[M] (2) IDF District

Asindee

France26 Posts

August 24 2014 11:52 GMT

IDF District

UPLOADED - [EU] [AM]

Hi, this is my third map, I wanted to work on a kind of abandoned station.
I'm not sure about the balance, cause of the lack of good players to test it, so any feedback is welcome. Hope you'll like it.

Overview:

Details:

Spawns :2
Bases: 16 (8m 2g)
Xel Naga Tower: 2
Playable Size: 155x136

Map analysis:

+ Show Spoiler +

Pictures:

+ Show Spoiler +

Meavis

Netherlands1300 Posts

August 24 2014 12:13 GMT

so simple yet so amazing, main looks bit small imo

The_Templar

your Country52798 Posts

August 24 2014 13:57 GMT

Surprisingly solid map. Main concern is that everything seems to be about the same width.

lorestarcraft

United States1049 Posts

August 24 2014 16:45 GMT

Tiniest mains NA

Genome852

United States979 Posts

August 25 2014 00:19 GMT

The diagonal dark metallic textures (e.g. at natural choke) make the overlay a bit visually confusing. Maybe just me.

-NegativeZero-

United States2142 Posts

August 25 2014 02:25 GMT

Nice theme/aesthetics. The huge gap in the center could lead to some weird base-race situations when both players take opposite routes.

Uvantak

Uruguay1381 Posts

August 25 2014 02:41 GMT

I dig it, i fin the fourth bases to be slightly farther away than i would be comfortable with but that shouldn't be much of an issue, the map does have some things that could be problematic tho, such as the vespene positioning in the main bases making it harder for zerg players to get scouting + Show Spoiler +

, or the lack of a reaper cliff into the main base, there is also + Show Spoiler [this] +

, places such as that one can be a pretty good pain in the ass to deal with, they are not inherently "imba" tho, but it is always to have them in mind when creating a map and remove them or leave them be according of how you want the map to play out (be mindful of them).

Regarding the main bases to me they look of a nice size, maybe because i'm moving towards smaller mains for some reason, but yeah i see no problem with them atm.

Oh! And try to use our new, shiny and NewSunshine approved.

[image loading]

Asindee

France26 Posts

August 25 2014 16:50 GMT

First of all, thanks everyone for the feedback, it is much appreciated.
Taking consideration of your remarks, I'm gonna try to add some slight modifications to the map, like add more room to the main and use the "standard mineral placement" (wich is very usefull by the way), and maybe change the awkward spots like those that Uvantak has noticed.

I'm pumped to make a new map now ! Thanks again.

Please or register to reply.

[M] (2) IDF District

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming