|
So, most people seem to want to lynch Therapy, and in the case I end up becoming mayor, I feel like he'd be the best person to lynch unless something comes up. JeeJee's last few posts have been good and he seems like a good player who'd do well as a mayor. However, the recent bandwagon voting for him has become a little bit worrying for me. It probably is nothing, though.
I'm not sure of when exactly the voting is going to end, but I'm guessing it's quite soon, and so I've decided to compose a medic list to help medics protect valuable members for the town. If you have some feedback about the list, want to add or remove someone, or think someone on the list is suspicious and likely to be red, please let me know.
Medic List:
Shikyo
JeeJee
Jimtudor
zeks
crate
teks
vx70GTOJudgexv?
In addition to merely being a help for the medics, the medic list actually indirectly protects everyone on it even if medics don't protect them, since mafia is unlikely to hit anyone on the list because of the risk of getting their hit blocked.
Many of the mayor/sheriff candidates are on the list because, interestingly enough, they've been contibuting quite a bit. If one of them becomes the mayor/sheriff, he will naturally be taken off the list. It's likely that one of them is a mafia, but since we don't have strong enough evidence against anyone, and can't exactly remove all of them off the list, the most important ones will remain there. Of course, I'm taking suggestions, and highly suspicious people will be taken off the list if the need arises.
I'd also like to point out that The_Master has been quite inactive as well. His first post was basically a "I will post for the sake of posting" post that added absolutely nothing and was most likely highly ignored. However, that seems slightly more sincere to me, and hence I'm not that suspicious him. It still is something to note, though. After that, he has only posted once, about changing his vote along with the bandwagon. What's interesting is how he thanked JeeJee about the role post, I wonder what I should think about that. Is he someone who would have benefitted of it, or a mafia acting like he was?
Before pointing fingers at too many people, I'm waiting eagerly for the day 2 clues. I'm sure the clue analysis will be far more fruitful with the ability to compare them to the day 1 clues. I haven't bothered analysing these day 1 clues at all, but I'm planning on analysing day 2 clues along with day 1 clues, and hopefully am able to figure something out.
|
I disagree on putting JimTudor on the medic list. He is under suspicion atm.
I only agree on JeeJee, zeks, crate and teks.
|
l10f
United States3241 Posts
And there are only 3 medics + sheriff + mayor. That's only 5 people that are protected what about the other two?
|
On May 20 2009 09:56 l10f wrote:
And there are only 3 medics + sheriff + mayor. That's only 5 people that are protected what about the other two?
The point of the medic list isn't for the medics to protect them, however contradicting this might sound. It's simply what the medics themselves should've come up with (or something similar) if they followed my advice by reading the thread from mafia's point of view and deciding who to kill (and consequently, prot). Obviously, if the medics were to blindly protect people on the list, the mafia would blindly.. not hit people on the list, thus negating medic protection completely. The fact that the medic list contains more people than there are medics is irrelevant.
|
I don't understand what is so suspicious about saying that I don't have anything to add. However, if I AM lynched, and that seems to be becoming extremely likely I suggest suspicions be turned towards JeeJee and zeks as they were very quick to bandwagon against me with little to no real evidence. I'm not sure what I can really say in my defense, I'm just inexperienced and figured I was supposed to post, just couldn't think of anything to add. Guess I'll take this as a learning experience for the next game.
|
Well, Shikyo, I thank you for not being too suspicious of me. It makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.
On May 20 2009 07:36 zeks wrote:
I find it suspicious that The_Master is changing his vote to JeeJee after I brought up the fact that we should check clues on the people who vote for JimTudor.
I don't mind that you find that suspicious at all. I would still be voting to JimTudor if JeeJee hadn't swayed me over to the dark side (pardon the figure of speech). Also, I wouldn't expect to not get off the 'suspected' list by changing my vote but I figured I'd be suspected either way so I may as well vote for who I wanted to vote for.
If you think I swtiched votes to remove suspicions from myself, think of it this way: If I was a mafia the two ways I can think of to explain my actions are:
a) I panicked at possibly being the center of attention so I joined a bandwagon and made up the pitiful excuse of why I changed my vote; or
b) My Mafian ringleaders (all more experienced than me so they would know it would bring attention to myself) told me to switch from JimTudor (if he is Mafian like you suspect) to JeeJee ... for some reason. Perhaps JeeJee is mafia as well then or JeeJee would somehow benefit them in some way that would counter the extra suspicion being dumped upon me?
Now, if I was a lonely little townsfolk peasant person with no friends to give me a character reference I can only think of one reason to change: I liked JeeJee in more than JimTudor (or maybe I have a 6th sense just joined the bandwagon before I realized there was a bandwagon - now, that would be cool).
|
On May 20 2009 09:52 iLoveKTF wrote:
I disagree on putting JimTudor on the medic list. He is under suspicion atm.
I only agree on JeeJee, zeks, crate and teks.
Please elaborate as in why am I under suspicion other than I ran for office.
|
umm... read the last 2 or 3 pages?
|
Well, then I don't have much to defend against...
Other than the fact that I sure hope that Teks elimination number game is wrong and that for all the 'top' contenders for office, one should be mafia.
|
On May 20 2009 10:28 Jimtudor wrote:Show nested quote +On May 20 2009 09:52 iLoveKTF wrote:
I disagree on putting JimTudor on the medic list. He is under suspicion atm.
I only agree on JeeJee, zeks, crate and teks. Please elaborate as in why am I under suspicion other than I ran for office.
First of all, running for office grants you more attention. So anyone that runs for office is most likely under suspicion, so to me that point is null. That and you've hardly been posting and if you do, it's kind of ...blah. Something someone running for a position probably shouldn't do. You brought the attention on yourself but you aren't dealing with it too well IMO. But I definitely agree with KTF. Other than that you're still quite active. I'm not suspicious of you, but there ARE reasons to be.
On May 20 2009 10:35 iLoveKTF wrote:
umm... read the last 2 or 3 pages?
Just a thought...
Anyways, I still find it very suspicious that The_Master suddenly changes his vote after someone said something so simple... That and he posts just to post to say he is here and disregards everything he says. Although it could just be inexperience. Even so, he said himself that he wish he could post something useful. Well, I wish you could, too. You're pretty much bandwagoning, and you make it look like you're trying to get a fellow mafia into office, hm...
|
On May 20 2009 09:52 iLoveKTF wrote:
I disagree on putting JimTudor on the medic list. He is under suspicion atm.
I only agree on JeeJee, zeks, crate and teks.
I didn't feel like there was too much against him. Just basically people being suspicious of the voting patterns and him not having posted much recently, which I don't feel is all that strong. Still, I feel that he's been contributing more than much of the town has. If he becomes more suspicious, however, I am going to change the list appropriately if necessary.
I thought that more names would be better than less names for now, since the more people the list protects, generally the better. Especially since vigi hits can't be used during the first night, so even if someone on the list is a mafia, the damage isn't really all that significant. You don't agree with me being on the list? Ah, that breaks my heart.
|
nah. Youve clearly won a seat already... :p
|
On May 20 2009 10:51 iLoveKTF wrote:
nah. Youve clearly won a seat already... :p
JeeJee hasn't? He seems to be ahead of me in votes right now.
|
@Koopie:
Fair enough.
Changed my vote to Shikyo as I feel he is the strongest candidate with the best plan that has a chance at top office.
|
l10f
United States3241 Posts
Shikyo 10 - JeeJee 10 except the vote on JeeJee came before Shikyo's, so that would mean JeeJee would be sheriff if nothing else changes.
|
On May 20 2009 10:53 Shikyo wrote:Show nested quote +On May 20 2009 10:51 iLoveKTF wrote:
nah. Youve clearly won a seat already... :p JeeJee hasn't? He seems to be ahead of me in votes right now.
yeah while I was writing that I somehow thought that the race between jimtudor and jeejee was still close. and I checked back and now your tied again (counting jimtudor's vote).
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
Shikyo, is you putting yourself on the medic list implying that you are medic?
|
l10f
United States3241 Posts
On May 20 2009 11:21 Foolishness wrote:
Shikyo, is you putting yourself on the medic list implying that you are medic?
Doesn't sound like it, but JeeJee did say that
It's simply what the medics themselves should've come up with (or something similar) if they followed my advice by reading the thread from mafia's point of view and deciding who to kill (and consequently, prot).
which implies that he isn't a medic.
|
On May 20 2009 11:21 Foolishness wrote:
Shikyo, is you putting yourself on the medic list implying that you are medic?
Where did you get that from? It's a list of who to protect.
Time to sleep, I guess.
|
On May 20 2009 11:24 l10f wrote:Show nested quote +On May 20 2009 11:21 Foolishness wrote:
Shikyo, is you putting yourself on the medic list implying that you are medic? Doesn't sound like it, but JeeJee did say that Show nested quote +It's simply what the medics themselves should've come up with (or something similar) if they followed my advice by reading the thread from mafia's point of view and deciding who to kill (and consequently, prot). which implies that he isn't a medic.
Mm, good point. Makes sense. ...But he still could be, I wouldn't rule it out. He knows enough about what he's doing that if he wanted to not let anyone know, that would be the way to go. Or just to add further confusion, hoo-rah!
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
