|
On November 08 2010 04:48 Xeteh wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2010 04:46 sleepingdog wrote:On November 08 2010 04:39 JWD wrote:
Guys, do we really need to have this same tired debate about the merits of MLG's extended series in every MLG LR thread? I'd agree with you generally, but here it's really about that both players have lost in WB and it shouldn't matter at all if one of them has beaten the other one in WB - both have lost a bo3 and still one goes into the loser-bracket-match with a huge advantage Makes no sense at all, quite opposed to the discussion about the extended series in the finals. Well, back to the match, glad that TT1 won on xel naga, excited for more! Someone said already, and it was totally ignored, if the next match went 2-1 for Tyler that means that Tyler advanced with a record of 2-3 vs PainUser. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it isn't fair/logical.
ok then it's fair that painuser is the only person who gets to lose 6 (4 to someone who he's already proven he can beat) times to get eliminated while everyone else gets only 4?
|
On November 08 2010 04:48 Xeteh wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2010 04:46 sleepingdog wrote:On November 08 2010 04:39 JWD wrote:
Guys, do we really need to have this same tired debate about the merits of MLG's extended series in every MLG LR thread? I'd agree with you generally, but here it's really about that both players have lost in WB and it shouldn't matter at all if one of them has beaten the other one in WB - both have lost a bo3 and still one goes into the loser-bracket-match with a huge advantage Makes no sense at all, quite opposed to the discussion about the extended series in the finals. Well, back to the match, glad that TT1 won on xel naga, excited for more! Someone said already, and it was totally ignored, if the next match went 2-1 for Tyler that means that Tyler advanced with a record of 2-3 vs PainUser. Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it isn't fair/logical.
This isn't true and ignores the amount of games played. I'm going to bullshit some numbers here b/c I don't want to pour over the brackets but...
You're saying it's more fair for Tyler to be down 0-2 even though Painuser may only be 10-5 aggregate while Tyler is 20-4? (Bullshit numbers but it is a possibility due to dropping to LB earlier)
Edit: The poster above me raises another good point. The MLG system is just an experiment that has failed (imo) and they need to get in line with every other major double elim tournament.
|
On November 08 2010 04:48 Xeteh wrote:
Someone said already, and it was totally ignored, if the next match went 2-1 for Tyler that means that Tyler advanced with a record of 2-3 vs PainUser.
Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it isn't fair/logical.
so what? someone can get out of group stages having lost to someone who gets eliminated. It's not about head-to-head records, it's about overall performance across the bracket.
|
repetition of game 1 incoming
|
Love jinro's mad scouting. Beaten into him by OGsInca I guess...
|
Here we go again, raven/banshee push lets see how hard TT1 is gonna lose this time.
|
will need phoenix this game otherwise TT1 is done imo.
|
|
|
On November 08 2010 04:49 dtz wrote:
FA= FrozenArbiter = Jinro
He was toss in BW? Or just randomly toss-sounding name?
|
|
|
Canada13410 Posts
why does everyone like collossus so much?
|
On November 08 2010 04:50 Redmark wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2010 04:48 Xeteh wrote:
Someone said already, and it was totally ignored, if the next match went 2-1 for Tyler that means that Tyler advanced with a record of 2-3 vs PainUser.
Just because you don't like something doesn't mean it isn't fair/logical. so what? someone can get out of group stages having lost to someone who gets eliminated. It's not about head-to-head records, it's about overall performance across the bracket.
I want to make this clear: This is why you can't please everybody, so stop complaining. Some people agree with it, some people don't. There is no actual way to say "this format is better", because it's 100% subjective. Stop complaining and start your own tournament w/ a structure you like.
|
United States238 Posts
|
cant see tt1 winning this...
|
My stream's lagging/pulsing, anyone know a reason why?
|
On November 08 2010 04:49 slam wrote:
What is SotG?
State of the Game podcast with JP, Day9, Tyler and Incontrol.
|
Non-adaptive play is gonna cost TT1 the game, probably :S
|
Seems like Jinro has catched on to how greedy TT1 plays.
|
On November 08 2010 04:51 ironwarrior wrote:
why does everyone like collossus so much?
Shoots laz0rz0z?
|
I should have know that. 
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
