• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
TeamLiquid Liquipedia LiquidDota LiquidLegends
EDT 19:02
CEST 01:02
KST 08:02
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[BSL15] Ro16 Recap Pt.13Lore of the Nexus: The Angiris Council0DHM Valencia: Power Rank52[TSL9] Prize Pool & Talent18Code S RO10 - Group B, Day 1 Preview (Season 2)7
Community News
2022 AfreecaTV Challengers Starleague Season 211BSL 2v2 ProLeague x ShieldBattery - SIGN UP NOW!14Code S RO10 Groups announced, RO20 final results1ESL Open #128: ByuN, MaxPax, Scarlett win3Artosis to leave Korea after GSL Season 3, possibility of online GSL casts?87
StarCraft 2
General
Rogue & Trap out for DHM Valencia? Doublelift on State of SC2 and the Various Regions Zest Retires Forbidden Ground buildings DHM Valencia: Power Rank
Tourneys
DreamHack Masters: Valencia 2022 - Main Event [TSL 9] Qualifiers HSC XXI Qualifiers [GSL 2022] Code S:Season 2 - Ro10 Group A ProBots 2022 Season 2
Strategy
herO's PvZ Simple Questions Simple Answers What should I try to work on to improve my TvZ [G] YAKS LOTV: Yet Another hotKey Setup - zerg
Custom Maps
Simple Questions/Answers [A] SC Real Scale
External Content
Mutation # 324 Violent Night Mutation # 323 Well Trained Mutation # 322 Warp Zone Mutation # 321 Rise From Ashes
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion repmastered.app: replay sharing and analyzer site BGH auto balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ [BSL15] Ro16 Recap Pt.1 YellOw wins poker tournament for $696,000 USD
Tourneys
Hawk vs Artosis Show match July 6th 50$ prize pool No-Worries League - Similar-Skill Match-Making Deathfate Pro Team League 2 Announcement [BSL15] - RO16 Group C - Friday 17:00 CEST
Strategy
A new RTS map for scbw Project: Strat Update ZvT Guardian Hydra Optimized Strategy before the gosus
Other Games
General Games
Path of Exile Final Fantasy XIV Diablo Immoral The PlayStation 5 Crossfire: Legion - A new RTS combining C&C and SC
Dota 2
[DPC 21-22] Tour 3 Discussion/LR Official Dota and Chess General Discussion TL.net migration megathread + LiquidDota archive LiquidDota to reintegrate into TL.net LiquidDota Site Rules
League of Legends
[Patch 12.7] Arcana Skins Release Discussion LiquidLegends to reintegrate into TL.net [Summer Split] LoL Esports General Discussion [Patch Notes] Release General Discussion
Heroes of the Storm
HotS: WP and Funny Moments Lore of the Nexus: The Angiris Council Mapping Heroes: Battleground Stats
Hearthstone
TL Mafia
British Empire Mini Mafia II TL Mafia Community Thread Chezinu streak(s) Mafia Sengoku Mafia Survivor II: The Amazon
Community
General
Russo-Ukrainian War Thread US Politics Mega-thread NASA and the Private Sector If you're seeing this topic then another mass shooting happened and people disagree on what to do The Games Industry And ATVI
Fan Clubs
Day[9] Fan Club soO Fan Club Zest Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread Korean Music Discussion Movie Discussion! [TV] HBO Game of Thrones [Manga] One Piece
Sports
2021 - 2022 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion NBA General Discussion 2021 NFL/CFB Season McBoner: A hockey love story
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread Starcraft 2 No longer going on top of Start Bar The Ultimate Mouse Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Helping
ChristianS
On Radicalization and S…
plasmidghost
Bravery and cowardice…
Starlightsun
My daughter wants to pla…
JoinTheRain
On gun violence in America…
MrBitter
First time having "S*X".
Garnet
Gomorrah
Broodwar4lyf
Getting Back to it..!.20 years…
FuDDx
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1340 users

[D] Intellectual Ownership of your maps v.s. Blizzard

Forum Index > SC2 Maps & Custom Games
Post a Reply
1 2 Next All
Tassadar_UK
Profile Joined May 2011
United Kingdom5 Posts
August 05 2011 19:44 GMT
#1
A few days ago ~1st August there was a new EULA for starcraft 2.
(incorrectly dated 11th June if i remember correctly)

What im NOT going to do is mention roughly 14 legal flaws/loopholes i meticulously noted in the document. (not just with new stuff, but all of it)

What i AM going to do, is flag up a legal flaw with one of the new parts of the EULA, relating to ownership of custom maps.

Paraphase:
"Maps made through the use of the map editor are no longer intellectual property of the creator, but the sole property of Blizzard. This applies retrospectively to all previously made maps, once the new agreement is accepted.
The new agreement is automatically accepted without user consent, on 1st September (30 days after change), unless the user specifically deletes sc2, and sends a mail to blizzard france. The new eula is automatically accepted without user concent Regardless of whether the user clicks the Reject button upon seeing it - the previous steps of IRL mail must be followed to reject."

What i will be addressing are fundamental concepts of contract, something which may be over the heads of users who spent 2005-2009 using only Mutalisks and Reavers, under the impression they were 'playing brood war'.


1) a EULA is not a contract. a contract must be signed in person, and blizzard must know your real name. even the paypal 'contract' which had a box to fill in your name, and which deals with real money, is not a genuine contract; which is why they shy away from fighting legal action if push comes to shove.
"License Agreement" and "Terms of Use" are both EULAs.

2) the DMCA says that any content which is a re-arrangement of other peoples copyrighted content, becomes jointly-owned by the copyright holders AND the re-arranger - with both parties needing to agree on the re-arranged object's usage, before it can be used for anything. The re-arragement must however be 'not trivial', otherwise the above ownership-grantage doesnt apply.

3) the power of a EULA is extremely LIMITED. a EULA can do only 2 things:
a) Give the purchaser of the EULA (when you buy sc2 you are infact purchasing a EULA) an extremely-temporary super-limited right to play the game/make maps.
b) Give blizzard the power to revoke the EULA you purchased, without giving your money back, for an enormous host of reasons. Infact without any reason at all, due to point 4) below.

4) part of the EULA states the EULA can be changed at any time, and that (as stated at the start of this post) you must accept it to continue playing/making maps, and that you automatically accept it unless you go to extreme lengths to reject it. blizztard can therefore change the EULA to read that it can revoke your EULA for no reason - and thus they gain the power to do so. [They could also make it more interesting, by saying everyone who isnt able to juggle while riding a unicycle is banned. There is no theoretical limit to what they can put in it with this 'changes' rule.]

5) point 5 is once again reminding you of point 3). Blizzard can put anything in the EULA that they like, but a EULA does NOT have the power to do anything except 3a) and 3b), regardless of what is put in it. This is because it is NOT a contract.

6) point 6 is a side point about real contracts. not even real contracts are criminally-binding, only civily-binding. you can't go to prison for violating a contract in itself, although chances are you broke another law too so your going anyway ^_^.

7) Under numerous standard/common/old laws: ownership of something you initially own, or would otherwise own if not for a mitigating reason making you not own it.. can ONLY be given away to someone else if you sign a _C_O_N_T_R_A_C_T_ stating you are giving that ownership away.

8) Blizzards new eula says they now own every map you ever made and ever will make. Unfortunately for blizzard, a EULA is NOT a contract - and as such does not have the power to allow you to give away your ownership. Thus the DMCA's rule still stands.
As a result, you are still a shared-owner of your map.

I'll say that last bit again.

You are STILL a SHARED-OWNER of your map!

Blizzards latest EULA is legally incapable of removing this ownership.


But obviously, as repeatedly implied.. blizzard is also a shared owner too, and you can never take that away from them either

So you are copyright partners with blizzard, and they cant sell your map on their new 'Marketplace' without your concent.
TubeZ
Profile Joined July 2011
28 Posts
August 05 2011 19:56 GMT
#2
Nice find!
@blizz;


User was warned for this post
Snaphoo
Profile Joined July 2010
United States614 Posts
August 05 2011 20:07 GMT
#3
StarCraft and How I Met Your Mother in the same thread? I think I'm in heaven.
Asday
Profile Joined November 2010
United Kingdom388 Posts
August 05 2011 20:56 GMT
#4
Fuck himym.

Thanks for the redux, Tassadar, I actually put both my projects on hiatus on reading the new EULA. Nice to know Blizz can go fall on a sharp dick.
weareallclowns
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
Denmark113 Posts
August 05 2011 21:03 GMT
#5
Yea, nice find. Reminds me of that time, when blizzard tried to stop the selling of a WoW guide (which got immensely popular; source) made by some kid. They are a cooperation like any other.
we are all co-authoring a gigantic Dostoevsky novel, starring clowns! - T. Levitch
Jetaap
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
France4814 Posts
August 05 2011 21:06 GMT
#6
Wasn't it already the case ? What was the EULA before that?
Birdie
Profile Blog Joined August 2007
New Zealand4438 Posts
August 05 2011 21:26 GMT
#7
Blizzard cannot prove you ever agreed to their EULA. Just say your mother agreed to to the EULA, not you. You then used it but never agreed to their EULA.
Red classic | A butterfly dreamed he was Zhuangzi | 4.5k, heading to 5k as support!
Barrin
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States5002 Posts
August 05 2011 21:26 GMT
#8
Blizzard (*cough*Bobby Kotick*cough*), I am disappointed.

I love you guys, but I really wish you would step it down a few notches on the greed factor
Grandfather of LotV's resource model. "Fewer Resources per Base"
monitor
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
United States2393 Posts
August 05 2011 21:28 GMT
#9
On August 06 2011 06:26 zany_001 wrote:
Blizzard cannot prove you ever agreed to their EULA. Just say your mother agreed to to the EULA, not you. You then used it but never agreed to their EULA.


Well no, because your account is associated with you. You're responsible for anything that happens on your account, I assume.

This is a really interesting point, I'm surprised that they are so ambitious (greedy, as Barrin says) to control everything. I'm glad that they don't!
fezvez
Profile Blog Joined January 2011
France3021 Posts
August 05 2011 21:31 GMT
#10
Thank you very much dear sir!

It reminds me how Facebook tried to force the fact that every bit of content on facebook belonged to them and not to their users. I believe they had to back off because of the angry reaction from the users.

Don't take it personnaly, but I would like to know if someone else, knowledgeable in this area, can confirm your affirmations.

Anyway, thanks for sharing it with us!
Barrin
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States5002 Posts
August 05 2011 21:37 GMT
#11
On August 06 2011 06:31 fezvez wrote:
Thank you very much dear sir!

It reminds me how Facebook tried to force the fact that every bit of content on facebook belonged to them and not to their users. I believe they had to back off because of the angry reaction from the users.

Don't take it personnaly, but I would like to know if someone else, knowledgeable in this area, can confirm your affirmations.

Anyway, thanks for sharing it with us!

The real problem is that this kind of thing is becoming more and more typical of Blizzard. I honestly do not doubt the validity of the OP for a second. Wouldn't argue with further confirmation though :D
Grandfather of LotV's resource model. "Fewer Resources per Base"
FoxyMayhem
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
624 Posts
August 05 2011 21:55 GMT
#12
<3s for posting. We folk really benefit from an interpreter of legalese.
TheStonerer
Profile Joined June 2011
Canada278 Posts
August 05 2011 21:55 GMT
#13
First, how did you find this, did you read the EULA completely twice? Second, If it was clearly written, why did you have to paraphrase?

Don't want to be a dick, but this sounds like you're making things up. If you could bring proof instead of affirmations, would be great.
LunaSaint
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United Kingdom620 Posts
August 05 2011 21:56 GMT
#14
Aren't most of these just meant to be catch-all tags that prevent any wierd legal action being taken care of anyway?

Either way, I'm glad the DMCA takes priority.
fezvez
Profile Blog Joined January 2011
France3021 Posts
August 05 2011 22:06 GMT
#15
On August 06 2011 06:37 Barrin wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 06:31 fezvez wrote:
Thank you very much dear sir!

It reminds me how Facebook tried to force the fact that every bit of content on facebook belonged to them and not to their users. I believe they had to back off because of the angry reaction from the users.

Don't take it personnaly, but I would like to know if someone else, knowledgeable in this area, can confirm your affirmations.

Anyway, thanks for sharing it with us!

The real problem is that this kind of thing is becoming more and more typical of Blizzard. I honestly do not doubt the validity of the OP for a second. Wouldn't argue with further confirmation though :D


In fact, I'm absolutely not putting into question what the OP said about Blizzard (which you can sum up in one word : "greedy")

No, I'm asking whether his conclusions about being co-owner are grounded. Because there are some legal things, and in this field, I have no clue at all.

I mean, he could've said "They said bla-bla-bla in their EULA, and because of law XXX, then you can't have a friend watching you play if he does not own a copy of SC2". (this is just an example!) What I ask for is for someone else to confirm the "because/then" part that the map authors are still co-owners of their creations.
MavercK
Profile Joined March 2010
Australia2181 Posts
August 06 2011 07:26 GMT
#16
i feel like this whole ownership based off the eula was bullshit anyway
obviously they can't take your map without your permission and sell it. eula would not stop a courtroom ruling in your favor.

but.
i think it's more of a ... safety net for themselves.
i feel like they could basically steal/take/use anything from a custom map and claim it as their own. ideas, functions etc.

i'm betting Blizzard are pissed about their missed oppurtunity with DotA 2.
blizzard dota is going to be shockingly average at best.
i think it's just permission to rip off your content basically. i dunno..
Brood War Remake - SC2BW - http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=145316
MavercK
Profile Joined March 2010
Australia2181 Posts
August 06 2011 07:30 GMT
#17
On August 06 2011 07:06 fezvez wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2011 06:37 Barrin wrote:
On August 06 2011 06:31 fezvez wrote:
Thank you very much dear sir!

It reminds me how Facebook tried to force the fact that every bit of content on facebook belonged to them and not to their users. I believe they had to back off because of the angry reaction from the users.

Don't take it personnaly, but I would like to know if someone else, knowledgeable in this area, can confirm your affirmations.

Anyway, thanks for sharing it with us!

The real problem is that this kind of thing is becoming more and more typical of Blizzard. I honestly do not doubt the validity of the OP for a second. Wouldn't argue with further confirmation though :D


In fact, I'm absolutely not putting into question what the OP said about Blizzard (which you can sum up in one word : "greedy")

No, I'm asking whether his conclusions about being co-owner are grounded. Because there are some legal things, and in this field, I have no clue at all.

I mean, he could've said "They said bla-bla-bla in their EULA, and because of law XXX, then you can't have a friend watching you play if he does not own a copy of SC2". (this is just an example!) What I ask for is for someone else to confirm the "because/then" part that the map authors are still co-owners of their creations.


a EULA wont hold up in court as i understand. like i said in my other post im pretty sure it's just a safety net for the company "you can't complain about being banned because you agreed not to hack" sort of thing.
but to actually claim ownership of something you've created. even if you used their tools. i dont think a EULA holds that type of power.
Brood War Remake - SC2BW - http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=145316
Vagabond
Profile Joined April 2011
Scotland149 Posts
August 06 2011 07:54 GMT
#18
This has been in the EULA for WoW since it started, it might even be in the SC &BW EULA. it just away to stop people making cash off thier stuff. then again i don't know how it will work when the bring in the SC2 marketplace if that ever takes off.
Drone untill i die.
mavsfan0041
Profile Joined February 2011
United States306 Posts
August 06 2011 08:02 GMT
#19
The thing is, and maybe I'm just cynical, that what's to stop Blizzard from just taking your maps anyways regardless of whether the EULA is legally binding or not? I mean they're the multi-billion dollar company with expensive lawyers. And odds are the map maker isn't going to go to war with Blizzard for the relatively small amount of money compared to the cost of what would surely be a drawn out court battle.
R.I.P. CheckSix
TheAmazombie
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
United States3714 Posts
August 06 2011 08:05 GMT
#20
So, OP, it says here that you are in the UK. Does all of this stand true between US, UK, Europe, or wherever?
The other side of this is a problem that we have in US quite a bit with large companies. Sometimes they do stupid crap like this to get people to believe that their rights are torn, but let's say Blizzard decides to "sell" your maps without your consent. In order for you to get anything from that you would need to file a complaint and possibly legally sue them. A lot of people, even ones who know these legal loopholes, might not have the means (money or pro-bono help) to actually get anything done, and even if they do, will it be worth it monetarily to do so?

Because of these limitations, a lot of people and companies get away with stupid crap just because most people cannot force the issue, and the ones who do they just make a quiet settlement with.

I hate when someone gives you a tool of creation then tries to claim all rights to those creations. I understand if it is a work for pay or contracted job where you are willingly giving away your creations, but in cases like this EULA, it is just greedy it seems, not to mention insulting to those who can see through this crap.
We think too much and feel too little. More than machinery, we need humanity. More than cleverness, we need kindness and gentleness. Without these qualities, life will be violent and all will be lost. -Charlie Chaplin
1 2 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
ESL Pro Tour
23:00
Americas Open Open Cup #130
SteadfastSC409
rockletztv 32
Golden0
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
JimRising 614
Nathanias 457
UpATree 162
Forgg! 146
RotterdaM 78
NeuroSwarm 59
Golden 0
StarCraft: Brood War
Shuttle 2390
Jaeyun 152
Shinee 82
Terrorterran 41
yabsab 23
IntoTheRainbow 8
Dota 2
qojqva7393
Super Smash Bros
hungrybox2562
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu691
Other Games
shahzam4950
Grubby2600
byalli469
HitmanStarcraft2130
febbydoto35
ROOTCatZ25
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick6457
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO387
Dota 2
BeyondTheSummit248
StarCraft 2
OGamingTV SC2 126
Other Games
BasetradeTV73
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
[ Show 21 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• musti20045 35
• Adnapsc2 16
• Gussbus
• Migwel
• Alpha X_
• aXEnki
• Poblha
• intothetv
• CSOeSports
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamez Trovo
• Laughngamez YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
• sscaitournament3
• STPLYoutube
• BSLYoutube
• AfreecaTV YouTube
League of Legends
• Froggen1975
• smoothie143
Other Games
• imaqtpie2118
• Shiphtur1315
Upcoming Events
KCM Race Survival
10h 58m
DPC 2021/2022 Tour 3
19h 58m
Evil Geniuses vs TBD
OSC
20h 58m
TeamLiquid StarLeague
1d 11h
TeamLiquid StarLeague
2 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
3 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
4 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
4 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
4 days
ESL Pro Tour
5 days
[ Show More ]
TeamLiquid StarLeague
5 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
5 days
TeamLiquid StarLeague
5 days
ESL Pro Tour
6 days
ESL Pro Tour
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

2022 ACS Season 2: Qualifier
DH Masters Valencia
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 5
ESL Challenger Valencia 2022

Ongoing

BSL Season 15: GosuLeague
Luck Over Strength
STL37
RCG 2021
KCM Ladies Race Survival 2022 Season 2
Nine-Tathlon Invitational
HoneyCai Friendlies Season 4
GAN Race Survival Season 4
CWCL Season 4
FS Mania
Big Baby Popularity Contest
KCM Race Survival 2022 Season 2
BSL Season 15
Deathfate Pro Team League
TOP Challenge Qualifier
WTL 2022 Summer
2022 GSL S2: Code S
StarCraft II: NationWars 7
Community Clash League S4
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Quals.
Masters Clash Champ. 2022

Upcoming

Deathfate Pro Team League 2: Qualifier
Future Cup 4 (U18)
NiuPi Cup CN vs KR 1: Mihu vs Mighty
TOP Challenge
2022 ACS Season 2
NiuPi Cup 7: Soma vs sOrry
WSL Season 3
IEM Katowice 2023
2022 GSL: ST 2
DH Masters Atlanta
2022 GSL S3: Code S
TSL 9
HomeStory Cup XXI
X-Cup Summer 2022
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 10
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 9
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 8
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 7
X-Cup Summer 2022 - Qual. 6
IEM Rio Major 2022
ESL Challenger Melbourne 2022
ESL Pro League Season 16
BLAST Premier Fall Groups
ESL Challenger League S42 NA
ESL Challenger League S42 EU
ESL Challenger League S42 AP
IEM Cologne 2022
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2022 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.