melliflue

United Kingdom1389 Posts

December 17 2022 07:33 GMT

#1132

On December 17 2022 05:49 Liquid`Drone wrote:
M is like, Messi Maradona Modric Matthaus Marcelo Maldini Mbappe/Müller (gerd).. there's a goalie missing and two/three midfielders/defenders, but the team basically contains two of the top 3-4 players ever, and every other player on the list has arguably peaked as number one in their particular position.

Even going with a macherano level dm and a relatively mediocre gk (before my time but sepp maier seems like a solid pick) I still think this is a winner.

How about Makelele as dm?

KobraKay

Portugal4359 Posts

December 17 2022 08:57 GMT

#1133

contemporary keepers you got marchesin, martinez, mendy as 3 low budget candidates.

Liquid`Drone

Norway28866 Posts

December 17 2022 10:34 GMT

#1134

I was trying to remember Makelele! He's totally on the team.

DropBear

Australia4415 Posts

December 17 2022 15:05 GMT

#1135

Stanley Matthews should be in the equation

DropBear

Australia4415 Posts

December 17 2022 16:20 GMT

#1136

Alright I think I have a competitive and balanced all time team for C.

GK: Iker Casillas
RB: Cafu
CB: Fabio Cannavaro
CB: Alessando Costacurta
LB: Antonio Cabrini
M: Mario Coluna
M: Fyodor Cherenkov
M: Bobby Charlton
RF: Jans Ceulemans
CF: Johan Cruyff
LF: Zoltan Czibor

The hardest to select was the goalkeeper. Rogerio Ceni and Jose Luis Chilavert missed out.