|
United States60190 Posts
On April 12 2013 06:41 ROOTheognis wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 06:30 TritaN wrote:From Sundance's Twitter: Updates to the NA WCS qual process inbound.
2 key changes.
People should be happy - except possibly the tourney admins... Hmm... prolly just all qualifiers or more qualfiers? Only thing to make tourney admins more upset ![](/mirror/smilies/puh2.gif)
No charge for qualifers, that would piss admins off for sure. Fingers crossed for the other one(going full Red Sox mode and not jinxing it.)
|
On April 12 2013 01:47 Hasuu wrote: It really dissapoints me to not see up and coming top NA players like Quanitc Glon on that list. Instead Korean pro gamers? In NA?
It befundles me that Hellokitty/Capoch got in.... overall the entire process disgusts me.
But it's OK - I now have to do a 256 open man bracket versus a horde of koreans. I'd rather have a chance with a slap in the face than not have one at all.
|
Dunno if this has been posted yet, but DeMusLim just got in!!
also @DeMusliM will now be joining us as one of the 32 - we had a cancellation...
|
|
United States5162 Posts
|
Cancellation huh? Well, i'm happy for Demu.
e. meh.
|
On April 12 2013 07:14 Branman wrote:That's a year old.
dont I look stupid now . Was so happy when a friend sent me the link, and I just watched the timestamp latest reply which was today
|
On April 12 2013 07:14 Branman wrote:That's a year old.
I easily felt for it
|
8748 Posts
This invitation + qualifier combination is weird. After this first season, all spots will be determined by a clear and proven qualification process. It is a huge improvement for the NA and EU scenes that 9 new major events per year (7 in 2013) will have a clear and good qualification process. Despite this promising future, just for this first season, WCS is going to have 3/4 of the Premier players determined by invitation. It has to be somewhat open or people will (rightfully) be outraged so 1/4 of the players will be determined by a one-time qualification process. But the qualification process could just as easily determine all 32 players. So as long as there must be a qualifier, why not allow it to determine all players?
Invites are simply vague and shitty qualification processes. If you invite someone because they got some result at some random past tournament, then that tournament was essentially a qualifier for your invitational event and that's just absurd. It's a reasonable shortcut when it's not feasible to run qualifiers or when you're not trying to determine the players in your tournament by merit. But if you are doing a real qualification process anyway, then there's no reason to have any invites.
|
On April 12 2013 07:24 Lukeeze[zR] wrote:I easily felt for it
yeah me to ;/
|
I personnaly think all foreigner from any region should get a seed and earn a spot. If youd put like top 32 ladder from each region with a close watch at abuse well that would make the ladder so fun !!!! :D
|
Benjamin Baker @DeMusliM 7 min @MLGSundance Thank you ![](/mirror/smilies/smile.gif)
Oh god, I feel bad for him :[
|
On April 12 2013 07:33 Lukeeze[zR] wrote:Benjamin Baker @DeMusliM 7 min @MLGSundance Thank you ![](/mirror/smilies/smile.gif) Oh god, I feel bad for him :[
most likely the open bracket qualifier thing, he talked about in his stream earlier about some qualifier thingy
|
Alright, this is going to be on page 30 or something but I hope some people will really see it because there are so many weird things being thrown around in here...
The way the invites have worked for North America is like this:
There are 24 invitations total. 16 of those invites were supposed to be going to American players (this includes Mexico, South America, etc.) and those are the following:
+ Show Spoiler +1. KiLLeR 2. Scarlett 3. IdrA 4. Suppy 5. Fenix 6. ViBE 7. HuK 8. Illusion 9. Major 10. State 11. Goswser 12. Hellokitty 13. Minigun 14. theognis 15. Capoch 16. Maker The remaining 8 invitations were given to non-American players (Korea, Europe, etc.). Those are these:
+ Show Spoiler +17. Ryung 18. HerO 19. viOLet 20. Polt 21. mOOnGLaDe 22. Sen 23. NesTea 24. Snute These 2 categories people were done seperately and even if you're residing in North America you are not a North American player. A controversial one is that people are giving MLG a lot of flack for having invited Capoch, Maker and a few others instead of DeMusliM but it's completely irrelevant based on how the system works. DeMusliM does not belong in that category, but he belongs between the last 8 invitation spots.
The non-American invites are 5 Koreans, 2 SEA people (TW and Australia) and 1 European. It's very clear that regions have been a factor as well as skill. I don't think the invitation is supposed to be stating that mOOnGLaDe is better than all the other contenders there were, but they were trying to distribute it to all regions so they wouldn't just invite 8 Koreans. What you can discuss is whether or not there should have been a different distribution and this is where a player like DeMusliM comes to mind for me. I could see it making sense removing a Korean invite (which in this case probably would have been Ryung) and given one more to Europe (DeMusliM or Stephano, but I assume Stephano would have gotten it if he had wanted it but he chose WCS EU).
|
United States60190 Posts
On April 12 2013 07:46 Bumblebee wrote:Alright, this is going to be on page 30 or something but I hope some people will really see it because there are so many weird things being thrown around in here... The way the invites have worked for North America is like this: There are 24 invitations total. 16 of those invites were supposed to be going to American players (this includes Mexico, South America, etc.) and those are the following: + Show Spoiler +1. KiLLeR 2. Scarlett 3. IdrA 4. Suppy 5. Fenix 6. ViBE 7. HuK 8. Illusion 9. Major 10. State 11. Goswser 12. Hellokitty 13. Minigun 14. theognis 15. Capoch 16. Maker The remaining 8 invitations were given to non-American players (Korea, Europe, etc.). Those are these: + Show Spoiler +17. Ryung 18. HerO 19. viOLet 20. Polt 21. mOOnGLaDe 22. Sen 23. NesTea 24. Snute These 2 categories people were done seperately and even if you're residing in North America you are not a North American player. A controversial one is that people are giving MLG a lot of flack for having invited Capoch, Maker and a few others instead of DeMusliM but it's completely irrelevant based on how the system works. DeMusliM does not belong in that category, but he belongs between the last 8 invitation spots. The non-American invites are 5 Koreans, 2 SEA people (TW and Australia) and 1 European. It's very clear that regions have been a factor as well as skill. I don't think the invitation is supposed to be stating that mOOnGLaDe is better than all the other contenders there were, but they were trying to distribute it to all regions so they wouldn't just invite 8 Koreans. What you can discuss is whether or not there should have been a different distribution and this is where a player like DeMusliM comes to mind for me. I could see it making sense removing a Korean invite (which in this case probably would have been Ryung) and given one more to Europe (DeMusliM or Stephano, but I assume Stephano would have gotten it if he had wanted it but he chose WCS EU).
Did the players know about these caps when they made the decision on what region to play WCS in? People understand the need for invite systems for the first WCS. The question is if the players were given enough information from Blizzard before they made the decision.
|
On April 12 2013 07:46 Bumblebee wrote:Alright, this is going to be on page 30 or something but I hope some people will really see it because there are so many weird things being thrown around in here... The way the invites have worked for North America is like this: There are 24 invitations total. 16 of those invites were supposed to be going to American players (this includes Mexico, South America, etc.) and those are the following: + Show Spoiler +1. KiLLeR 2. Scarlett 3. IdrA 4. Suppy 5. Fenix 6. ViBE 7. HuK 8. Illusion 9. Major 10. State 11. Goswser 12. Hellokitty 13. Minigun 14. theognis 15. Capoch 16. Maker The remaining 8 invitations were given to non-American players (Korea, Europe, etc.). Those are these: + Show Spoiler +17. Ryung 18. HerO 19. viOLet 20. Polt 21. mOOnGLaDe 22. Sen 23. NesTea 24. Snute These 2 categories people were done seperately and even if you're residing in North America you are not a North American player. A controversial one is that people are giving MLG a lot of flack for having invited Capoch, Maker and a few others instead of DeMusliM but it's completely irrelevant based on how the system works. DeMusliM does not belong in that category, but he belongs between the last 8 invitation spots. The non-American invites are 5 Koreans, 2 SEA people (TW and Australia) and 1 European. It's very clear that regions have been a factor as well as skill. I don't think the invitation is supposed to be stating that mOOnGLaDe is better than all the other contenders there were, but they were trying to distribute it to all regions so they wouldn't just invite 8 Koreans. What you can discuss is whether or not there should have been a different distribution and this is where a player like DeMusliM comes to mind for me. I could see it making sense removing a Korean invite (which in this case probably would have been Ryung) and given one more to Europe (DeMusliM or Stephano, but I assume Stephano would have gotten it if he had wanted it but he chose WCS EU).
What competition was the seeds given out on? If it's purely based on WCS then Demuslim should've gotten a seed in the EU division over either HasuObs or ThorZaIN and MaNa and TitaN who finished the same as Demuslim. Even if its based on all tournaments, some of the invitees are (excuse my language) fucking horrible and makes no sense at all.
|
On April 12 2013 00:01 Godwrath wrote:Show nested quote +On April 11 2013 23:58 Meatloaf wrote: No lucifron or vortix make me a sad spaniard They are in the EU list, or did i miss something ?
LOL i just missed their names altogether thank you.
let me rephrase: Lucifron and Vortix will make me a happy spaniard!! GO LUCIFRON!
|
On April 12 2013 07:52 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 07:46 Bumblebee wrote:Alright, this is going to be on page 30 or something but I hope some people will really see it because there are so many weird things being thrown around in here... The way the invites have worked for North America is like this: There are 24 invitations total. 16 of those invites were supposed to be going to American players (this includes Mexico, South America, etc.) and those are the following: + Show Spoiler +1. KiLLeR 2. Scarlett 3. IdrA 4. Suppy 5. Fenix 6. ViBE 7. HuK 8. Illusion 9. Major 10. State 11. Goswser 12. Hellokitty 13. Minigun 14. theognis 15. Capoch 16. Maker The remaining 8 invitations were given to non-American players (Korea, Europe, etc.). Those are these: + Show Spoiler +17. Ryung 18. HerO 19. viOLet 20. Polt 21. mOOnGLaDe 22. Sen 23. NesTea 24. Snute These 2 categories people were done seperately and even if you're residing in North America you are not a North American player. A controversial one is that people are giving MLG a lot of flack for having invited Capoch, Maker and a few others instead of DeMusliM but it's completely irrelevant based on how the system works. DeMusliM does not belong in that category, but he belongs between the last 8 invitation spots. The non-American invites are 5 Koreans, 2 SEA people (TW and Australia) and 1 European. It's very clear that regions have been a factor as well as skill. I don't think the invitation is supposed to be stating that mOOnGLaDe is better than all the other contenders there were, but they were trying to distribute it to all regions so they wouldn't just invite 8 Koreans. What you can discuss is whether or not there should have been a different distribution and this is where a player like DeMusliM comes to mind for me. I could see it making sense removing a Korean invite (which in this case probably would have been Ryung) and given one more to Europe (DeMusliM or Stephano, but I assume Stephano would have gotten it if he had wanted it but he chose WCS EU). Did the players know about these caps when they made the decision on what region to play WCS in? People understand the need for invite systems for the first WCS. The question is if the players were given enough information from Blizzard before they made the decision. Nazgul and I were fully aware of the system when we made the decision to play Snute, Zenio and HerO in NA for season 1, yes.
On April 12 2013 07:55 Aleteh wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 07:46 Bumblebee wrote:Alright, this is going to be on page 30 or something but I hope some people will really see it because there are so many weird things being thrown around in here... The way the invites have worked for North America is like this: There are 24 invitations total. 16 of those invites were supposed to be going to American players (this includes Mexico, South America, etc.) and those are the following: + Show Spoiler +1. KiLLeR 2. Scarlett 3. IdrA 4. Suppy 5. Fenix 6. ViBE 7. HuK 8. Illusion 9. Major 10. State 11. Goswser 12. Hellokitty 13. Minigun 14. theognis 15. Capoch 16. Maker The remaining 8 invitations were given to non-American players (Korea, Europe, etc.). Those are these: + Show Spoiler +17. Ryung 18. HerO 19. viOLet 20. Polt 21. mOOnGLaDe 22. Sen 23. NesTea 24. Snute These 2 categories people were done seperately and even if you're residing in North America you are not a North American player. A controversial one is that people are giving MLG a lot of flack for having invited Capoch, Maker and a few others instead of DeMusliM but it's completely irrelevant based on how the system works. DeMusliM does not belong in that category, but he belongs between the last 8 invitation spots. The non-American invites are 5 Koreans, 2 SEA people (TW and Australia) and 1 European. It's very clear that regions have been a factor as well as skill. I don't think the invitation is supposed to be stating that mOOnGLaDe is better than all the other contenders there were, but they were trying to distribute it to all regions so they wouldn't just invite 8 Koreans. What you can discuss is whether or not there should have been a different distribution and this is where a player like DeMusliM comes to mind for me. I could see it making sense removing a Korean invite (which in this case probably would have been Ryung) and given one more to Europe (DeMusliM or Stephano, but I assume Stephano would have gotten it if he had wanted it but he chose WCS EU). What competition was the seeds given out on? If it's purely based on WCS then Demuslim should've gotten a seed in the EU division over either HasuObs or ThorZaIN and MaNa and TitaN who finished the same as Demuslim. Even if its based on all tournaments, some of the invitees are (excuse my language) fucking horrible and makes no sense at all. I don't think you can say iti was based on a competition, but more so what made sense due to a lot of factors. Marketing, skill, region, etc. I don't think there was just 1 factor. But I don't know for sure nor did I have any influence.
|
France7248 Posts
The WCS America Season 1 Qualifying Tournament will now feature 512 players and will be FREE to enter. Register here: http://mlg.to/ZPZRLP
|
Demuslim should be on that list and Idra should not.
|
|
|
|