| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
Black Gun
Germany4482 Posts
On January 01 2011 15:07 Tempest[OEC] wrote: Bisu's PvT is very cut and dry. He produces results but not as much flair as Stork's imo. Idk its subject to opinion I guess. just like stork has a natural feeling for pvt, bisu has a natural feeling for pvz. bisu is obviously lacking the same understanding of pvt, and storks pvz is always a really nerve-wrecking chaos.... | ||
|
baubo
China3370 Posts
On January 01 2011 15:07 Tempest[OEC] wrote: Bisu's PvT is very cut and dry. He produces results but not as much flair as Stork's imo. Idk its subject to opinion I guess. But he doesn't. He consistently gets kicked out of starleagues by losing to various terrans. While whenever Stork sees terran in BoX, it usually ends ridiculously one-sided in Stork's favor. Bisu has good PvT record because he kills terrans in the proleague. But when his opponent prepares against him, he becomes a lot less awesome at it. | ||
|
night terrors
China1284 Posts
| ||
|
Black Gun
Germany4482 Posts
On January 01 2011 15:34 baubo wrote: But he doesn't. He consistently gets kicked out of starleagues by losing to various terrans. While whenever Stork sees terran in BoX, it usually ends ridiculously one-sided in Stork's favor. i just looked it up: stork has lost the following BoX series against terran: to mvp in gom classic season 3 in 09 to flash in bacchus osl in 08 to flash in the gsi finals in 08 (flash had just invented his double armory build at that time and was stomping stork with a build which he couldnt analyse appropriately in the short timeframe between these 2 finals...) to iris in daum osl in 07 to midas in the mbc survivor tournament in 05 so in over 251 played games against terran, over the course of 6 years, stork has lost only 5 BoX series against terrans, of which one was in the mbc survivor at at time when stork wasnt a dominant force on the scene yet, one to flash in a series where flash was showing his new build for the first time which would proceed to become a staple of modern tvp, and to mvp in a league that stork probably didnt really care or prepare for... this leaves us with 2 "serious" defeats against terrans in boX. and as i mentioned above, flashs sweep of stork in the bacchus finals can be explained by the short amount of time between it and the gsi finals; too few time to find out weaknesses of a build as monstrously strong as flashs double armory build. so basically, if stork is in good shape and its not against flash, he does not lose BoX pvts.. it just wont happen. | ||
|
overt
United States9006 Posts
On January 01 2011 13:53 Black Gun wrote: well, i think there is a broad consensus that stork and bisu belong to the top2 spots this month and that right now there is not much separating them. luckily for us, the question of who the leader of the recent surge of protoss is will be answered by the msl ro16 game between them. edit: ppl were not only questioning bisu because his group was really strong, they were also questioning him because he had been failing quite a lot recently against both kal and shine. In my opinion one bo3 isn't going to determine which one is the best. For example, if Bisu defeats Stork and goes on to win the MSL while Stork goes on to win the OSL I wouldn't necessarily say that Bisu is the better player. The bo3 they have coming is going to be really cool to watch and I'm sure people will claim that Stork or Bisu is the "best Protoss" after it's over but I think we'll have to wait and see how the rest of the MSL/OSL and Proleague plays out to make that call. As a Bisu fan, I can confidently say that I think Stork is a bit scarier and probably better right now. But Bisu beating Stork in the MSL isn't going to convince me that Bisu is better than Stork...unless of course Bisu absolutely demolishes Stork and it isn't even close. | ||
|
ShadeR
Australia7535 Posts
On January 01 2011 16:12 overt wrote: In my opinion one bo3 isn't going to determine which one is the best. For example, if Bisu defeats Stork and goes on to win the MSL while Stork goes on to win the OSL I wouldn't necessarily say that Bisu is the better player. The bo3 they have coming is going to be really cool to watch and I'm sure people will claim that Stork or Bisu is the "best Protoss" after it's over but I think we'll have to wait and see how the rest of the MSL/OSL and Proleague plays out to make that call. As a Bisu fan, I can confidently say that I think Stork is a bit scarier and probably better right now. But Bisu beating Stork in the MSL isn't going to convince me that Bisu is better than Stork...unless of course Bisu absolutely demolishes Stork and it isn't even close. Lets not forget that Stork's PvP is currently going through the crapper =/ | ||
|
Chronopolis
Canada1484 Posts
| ||
|
ReketSomething
United States6012 Posts
for speed + Show Spoiler + in tetris and holy shit your power ranks are detailed. You are the best! (after qxc) | ||
|
Tempest[OEC]
United States417 Posts
On January 01 2011 15:34 baubo wrote: But he doesn't. He consistently gets kicked out of starleagues by losing to various terrans. While whenever Stork sees terran in BoX, it usually ends ridiculously one-sided in Stork's favor. Bisu has good PvT record because he kills terrans in the proleague. But when his opponent prepares against him, he becomes a lot less awesome at it. The only "recent" BoXs that Bisu has lost to terrans was one to go.go., The Ro4 match against Fantasy, and the Avalon MSL Bo5 against Iris. Those are three that come to mind. While his wins are a Bo3 against Flash in WCG Korea, Bo3 against Mind last OSL, Bo3 against Baby in WCG 2010. He wins some and loses some. | ||
Milkis
5003 Posts
The ranking seems to put some ridiculous weight on being in OSL/MSL -- really? Enough to put Stork over Bisu, when Stork suffered some embarrassing losses recently? I dunno, that's just arbitrary bullshit to me lol. Flash is bonjwa but he's #5? That's utter nonsense -- if Flash is not PR #1, he is not bonjwa, let it be that. Drop the arbitrary title if you're going to admit he's not the scariest player at the moment. And then you have Kal magically at 3rd. Have you seen him play in the Proleague? I think you got swept a little too much by Kal vs Shine or something, because Kal is 1-4 in Proleague. Hogil #10? It makes me wonder if you even WATCHED the games that Hogil actually played -- they hardly resembled Hogil actually playing well. This is seriously disgusting lol. honestly looks like some sort of ridiculous fanboyism and arbitrary and easily swayed rankings. If your rankings shift that much in 15 days then well, I question the quality of the rankings before =/ | ||
|
Black Gun
Germany4482 Posts
On January 01 2011 16:34 Milkis wrote: This is seriously disgusting lol. honestly looks like some sort of ridiculous fanboyism and arbitrary and easily swayed rankings. If your rankings shift that much in 15 days then well, I question the quality of the rankings before =/ extremely unexpected events legitimate a more extreme shift of opinion, dont they? | ||
|
baubo
China3370 Posts
On January 01 2011 16:34 Tempest[OEC] wrote: The only "recent" BoXs that Bisu has lost to terrans was one to go.go., The Ro4 match against Fantasy, and the Avalon MSL Bo5 against Iris. Those are three that come to mind. While his wins are a Bo3 against Flash in WCG Korea, Bo3 against Mind last OSL, Bo3 against Baby in WCG 2010. He wins some and loses some. First of all, players barely practice for WCGs. So it's hardly comparable to OSL/MSL. And second of, it seem as a Bisu fan you're blocking out his most recent loss in a PvT BoX as if it didn't exist. Here's a hint: the terran's pretty popular here. Look, if one were to argue that Bisu's superior player to Stork, I think there's a good case for it. I do think his PvZ and PvP are superior at this point, although Stork's recent PvP crapola may just be an aberration. But there's no case for any protoss to reach Stork's status in PvT. There just isn't. | ||
|
BYAHH
United States20 Posts
Pained at the lack of Yum Bo Sung and Lee Jae Ho even from CNBC and shoutouts...Ssak, Mind, and Classic are all very bland. I'm really hoping Midas pulls an upset. | ||
|
infinity2k9
United Kingdom2397 Posts
On January 01 2011 16:34 Milkis wrote: lol this is seriously the worst power ranking i have ever seen in my life. The ranking seems to put some ridiculous weight on being in OSL/MSL -- really? Enough to put Stork over Bisu, when Stork suffered some embarrassing losses recently? I dunno, that's just arbitrary bullshit to me lol. Flash is bonjwa but he's #5? That's utter nonsense -- if Flash is not PR #1, he is not bonjwa, let it be that. Drop the arbitrary title if you're going to admit he's not the scariest player at the moment. And then you have Kal magically at 3rd. Have you seen him play in the Proleague? I think you got swept a little too much by Kal vs Shine or something, because Kal is 1-4 in Proleague. Hogil #10? It makes me wonder if you even WATCHED the games that Hogil actually played -- they hardly resembled Hogil actually playing well. This is seriously disgusting lol. honestly looks like some sort of ridiculous fanboyism and arbitrary and easily swayed rankings. If your rankings shift that much in 15 days then well, I question the quality of the rankings before =/ I have to agree and by looking at the rankings i just think, has the person actually watched the games? | ||
|
hp.Shell
United States2527 Posts
| ||
|
jaQi
1121 Posts
On January 01 2011 19:00 infinity2k9 wrote: I have to agree and by looking at the rankings i just think, has the person actually watched the games? Honestly, like a lot of guys like you said it before, this is really a bad bad PR. Stork is doing a great job recently but he's definetly not the number #1. Bisu's #2 is ok. Kal # 3? wtf? Jaedong #4?? WTF? Flash #5 ??? WTF???? Actually there is no doubt that Flash should still put on 1st place even he's out of MSL/OSL. There is no other player who shines out that much fear to the other players. IMO #1 Flash #2 Bisu #3Jaedong, because the dong isn't doing such an impressive job like Bisu in PL. | ||
|
p14c
Vatican City State431 Posts
| ||
|
shucklesors
Singapore1176 Posts
id say this PR would be a little off, if you count a month's value as 80% and history's value as 20% even. is it, now? a month ago, the number 1 spot was for 'listing achievements flash has done during that month', and now he's 5th. + Show Spoiler + flash is ONLY 7-5 this month (u guys are probably like 'holy shit, u for real bro? thats horrible!' thats actl rather close to kal's career win percentage) JAEDONG (omg i love u jaedong), who is 10-5 this month (again, horrible as hell, i mean COME ON MAN THAT'S ONLY 66.6%) lost to hogil and hiya. fine, completely unacceptable. but really, who would argue against the game against hiya being a serious fluke that probably happens in a very very rare blue moon? against hogil, really horrid and slooppy, unexcusable, but SERIOUSLY, STILL. would u be more scared of bisu than jd when it comes to vZ? bisu lost to a slumping action because he let it get to macro game. enough on that. stork has a superb and fantastic month, no one can really disagree, fine. but come to his vT (probably the current best vT as well), and do u think he would say that hes actl rather close to flash's vP yet? the gap between JF and basically 'everyone else' is thinning, with JF's losses helping that thin faster, but there is way more for everyone to do before they come really close to JF. also, who in the top 3 is truly DOMINATING like JF when they were at peaks? perhaps stork/bisu, but for so damn long? and now with wr of JUST ONLY SLIGHTLY ABOVE 50%', they get dropped to 4th and 5th. id say requestion whos 1st and whos 2nd for JF, and sort out the protosses 3rd 4th and 5th. when bisu starts losing again, see how tough it is to drop him simply because youve experienced his amazingly overhyped recovery before. but not for JF eh. | ||
|
corumjhaelen
France6884 Posts
On January 01 2011 16:34 Milkis wrote: lol this is seriously the worst power ranking i have ever seen in my life. The ranking seems to put some ridiculous weight on being in OSL/MSL -- really? Enough to put Stork over Bisu, when Stork suffered some embarrassing losses recently? I dunno, that's just arbitrary bullshit to me lol. Flash is bonjwa but he's #5? That's utter nonsense -- if Flash is not PR #1, he is not bonjwa, let it be that. Drop the arbitrary title if you're going to admit he's not the scariest player at the moment. And then you have Kal magically at 3rd. Have you seen him play in the Proleague? I think you got swept a little too much by Kal vs Shine or something, because Kal is 1-4 in Proleague. Hogil #10? It makes me wonder if you even WATCHED the games that Hogil actually played -- they hardly resembled Hogil actually playing well. This is seriously disgusting lol. honestly looks like some sort of ridiculous fanboyism and arbitrary and easily swayed rankings. If your rankings shift that much in 15 days then well, I question the quality of the rankings before =/ Yeah Bisu's play is soooooooooooooooooooooo inspiring... Embarassing loss like to Lucifer yeah ? Which are the others exactly ? At the very limit, the first to Shine I guess. You're pretty lucky that Bisu had a BO win against Kal, because it's the only reason he's at And, guess what, you're also putting an arbitrary weight on PL. Honestly what would you have wanted ? What would you have done ? Noo ne is really dominating atm, and no one is playing well in all three match up. I don't see for instance, how you could put Jaedong over Kal with Jaedong's play. I'd say you have your own biases and you're own way of ranking, which might explain why some people are happy about this PR, and some are saying it's utter crap. If I want a non-arbitrary PR, I go check TPLD, or Kespa's ranking. And as for fanboyism, there has been much much worse on the PR in the past. | ||
|
Iplaythings
Denmark9110 Posts
I salute you ! Awesome ranking and I luuuuuv the shoutout part. Happy new years eve !  | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
Stellar Fest
OSC
CranKy Ducklings
Online Event
FEL
AI Arena Tournament
BSL: Ladder Tournament
Sparkling Tuna Cup
INu's Battles
herO vs Classic
Percival vs Rogue
BSL Open Qualifier
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
