EPThopefully the strat forums become more useful now
[!] A WARNING (Purge) - Page 11
| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Strategy |
|
-AtRi-
123 Posts
hopefully the strat forums become more useful now | ||
|
zocktol
Germany1928 Posts
On April 10 2011 00:52 Jeffbelittle wrote: This is the only one I'm really concerned about, I mean, granted this is a higher level Strategy forum; however, even Master league players will forget to make workers at times, or get supply blocked, and of course either of those two things will contribute to the loss; however, I didn't think it'd be such a horrible offense after posting the replay and giving an in-depth analysis of the replay that just because our probes and pylons isn't day9 that we get banned? If this is the case, could you at least make a stickied thread much like the simple question simple answer where novices can post their replays and ask for help? I do not think he is talking about forgetting the occasional worker, but rather things like 1500 minerals at the 10 minute mark, only 21 Workers on 2 base or other obvious flaws like that. I have never posted in the strategy forum before, because i feel not qualified to give other people advice, however, when i read some of the threads here i actually think that such harsh guidelines are neccesary. Btw. im really suprised nobody has posted this : Shit just got real! | ||
|
stokes17
United States1411 Posts
On April 08 2011 11:27 CecilSunkure wrote: I like how it's mandatory to read my thread on improving :D its cause all your threads are fucking awesome dude Keep up the Good Work | ||
|
Foreplay
United States1154 Posts
| ||
|
DyEnasTy
United States3720 Posts
On April 08 2011 11:21 ElusoryX wrote: it's like almost every post will get banned. maybe ths will get me banned too lol. walkin the edge of martyrdom. But damn Saracen, droppin the ban hammer, better yet the ban nuke. I love it! | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
On April 08 2011 11:11 Saracen wrote: If your thread is about a new strategy and you do not have a damn good analysis (with replays) (i.e. I think your thread is too theorycrafty), you can play against me in a BO3 with your strategy. If you lose, you will be BANNED. This is amazing, casted by Day9 I hope :D | ||
|
Dubz
United States242 Posts
| ||
|
Rareware
Canada340 Posts
On April 10 2011 01:14 stokes17 wrote: its cause all your threads are fucking awesome dude Keep up the Good Work Agreed that guide is excellent.And really so many of peoples problems could be solved by that guide that you don't need to be constantly spamming the strat forum with help threads. | ||
|
Rawr
Sweden624 Posts
| ||
|
zickoray
United States366 Posts
http://us.battle.net/sc2/en/forum/topic/2353268336 I mean for god sakes look at the title it is absolutely pathetic  so i really hope you continue this banhammer campaign GL with getting the thread back to quality | ||
|
mothergoose729
United States666 Posts
| ||
|
Beef Noodles
United States937 Posts
On April 10 2011 05:01 mothergoose729 wrote: I fear TL and especially the TL strategy thread is becoming exceptionally elitist. 92% of players on the ladder are platinum and under, and ~50% are bronze. The teamliquid site should embrace people of all skill levels. If the sc2 strategy forum is going to be so exclusive, there should be a place for people to ask questions and get help that is much more inclusive. Make the sc2 strategy board you want, but include a board (and one thread is not enough, sorry) where people can post less then exceptional threads. It's not about elitism or not. It's about strategy. It's about what's bad play and what's better play. Let's use an example: the vast majority of people are not scientists. That doesn't mean we get to clog/clutter the science textbooks and journals with our random ideas. Scientists aren't being "elitist" by excluding how I think the oceans formed in their journals. They know more than me. There needs to be some censorship of the strategy forum or else no one will learn anything. | ||
|
AUGcodon
Canada536 Posts
| ||
|
O-ops
United States4236 Posts
And how is the forum becoming more elitist? What he is weeding out from is the stuff that people can found just by spending time analyzing their own reps (is it really that hard to know you need better macro when you have 1.5k min 15 mins into the game?), the retarded shit that some random guy think is good by winning vs bronze people (i don't go here often, but there's a thread in the bw forum about 10hatch pwn protoss), and threads where people go "derp derp how do i do dis" when there are like 10 threads about that already if they bother to use the search function. In a short version, this is what he did: You don't spend effort into improving your own game, you're banned. You post a guide and it obviously blows ass, you're banned. You don't use the search function, you're banned. Posting is somewhat the same. Some effort and common sense is required. If you're posting, look at this, and worried about posting something too scrubby, you probably are one and you shouldn't post. Save the thread from being flooded with 3 pages of shit posts and 1 liners. Anything wrong with that? Most of game forums out there either do the same shit, or they're dead. Granted, Saracen's punishment is a bit extreme, but Shoryuken.com and diablo.incgamers.com do the same stuff, and they're the biggest site of their respective game. | ||
|
frogmelter
United States971 Posts
If you BM inside of the game, please don't post the replay here for us to analyze I've analyzed replays where the person who posts the replay is like "Oh excuse my bm" and when I watched the replays he flames the entire game People shouldn't bm then turn around and expect us to help them | ||
|
Antisocialmunky
United States5913 Posts
On April 10 2011 05:30 frogmelter wrote: Another rule please If you BM inside of the game, please don't post the replay here for us to analyze I've analyzed replays where the person who posts the replay is like "Oh excuse my bm" and when I watched the replays he flames the entire game People shouldn't bm then turn around and expect us to help them Aren't there tools that can extract chat from Reps? | ||
|
frogmelter
United States971 Posts
On April 10 2011 05:31 Antisocialmunky wrote: Aren't there tools that can extract chat from Reps? Teamliquid promotes manner in games I'm not sure if we can extract chat but I don't think people who bm in game deserve our help These are the complainers... If they complain in game it's more likely that they'll compare out of game/on TL When I analyze games, it takes me a good 20 minutes to write down all the thoughts and timings People that go against the Teamliquid spirit of manner don't deserve such a time commitment | ||
|
O-ops
United States4236 Posts
We have an Idra fanclub so i don't know what you're talking about  | ||
|
frogmelter
United States971 Posts
On April 10 2011 05:41 O-ops wrote: We have an Idra fanclub so i don't know what you're talking about IdrA gets a lot of haters because of his bm but he gets tolerance because he's a progamer and he has earned it. Average joe in masters hasn't It's not an equal place on teamliquid and no one will pretend that it is. | ||
|
O-ops
United States4236 Posts
On April 10 2011 05:53 frogmelter wrote: IdrA gets a lot of haters because of his bm but he gets tolerance because he's a progamer and he has earned it. Average joe in masters hasn't It's not an equal place on teamliquid and no one will pretend that it is. Why so srs lol. Humor likes to get lost on the interwebz or something... | ||
| ||
