Personally I think the whole site can use a renovation in the looks department. The weird blueish site color doesn't really look that great and new people may be discouraged from joining the site. Most forums nowadays have a more comprehensive forum style that has icon pictures, better profile settings and bigger signature space. I think if TL moved towards this direction it would be better for the site in terms of netting more views each month. The horses IMO also could use a renovation, like a new picture with a different font for the words.

AyJay

1515 Posts

July 23 2010 18:44 GMT

#202

Change to unicorns then it's ok.

KevinIX

United States2472 Posts

July 23 2010 18:52 GMT

#203

I don't like it. It has nothing to do with Team Liquid.

XsebT

Denmark2980 Posts

July 23 2010 18:59 GMT

#204

On July 24 2010 03:34 Lucid90 wrote:
Personally I think the whole site can use a renovation in the looks department. The weird blueish site color doesn't really look that great and new people may be discouraged from joining the site. Most forums nowadays have a more comprehensive forum style that has icon pictures, better profile settings and bigger signature space. I think if TL moved towards this direction it would be better for the site in terms of netting more views each month. The horses IMO also could use a renovation, like a new picture with a different font for the words.

I strongly disagree.
First of all, the color. To me it seems very neutral, but still very specific and the coloring makes it very easy to recognize the site.
As for the layout, I really think it's one of the best out there. Yes, it's very unlike the usual forums on the internet, but that does by no means make it bad. It is so manageable while still containing so much information. Old, but good - just like Brood War.

On July 24 2010 03:52 KevinIX wrote:
I don't like it. It has nothing to do with Team Liquid.

Well, that's not entirely true...

Folca

2235 Posts

July 23 2010 19:11 GMT

#205

If we change the horse, than thats going to give us leisure for a lot of other things, like the layout of the forums. Please don't change anything, keeping the forums as unique and as original as possible since the first day it came out will may look as usual, but thats what we want. We want TeamLiquid to be a forum that doesn't change their behavior, because it's one of the best out there.

Saracen

United States5139 Posts

July 23 2010 19:11 GMT

#206

Why on earth would you want to change it?

harenzo

United Kingdom36 Posts

July 23 2010 19:12 GMT

#207

The horses look awesome, keep the banner as it is.

Exteray

United States1094 Posts

July 23 2010 19:20 GMT

#208

What's the story behind them anyway? (as in why are they there)

GinNtoniC

Sweden2945 Posts

July 23 2010 19:21 GMT

#209

Never ever change them. If anything, alternate between different pictures... all including the horses.
some of the T-shirt-suggestions we had when making a poll for the new T-shirt design could be used as main site pictures - but the horse as motive has to stay.

So basically, don't ever change.

cgrinker

United States3824 Posts

July 23 2010 19:26 GMT

#210

You ever wonder about polls that are kinda vague about what the content is about?

Tidbits like:

Jim Warren was happy we used the banner so long as we credited him
It's vaguely about the Black Riders.

Stuff like that

disciple

9071 Posts

July 23 2010 19:32 GMT

#211

I'm sure the poll results would've been completely different if there was a sample with a different banner like 'hey guys here is another idea how we can make the banner look modern and up to date, so do you think (and basically list the current options)' Now people dont have a base to compare and autovote for what they are used to.

Q: We are curious if you are going to drink our new beer, but we dont want to tell you what will it taste like. Will you buy it?

(X) No, Im drinking the same beer for ages, its defining for my personality, I dont give a fuck how bad it is, I wont drink smth else for nothing
( ) No, I'm drinking the same beer for ages now, I'm just used to it
( ) Yea sure, I'm drinking the same beer for ages, its kind of cool but I dont mind trying out smth new, despite the fact I have no idea how it will taste
( ) I wont drink it but pershaps someone else will
( ) fuck yea, its time for a change

BlasiuS

United States2405 Posts

July 23 2010 19:45 GMT

#212

interesting poll...I think the horse banner definitely hasn't aged well, it looks really dated.

Having been here for almost 3 years I'm used to it, but it definitely looks like it was done during middle school art class, and the "random missing sections of the first letter of a word" font seems kind of weird when you stop and think about it.

I think the banner should be updated. The magic horse motif is unique, so keep that...just make it more sexy & modern.

edit: also, what happened to the bottom right corner of the banner? Looks like someone tore the corner off haphazardly

JayDee_

548 Posts

July 23 2010 19:50 GMT

#213

It clearly makes no sense, but it's completely hilarious. I think you guys should focus more on changing your comment format. Check out www.esreality.com to see how things should be done.

Akamu

United States309 Posts

July 23 2010 19:54 GMT

#214

I've been lurking here since sc2 beta came out and "the horses" have always been one of the most ridiculous(ly) ((bad)) things on the site.

I mean yes listening to silver and bronze players QQ about whats overpowered is one thing but seriously... horses? come on. This is a fairly hardcore gaming site and your home page looks like a bad attempt to lure in My Little Pony entusiasts.

Change it.

BlackHat

United States264 Posts

July 23 2010 20:07 GMT

#215

I don't mind either way, but looking at the horses always reminds me of the scene in Fellowship of the Ring where Gandalf magics up the river into horses. I thought it was appropriate since they were Liquid Horses.

ShabbySalami

38 Posts

July 23 2010 20:18 GMT

#216

On July 24 2010 04:54 Akamu wrote:
I've been lurking here since sc2 beta came out and "the horses" have always been one of the most ridiculous(ly) ((bad)) things on the site.

I mean yes listening to silver and bronze players QQ about whats overpowered is one thing but seriously... horses? come on. This is a fairly hardcore gaming site and your home page looks like a bad attempt to lure in My Little Pony entusiasts.

Change it.

Ok, I'll fold +1

GroK

United States11 Posts

July 23 2010 20:51 GMT

#217

I'm totally new to this site, and I just assumed you all had a good poetic or philosophical reason for a "team" of horses "flowing" through a snowstorm so that's fine. The content and functionality is really what matters and the site admins can make it look however they want for any or no reason at all.

But I do have an idea after seeing the original (and assuming the vote is to keep or update it) : maybe crop it a little less so you can see all their heads and feet (and maybe even use the mountains somewhere). That way it will look more like the original artwork ... especially if you flip it horizontally.

The idea of it being camouflaged to NOT look like a "gamer' site is also kinda clever. Was that intentional?