EPT[SPL] EG-TL vs Woongjin Stars R1 - Page 107
| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments |
|
eqinf
Germany100 Posts
| ||
|
babylon
8765 Posts
| ||
|
BoZiffer
United States1841 Posts
On December 23 2012 15:47 Ansinjunger wrote: But did JYP see the TC, or just a bunch of stalkers and/or 3 gates or something? I'm trying to figure out if JYP should have felt really lucky to scout the TC, or if he should have been suspicious that he was allowed to see it or something. I'm just curious how much of it was planned or a snap call (it's smart either way), and in glorious hindsight, it seems like a pretty logical play to make: fake 3 gate blink/robo on Antiga, expand with later robo, defend any 1 base push relatively easily or be ahead economically. I'm wondering if the logic simply breaks down if JYP is able to execute a 3 gate blink himself, or if Shy in fact does something entirely different if he sniffs it out of JYP. It's not so much clinging to could have beens for EG-TL, since JYP and Puma were playing quite impatiently anyway. I am rather dubious of strategies that rely on tech cancels when the lost resources could make the difference. This is especially possible in PvP, where defender's advantage isn't very much. Scouted the TC once in the back of the base, went back to the ramp with the scouting probe, and then scouted it again (~75%) at that point, then probe was killed by stalker, then TC cancelled. | ||
|
His_fas
20 Posts
On December 23 2012 15:47 Ansinjunger wrote: But did JYP see the TC, or just a bunch of stalkers and/or 3 gates or something? I'm trying to figure out if JYP should have felt really lucky to scout the TC, or if he should have been suspicious that he was allowed to see it or something. I'm just curious how much of it was planned or a snap call (it's smart either way), and in glorious hindsight, it seems like a pretty logical play to make: fake 3 gate blink/robo on Antiga, expand with later robo, defend any 1 base push relatively easily or be ahead economically. I'm wondering if the logic simply breaks down if JYP is able to execute a 3 gate blink himself, or if Shy in fact does something entirely different if he sniffs it out of JYP. It's not so much clinging to could have beens for EG-TL, since JYP and Puma were playing quite impatiently anyway. I am rather dubious of strategies that rely on tech cancels when the lost resources could make the difference. This is especially possible in PvP, where defender's advantage isn't very much. JYP Lost his mind in this game ... After the scouted the TC he saw no probes, no Stalkers , nothing on the map...sOs wasnt even trying to fake ... | ||
|
GTPGlitch
5061 Posts
lul i'm dumb, wrong thread | ||
|
oBlade
United States5256 Posts
On December 23 2012 15:46 Cel.erity wrote: My point was more about EG's signing practices and how they are more concerned with brand marketing, while other teams are more concerned with making their players better. Yes, that's a legitimate point in general, but it's not necessary to make things up about JD in the process. | ||
|
Supah
708 Posts
On December 23 2012 15:53 His_fas wrote: JYP Lost his mind in this game ... After the scouted the TC he saw no probes, no Stalkers , nothing on the map...sOs wasnt even trying to fake ... It was a good read by JYP, but his Zealots were bunched and didn't even get to engage due to FF positioning. Pushes like that usually work because the Zealots are spread and hitting things, and the opponent's Immortals are pushed forward. Neither of that happened. | ||
|
mijellin
China740 Posts
| ||
|
silent_owl
Philippines3098 Posts
| ||
|
letian
Germany4221 Posts
| ||
|
WhiteSatin
United States308 Posts
I love JYP but I do have to agree, why use him as Ace ? He seems a bit shaky when it matters... | ||
TheEmulator
28078 Posts
On December 23 2012 16:48 WhiteSatin wrote: I had to leave after the Taeja game and they were 2-2, came back to see the sad news. I love JYP but I do have to agree, why use him as Ace ? He seems a bit shaky when it matters... Yeah, the result is too bad  | ||
|
Scholes
Venezuela312 Posts
| ||
|
Micro_Jackson
Germany2002 Posts
| ||
|
Big-t
Austria1350 Posts
| ||
|
ZerglingTwins
United States850 Posts
On December 23 2012 17:24 USvBleakill wrote: Is the ace match not for the best players? I mean JYP is a good player but half the roster of TLEG are just better than him. Coach probably was trying to snipe soulkey with that JYP pick. And SoS was trying to snipe Taeja, I think. | ||
|
NightOfTheDead
Lithuania1711 Posts
| ||
|
TheEmulator
28078 Posts
On December 23 2012 17:28 NightOfTheDead wrote: Hm i dont doubt coach decision, but i wonder why send player who lost already today. They wouldnt have anticipated PvP probably, got tricked. Yeah, I am sure they had a reason, but just can't see it yet. | ||
|
SwizzY
United States1549 Posts
On December 23 2012 17:28 NightOfTheDead wrote: Hm i dont doubt coach decision, but i wonder why send player who lost already today. They wouldnt have anticipated PvP probably, got tricked. Exactly. Might be just testing the waters and player potential but that's the best excuse I can come up with. JYP not ace material either. | ||
|
alone
Poland410 Posts
On December 23 2012 15:50 eqinf wrote: the taeja game atleast was funny but puma ..................... It was funny in a tragic way. | ||
| ||
