Pyrry's Mafia Game - GG - Page 6

So I looked over chaoser's posts to see if I could spot anything weird. I'll take crate's advice this time and won't point out everything that would make sense if he were mafia, but rather try to find weird things to do as townie.

Here's what stood out to me:



Hmm.. The bolded part is weird. Why would he oppose getting a confirmed townie that much? Doesn't have a real role, how does that matter? he also neglects to mention the possibility of having 4 kills in one night, but that could be a honest mistake.

Also, "needs to be protected".. How about CAN be protected because it will more or less be guaranteed blocking hits from the mafia? That is MUCH better than not knowing at all who the mafia will hit. This won't be the last night where mafia didn't get three kills.



But here's the kicker. Ra.Xor.2, one of our safest mafia bets atm, tried to link chaoser to the clues. Wth.



Shikyo, could you elaborate on your thoughts about chaoser?

And then when our double lynch comes, chaoser even discourages lynching both omG.[RaYnE] and Shikyo:




I'm pretty sure that EVERY mafia at this point would want Shikyo dead. I'm actually surprised that they didn't bandwagon him more, but then again I don't feel that the mafia has played very well in this game. But for a mafia to go out and DEFEND the green townie? Yeah right.

That's all I could get out of chaoser's posts, really. The only suspicious post I could find was the one about the vigi plan. And that could just be lack of research/or a hastily written post on his part. That doesn't make him mafia.

Then motbob goes on making a case on chaoser, connecting him to softer's murder in the park. Let's look at this.



When has pokemon trainers ever been associated with whips? Even though you couldn't find any other matches doesn't mean that this has to be one. It could be a red herring, or simply a connection that Pyrr found and you didn't.



chaoser's 100% bad voting record, well, that goes for me as well. I've voted for all of our green/blue lynches up until now. I agreed on lynching therapy too. Does that make me mafia? Bad judgement does not equal red.

And Jimtudor was also a veteran player. Is it not possible that chaoser thought that JimTudor was the best choice? Jimtudor was town-aligned, so you can't make any conclusions from this.



I just went through the same posts, and I didn't see anything spectacular. Keep this in mind: this is a game for new players. There are PLENTY of misread clues throughout this whole thread, including clues as crepuscular, BWdero's sound waves, my clues on RaYnE, the therapy clues, ALL the clues we had on Jayme.

I do agree that his choice of passages to bold was poor. But take a look at the other clue analysis we've had, were they not just as poor?

Ok. Pawsom, like most of the other players in this game, keeps making bad calls on clues and overlooks things when he comments on confirmed townie and medic lists. But that could be said about many of us. The first weird thing I noticed when going through his posts was this:



So he's against double lynch. I can't see how he doesn't understand how 2 lynches instead of 1 means we have better chance of hitting a red. But oh well. This could also be a weird townie call so I won't put that much weight on it, especially since in the end we probably would've benefited more from postponing the double lynches for a day.



Even though it's been 5 days since you wrote that post, if you could, it would be great if you would elaborate on this, crate.



I know we've been making weird clue connections all over the place in this game, but come on. First of all, it was a flashy tie, not a green tie. And to connect a man in a tie to another murder which involved the neck area? That has got to be the most farfetched clue connection I've seen in this game so far. And that says a lot.

That's basically all I could get out of his posts. He did another weak and pointless clue analysis but it's no good evidence, so I'll leave it.

Now this is where things get interesting, and why I bothered to look into him at all. Let's take a look at yesterday's double lynch.



If you are townie you just made the biggest mistake you have ever done in this game. "Oh hey guys why don't we lynch our mayor? So what if he's townie, it's not like he's useful!"

What this looks like to me is a mafia trying to cover up the fact that he's voting for the townie mayor. No town-aligned player would say something like that, giving up three votes in our favor and lynching a bodyguard protected player, unless he strongly believed that the mayor was mafia. Pawsom seemingly didn't care about Shikyo's alignment.

At first, many of us connected Pawsom to the crepuscular sentence, along with Jayme. But the DT's checked that, and crepuscular wasn't a clue. So there would have to be something else.

The thing is, Pawsom basically has nothing to make clues out of. An SCV-icon and his nick is basically all we have to work with.
I had no idea where to start. I couldn't think of anything in these clues that could connect to Pawsom, probably because Pyrr has made a connection to his nickname that I have failed to see.

But then I got a PM from JeeJee the other day, who was questioning Pawsom's status as well. At first I disregarded his clues, as I didn't think they were any good. But with today's post, they actually were.



Keep in mind that this was said before the recent day post though. So I did some research to try and find some connections with today's murders.




If that's even a clue it's more probable that it's pointing to epicdoom, but oh well. I'll get to the point. I did find one highly plausible clue on Pawsom in today's day post. So if there's only one mafia per kill, the stench of death could refer to playing possum. Anyway, take a look at this:



Pouch was the word that immediately stood out to me. Keeping explosives in a pouch? Well, it all makes sense actually.



Then I checked out the marsupial species:



Could it be any clearer? Thanks to JeeJee for pointing out Pawsom -> Possum for me.