Quarterly Mafia (August 2023) - Page 17

On August 25 2023 23:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:

We have to agree to disagree here then. Because what i see is a player who bases their reads (especially early on) fully and completely to meta. The first post would be fine if he just said "i dont think Koshi would want to get lynched as mafia like this", but instead he bases it on a meta on Koshi where Koshi has never wanted to be lynched as mafia. This does not go well with the fact that his meta suggests that "Koshi doesn't do that as any alignment". Aka it should be a null tell for him, and especially the first post he made suggesests that he should not have that conclusion about Koshi's alignment based on what he gives as a reasoning.

On August 25 2023 22:12 LightningStrike wrote:
Morning guys. Marv, Rayn, and Koshi so far looks town from what I had read. Marv because his attitude seems a bit different from last game. Koshi due to his attempt to get himself lynched when he doesn't do that as mafia. Rayn because he actually trying to move things forward and trying to actually solve the game.

On August 25 2023 22:41 LightningStrike wrote:
Nope not that I remember but I think it's more town indicated of him though.

On August 25 2023 23:44 iamperfection wrote:
Im not getting huge scum vibes from LS early vibes. I felt the same thing about his forced ai point about jacob. Since i had already made those jokes sort of before the game and at the start.

On August 25 2023 21:31 die_meatbaby wrote:
Hey good morning guys. I didn't read the thread yet. Still nice to see you all again.

On August 25 2023 23:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:

So why does a player who plays only by meta early on contradict his own meta read on someone?

Do tou have an answer for that for a townie?

On August 25 2023 23:51 iamperfection wrote:

is that even true. Seems like a flawed way to play to me. I doubt its true.

On August 25 2023 23:22 DarthPunk wrote:


You are the LS whisperer apparently.

I didn't like how he used IRL to exit the thread as soon as he was under pressure.

Reminds me of the last time he was mafia.



Also, this: very disconnected from the thread, no one thinks this so why is he asking this? the position on Jacob generally is slight town read.

It's like a halfhearted effort to change the direction of the discourse from himself, to like the most out their topic before he nopes out of the thread.

On August 25 2023 23:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I can tell you though that 95% of LS reads are based purelyon meta, when he is town.

On August 25 2023 23:46 Koshi wrote:



LS was mafia in my last game and I wouldn't have guessed it on D1. So I will take your read in consideration but to me it seems he makes a meta read that I wouldn't do it as mafia. Not because I never did it, but that I wouldn't do it based on my previous playstyle as mafia.

He also elaborated it like that when pressed so story checks out.

On August 26 2023 00:00 raynpelikoneet wrote:

He made the read because its not your mafia!meta.
Whwn questioned, he said its not your town!meta either.

If honest, he should not read you anything because his meta suggests a null!read.