• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
TeamLiquid Liquipedia LiquidDota LiquidLegends
EDT 04:25
CEST 10:25
KST 17:25
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Lore of the Nexus: The Angiris Council0DHM Valencia: Power Rank43[TSL9] Prize Pool & Talent18Code S RO10 - Group B, Day 1 Preview (Season 2)7Code S RO10 - Group A, Day 1 Preview (Season 2)11
Community News
2022 AfreecaTV Challengers Starleague Season 210BSL 2v2 ProLeague x ShieldBattery - SIGN UP NOW!14Code S RO10 Groups announced, RO20 final results1ESL Open #128: ByuN, MaxPax, Scarlett win3Artosis to leave Korea after GSL Season 3, possibility of online GSL casts?87
StarCraft 2
General
Vidalista 20mg | Generic Tadalafil: Best ED Cure DHM Valencia: Power Rank Rogue & Trap out for DHM Valencia? Forbidden Ground buildings Shopify TeamLiquid StarLeague 9
Tourneys
DreamHack Masters: Valencia 2022 - Day 1 What Is The Price Of Chillwell Portable AC Reviews [GSL 2022] Code S:Season 2 - Ro10 Group A [NationWars 7] Ro8 thread [Alpha Pro Series] Rogue v TIME
Strategy
Hero's pvz Simple Questions Simple Answers What should I try to work on to improve my TvZ [G] YAKS LOTV: Yet Another hotKey Setup - zerg
Custom Maps
Simple Questions/Answers [A] SC Real Scale
External Content
Mutation # 323 Well Trained Mutation # 322 Warp Zone Mutation # 321 Rise From Ashes Mutation # 320 Retribution
Brood War
General
YellOw wins poker tournament for $696,000 USD Future Cup 4 Under 18 ¿BSL U18? Titan Reactor - Year 2 [Update]ShieldBattery: New Ranked System BW General Discussion
Tourneys
[BSL15] - RO16 Group C - Friday 17:00 CEST [BSL15] - Ro16 Group D - Sunday 17:00 CEST The Casual Games of the Week Thread Artosis vs Gauntlet of the Apes
Strategy
ZvT Guardian Hydra Optimized Strategy before the gosus Project: Strat Update [G] How to get started on ladder as a new Z player
Other Games
General Games
Diablo Immoral The PlayStation 5 Crossfire: Legion - A new RTS combining C&C and SC Final Fantasy XIV Nintendo Switch Thread
Dota 2
Official Dota and Chess General Discussion TL.net migration megathread + LiquidDota archive [DPC 21-22] Tour 3 Discussion/LR LiquidDota to reintegrate into TL.net LiquidDota Site Rules
League of Legends
[Patch 12.7] Arcana Skins Release Discussion LiquidLegends to reintegrate into TL.net [Summer Split] LoL Esports General Discussion [Patch Notes] Release General Discussion
Heroes of the Storm
Lore of the Nexus: The Angiris Council HotS: WP and Funny Moments Mapping Heroes: Battleground Stats Last Flight To Paris: MCC Group Stage
Hearthstone
TL Mafia
British Empire Mini Mafia II TL Mafia Community Thread Chezinu streak(s) Mafia Sengoku Mafia Survivor II: The Amazon
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Coronavirus and You Summer Games Done Quick 2022! Trading/Investing Thread Kashmir - Article 370 revoked
Fan Clubs
Day[9] Fan Club soO Fan Club Zest Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! [TV] HBO Game of Thrones Korean Music Discussion [Manga] One Piece [Manga] Berserk
Sports
2021 - 2022 Football Thread 2021 NFL/CFB Season NBA General Discussion Formula 1 Discussion McBoner: A hockey love story
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread The Ultimate Mouse Thread Simple Questions Simple Answers
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
On Radicalization and S…
plasmidghost
Bravery and cowardice…
Starlightsun
My daughter wants to pla…
JoinTheRain
On gun violence in America…
MrBitter
First time having "S*X".
Garnet
Gomorrah
Broodwar4lyf
Getting Back to it..!.20 years…
FuDDx
Age
AmericanUmlaut
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1046 users

[D]Mapmaking Skill

Forum Index > SC2 Maps & Custom Games
Post a Reply
neobowman
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
Canada3324 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-06 22:10:01
February 06 2012 22:08 GMT
#1
I'll try to keep this short. How successful I will be, no one knows.

I often relate mapping Starcraft maps to actually playing the game. Not only is there a huge correlation between the two skillsets (for example, Morrow was a great mapper in BW, and despite not being able to devote as much time to mapping in SC2, he still churns out amazing concepts), but there are so many misconceptions that people starting out tend to make. Simply said, some people tend to make maps trying to use unique ideas without understanding the basics.

Quite often, a player new to Starcraft will try to make a new strategy. For example, they'll go carrier rush every game. The problem with this is that they obviously lack the basic foundation to even start getting good with this build. Instead of working on the foundation of their play, they'll instantly try to do something cool and unique. This does not work out. In iloveoov's recent interview, he said this.

On December 18 2011 12:32 iloveoov wrote:
The process of instructing players only becomes fun once they reach a certain skill level. Without a good foundation, they won't be able to execute a strategy, and even if they do by accident, it's building a castle on sand. I would say players that are at least a 3 out of 5 in terms of skill are the ones that are capable of discussing a strategy and bringing improvement to both sides.


Now, remember, he's talking about the best of the best. These are professional level Starcraft players. If they played SC2, they'd be in Korean Grandmasters. And he says only the top 60% of these players can discuss strategies with him while getting something out of it. This may be somewhat of an exaggeration. As BW is so refined and perfected, it's increasingly harder to come up with new strategies and mechanics become more important than strategizing. In SC2, new strategies are still popping up every other month. Nonetheless, we can, or rather, we have to apply this to mapping.

Sometimes I read posts on map competitions. They claim they made their maps featuring unique concepts and it was rejected, supposedly because it was too unique and only the standard maps ever get chosen.

I'm not going to mince my words here. The reason the map was rejected was not because it had a far too crazy concept, but because the map was terrible.

New mappers often try to create crazy map concepts they thought up of while playing the game. Like the carrier rush example I gave earlier, this often ends up in complete failure because you do not have the proper foundations to do this. The reason you do not see the concepts that you thought up of in the maps that the best mappers make, is not because they are too standard. It's because, like the carrier rush, it's a silly idea that has a 99% chance of failing miserably in any competitive map. The problem isn't only a lack of testing available, it's that the concept is stupid.

As a whole, we're already pushing boundaries with our generation of maps. We're finding out what works and what doesn't. For example, Testbug obviously worked out rather badly. And that was a relatively standard macro map. It's far too early to start working with Plasmas and Battle Royales of Starcraft 2.

I'm getting off topic here but It's not that map contest organizers are somehow biased against non-team affiliated mappers. It's just that the best mappers happen to be on teams.

Btw, don't get depressed. Keep posting maps on TL and you'll keep getting advice. If you ever need advice on one of your own maps, feel free to PM me. I'll respond. Just don't expect me to honey up my words if I feel it can do with a lot of improvement. Don't worry. My first maps were trash too.

+ Show Spoiler [If you really want to see] +
panschk.de/mappage/(2)Beta(n).JPG
SigmaFiE
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
United States333 Posts
February 06 2012 22:28 GMT
#2
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?
https://johnemerson.artstation.com/
prodiG
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
Canada2016 Posts
February 06 2012 22:52 GMT
#3
And now presenting Real Talk with Neobowman! :D
ESV Mapmaking Team || http://twitter.com/prodiGsc || Real talk, I don't have time to sugar-coat it for you sir
Koagel
Profile Joined October 2010
Austria167 Posts
February 06 2012 23:00 GMT
#4
On February 07 2012 07:28 SigmaFiE wrote:
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?


Show your worth, then ask or get asked.
Icetoad
Profile Joined May 2010
Canada262 Posts
February 06 2012 23:09 GMT
#5
On February 07 2012 07:28 SigmaFiE wrote:
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?

Normally, to get picked up by a team is to show great potential. When I was the team leader of MCL, we would invite map makers that we felt had great talent and showed maps that became better and better.
Map Maker of Nimbus
Ragoo
Profile Joined March 2010
Germany2773 Posts
February 06 2012 23:20 GMT
#6
On February 07 2012 07:28 SigmaFiE wrote:
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?


Make like 3 good maps and we will start talking about you and maybe try to contact you about joining. There isn't rly any other way.
If you are just rly desperate to get more feedback for maps and discuss stuff with other mapmakers, there's a skype channel with 90% of the best mapmakers in it that basically "anyone" can join if they ask.

And lol@ neobowman. These things definitely had to be said and I agree 100% with you.
But man I'm always terrified when I see you commented on a map of mine. You are not mincing words :D
Member of TPW mapmaking team/// twitter.com/Ragoo_ /// "goody represents border between explainable reason and supernatural" Cloud
SigmaFiE
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
United States333 Posts
February 06 2012 23:26 GMT
#7
On February 07 2012 08:20 Ragoo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 07 2012 07:28 SigmaFiE wrote:
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?


Make like 3 good maps and we will start talking about you and maybe try to contact you about joining. There isn't rly any other way.


Thanks for not mincing words on the process Ragoo!
https://johnemerson.artstation.com/
SidianTheBard
Profile Joined October 2010
United States2469 Posts
February 06 2012 23:29 GMT
#8
On February 07 2012 07:08 neobowman wrote:
I'm not going to mince my words here. The reason the map was rejected was not because it had a far too crazy concept, but because the map was terrible.

New mappers often try to create crazy map concepts they thought up of while playing the game. Like the carrier rush example I gave earlier, this often ends up in complete failure because you do not have the proper foundations to do this. The reason you do not see the concepts that you thought up of in the maps that the best mappers make, is not because they are too standard. It's because, like the carrier rush, it's a silly idea that has a 99% chance of failing miserably in any competitive map. The problem isn't only a lack of testing available, it's that the concept is stupid.



Could not agree with this more.

I don't think Neo has ever commented on one of my maps, whether that's good or bad, I will never know.
Creator of Abyssal Reef, Ascension to Aiur, Battle on the Boardwalk, Habitation Station, Honorgrounds, IPL Darkness Falls, King's Cove, Korhal Carnage Knockout & Moonlight Madness.
neobowman
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
Canada3324 Posts
February 06 2012 23:30 GMT
#9
On February 07 2012 08:20 Ragoo wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 07 2012 07:28 SigmaFiE wrote:
Since you made mention of it -- how does one go about becoming part of a map making team? This has always perplexed me (aside from winning a mapping competition and being picked up). Would it be the same as say applying for a job and having a resume ready to be given and judged by the potential employer?


Make like 3 good maps and we will start talking about you and maybe try to contact you about joining. There isn't rly any other way.
If you are just rly desperate to get more feedback for maps and discuss stuff with other mapmakers, there's a skype channel with 90% of the best mapmakers in it that basically "anyone" can join if they ask.

And lol@ neobowman. These things definitely had to be said and I agree 100% with you.
But man I'm always terrified when I see you commented on a map of mine. You are not mincing words :D

I'm harsh because I luv you.

On February 07 2012 08:29 SidianTheBard wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 07 2012 07:08 neobowman wrote:
I'm not going to mince my words here. The reason the map was rejected was not because it had a far too crazy concept, but because the map was terrible.

New mappers often try to create crazy map concepts they thought up of while playing the game. Like the carrier rush example I gave earlier, this often ends up in complete failure because you do not have the proper foundations to do this. The reason you do not see the concepts that you thought up of in the maps that the best mappers make, is not because they are too standard. It's because, like the carrier rush, it's a silly idea that has a 99% chance of failing miserably in any competitive map. The problem isn't only a lack of testing available, it's that the concept is stupid.



Could not agree with this more.

I don't think Neo has ever commented on one of my maps, whether that's good or bad, I will never know.

Haha, do you wish to know?
RumbleBadger
Profile Joined July 2011
322 Posts
February 07 2012 01:28 GMT
#10
I agree. It wasn't until I think monitor came into one of my maps and basically told me why it sucked that I really understood even how to go about improving.

Mincing words is not beneficial at any level of map making skill.
Games before dames.
FlopTurnReaver
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
Switzerland1979 Posts
February 07 2012 01:35 GMT
#11
Well thank you for this, from now on I can just link to this thread^^

Maybe people will at least believe you
Check out @MapOfTheMonth on Twitter and under http://bit.ly/motmorg
monitor
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
United States2393 Posts
February 07 2012 01:37 GMT
#12
On February 07 2012 10:28 RumbleBadger wrote:
I agree. It wasn't until I think monitor came into one of my maps and basically told me why it sucked that I really understood even how to go about improving.

Mincing words is not beneficial at any level of map making skill.


Haha thanks <3. I think my older map feedback was quite questionable (sorry), but at least it gave the right idea to how to improve. And you certainly are!!
EatThePath
Profile Blog Joined September 2009
United States3943 Posts
February 07 2012 02:52 GMT
#13
This doesn't really have anything to do with mapping, it's just a truism about anything that involves expertise. It's impossible to make an impression on the inculcated without meeting their standards.

I'm not trying to drag you down neo, it's a fine post.

I didn't realize this was a pressing issue? Charlatans will be charlatans. And nobody will give them a break until it's proved they had a point--perhaps by accident. No harm in it.
Comprehensive strategic intention: DNE
Barrin
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States5002 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-07 04:32:41
February 07 2012 03:17 GMT
#14
Much of what you said overlaps with some of what I said here :o
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=306101

-

Indeed, almost all of the best mapmakers just happen to be on teams.
Grandfather of LotV's resource model. "Fewer Resources per Base"
wrl
Profile Joined April 2011
United States209 Posts
February 07 2012 04:01 GMT
#15
You had the opportunity to make a quality post here, Neo. Instead you just sound like an elitist jackass.

------

If you aren't part of a team, but aspire to produce great maps the best thing you can do is ask for more opinions and to be as humble as possible. A great example I can make is ArcticRaven. He was driven to keep asking for feedback and he built upon it and Aquamarine went from being a totally garbage map to something a lot closer to being good. Not that it would win any tournaments, but it certainly showcased how quickly one can grow as a mapmaker.

In my case, I wasn't exceptionally driven to grow as a mapmaker and I was too egotistical to directly seek out more experienced mapmaker's opinions. As a result it took a LOT of maps for me to produce a few good enough to be considered to join a team.

If you want more feedback than just the quick snippit from a MotM judge, I'd recommend PMing a mapmaker you like the style of and asking for some feedback. Be humble, listen, and focus on learning and producing newer, greater maps (instead of trying to perfect the one you are working on). Most of us would be flattered to have you directly request our opinion.

The members of ESV/TPW/Crux aren't perfect, and we weren't born as great mapmakers. We all have strengths and weaknesses and we focus on trying to work on the things that may be holding some of our maps back.
It's funny; I dream a lot, but I'm not a very good sleeper.
neobowman
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
Canada3324 Posts
February 07 2012 04:08 GMT
#16
On February 07 2012 13:01 wrl wrote:
You had the opportunity to make a quality post here, Neo. Instead you just sound like an elitist jackass.

------

If you aren't part of a team, but aspire to produce great maps the best thing you can do is ask for more opinions and to be as humble as possible. A great example I can make is ArcticRaven. He was driven to keep asking for feedback and he built upon it and Aquamarine went from being a totally garbage map to something a lot closer to being good. Not that it would win any tournaments, but it certainly showcased how quickly one can grow as a mapmaker.

In my case, I wasn't exceptionally driven to grow as a mapmaker and I was too egotistical to directly seek out more experienced mapmaker's opinions. As a result it took a LOT of maps for me to produce a few good enough to be considered to join a team.

If you want more feedback than just the quick snippit from a MotM judge, I'd recommend PMing a mapmaker you like the style of and asking for some feedback. Be humble, listen, and focus on learning and producing newer, greater maps (instead of trying to perfect the one you are working on). Most of us would be flattered to have you directly request our opinion.

The members of ESV/TPW/Crux aren't perfect, and we weren't born as great mapmakers. We all have strengths and weaknesses and we focus on trying to work on the things that may be holding some of our maps back.


I have no idea how your post contradicts anything I said.
wrl
Profile Joined April 2011
United States209 Posts
February 07 2012 04:09 GMT
#17
It doesn't. I just think you could have used more tact. Why try and alienate people who aren't on mapmaking teams even further?
It's funny; I dream a lot, but I'm not a very good sleeper.
neobowman
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
Canada3324 Posts
February 07 2012 04:19 GMT
#18
I may have gotten overly passionate about a certain group of people who may not represent the whole demographic. I mention in the end not to get depressed but I should have emphasized that part more. My bad.
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
ESL Pro Tour
08:00
DH Valencia 2022 - Day 2
ESL.tv2032
Esl_sc22032
IndyStarCraft 1086
ALGaming 572
ESL_sc2b559
TaKeTV 412
Crank 282
Maincast Studio 189
ESL_sc2c138
OGamingTV SC2 136
ESL118
HorussTv 43
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
IndyStarCraft 1086
Crank 282
ROOTSuperNova 210
ProTech63
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 16518
Horang2 3543
PianO 740
ToSsGirL 226
Leta 218
ggaemo 181
Shuttle 140
scan(afreeca) 92
Shinee 89
Terrorterran 72
[ Show more ]
sSak 53
zelot 53
CadenZie 21
Jumperer 16
Beast 8
Dota 2
resolut1ontv 1278
Attackerdota845
XcaliburYe549
XaKoH 545
febbydoto130
Super Smash Bros
Westballz51
Other Games
tarik_tv22196
summit1g21698
singsing1661
WinterStarcraft572
m0e_tv394
Livibee319
mouzStarbuck120
KnowMe58
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick64723
Dota 2
BeyondTheSummit17991
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO266
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
[ Show 19 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Bosshoore 2
• Gussbus
• Laughngamez YouTube
• Poblha
• Alpha X_
• aXEnki
• Migwel
• intothetv
• CSOeSports
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamez Trovo
StarCraft: Brood War
• sscaitournament1
• STPLYoutube
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV1476
League of Legends
• Rush9241
• Stunt386
Upcoming Events
DPC 2021/2022 Tour 3
1h 35m
Team Bald Reborn vs Nigma
OG vs TBD
CSO Contender
7h 35m
DPC 2021/2022 Tour 3
10h 35m
Evil Geniuses vs TBD
ESL Pro Tour
18h 35m
ESL Pro Tour
23h 35m
Ultimate Battle
1d 2h
Soulkey vs Rush
BSL: ProLeague
1d 6h
ESL Pro Tour
2 days
ESL Pro Tour
2 days
DPC 2021/2022 Tour 3
3 days
Evil Geniuses vs TBD
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Endless Battle 3: Mihu vs KuKu
DHM Valencia: EU
PSISTORM HC 2022
Roobet Cup

Ongoing

BSL Season 15: GosuLeague
STL37
RCG 2021
KCM Ladies Race Survival 2022 Season 2
Nine-Tathlon Invitational
HoneyCai Friendlies Season 4
GAN Race Survival Season 4
CWCL Season 4
FS Mania
Big Baby Popularity Contest
KCM Race Survival 2022 Season 2
BSL Season 15
TOP Challenge Qualifier
2022 ACS Season 2: Qualifier
Deathfate Pro Team League
WTL 2022 Summer
2022 GSL S2: Code S
StarCraft II: NationWars 7
DH Masters Valencia
Community Clash League S4
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Quals.
Masters Clash Champ. 2022
ESL Challenger Valencia 2022

Upcoming

BSL Season 15: HasuLeague
Future Cup 4 (U18)
Luck Over Strength
TOP Challenge
2022 ACS Season 2
WSL Season 3
Ultimate Battle: Soulkey vs Rush
2022 GSL: ST 2
DH Masters Atlanta
2022 GSL S3: Code S
TSL 9
HomeStory Cup XXI
X-Cup Summer 2022
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 7
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 6
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 5
IEM Rio Major 2022
ESL Challenger Melbourne 2022
ESL Pro League Season 16
BLAST Premier Fall Groups
ESL Challenger League S42 NA
ESL Challenger League S42 EU
ESL Challenger League S42 AP
IEM Cologne 2022
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2022 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.