Newbie Student Mafia XXX - Page 70

On October 03 2019 09:53 Tubesock wrote:
Why would mafia rb Branch? Won’t he just die and then rb HF.

On October 03 2019 10:01 Holyflare wrote:
Also cake why are you being so weird? You've lost all kinds of motivation and suddenly it's all about no lynching and not voting?

On October 03 2019 10:22 CopCake wrote:


Yes, like I want to lynch Shockey

But then I got called childish for having a strong read and asking you questions.

So I am like

🤷🏽‍♀️

All will lost.

I will sheep you.

On October 03 2019 10:55 CopCake wrote:
My two cents is that mafia is vivax and shockey

Yeah there are worlds in which GB and HF could be mafia but

1.- Just by poe, GB/Vivax/Shockey and even Tube I dont understanf why GB would carry the night one kill when mafia know that there could be a tracker. If GB was mafia and is soooooooooo good like Vivax say... why would he allow himself to carry it when HF and Him have history? And they both get extremely paranoid?

The only problem I have with GB are his wishy washy? Change of votes. Like I could understand the first two but this round... the “Hey cake vote vivax” it is like... why do you need me to vote?

If HF is mafia is only if he is mafia with Shockey, which is why I want to lynch him also, that way we could have a 100% town HF for everybody.

On October 03 2019 11:04 Tubesock wrote:
I think in a 9 player game, mafia would assume town has either doc or a cop since those are the usual roles. In 13 player games they’re usually those two. It’s not that often there’s a tracker in minis.

On October 03 2019 11:02 CopCake wrote:
I mean HF was also already after me and GB so why Mafia GB would carry the kill if he could be blocked/tracked/etc when he was in the middle of the hurricane for town with that sudden change of read on Ewya.

On October 03 2019 11:06 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Ok, think about it this way, I'm not mafia. Now what are your reads?

Also why does town want to give up a kill on a possible mafia? If there's two people that are mafia, we have a 29% chance of killing one of them now. If there's three mafia, we have 43% chance.

If you Lynch me that's going to give a ton of odds over to mafia. I personally think there's a possibility of godfather, and role blocker. It's a NEWBIE game, why not teach both roles while at it.

Also I'm going to follow up in like 30mins with a big post. Just need to write it out. Then I won't be back for a till late.

On October 03 2019 11:10 Holyflare wrote:


You're using hindsight. I don't think gb was really scum read by anyone but me at the time and I certainly don't think they thought I'd be tracker.

Also, sorry you're feeling shitty. You've done well imo at giving reasons for why you think/thought shockey is mafia.

On October 03 2019 11:10 Holyflare wrote:


You're using hindsight. I don't think gb was really scum read by anyone but me at the time and I certainly don't think they thought I'd be tracker.

Also, sorry you're feeling shitty. You've done well imo at giving reasons for why you think/thought shockey is mafia.

On October 03 2019 11:14 CopCake wrote:


Yeah but with poe we have vivax, tube and shockey as town reads? By almost all? Why give the kill to the most heated person at the time (GB). With heated I mean by you :p

On October 03 2019 11:11 FreezingFoot wrote:


I don’t mean to offend you, but nothing you say is relevant to the game and your reads are mostly based on WIFOM.

So, we have Holyflare saying he didn’t track tubesock into me. Who are you going to vote?

On October 03 2019 11:18 ShoCkeyy wrote:


No offense taken, but that may also be the mafia talking. Cause I know damn well I'm not mafia. And I think I play an ok mafia role, so I think I can find them easily.

On October 03 2019 11:19 Holyflare wrote:
I think it's GB + one of tube/vivax/shockey though, 100%. There's no way I believe a town GB has this much resolve to hold back from calling me mafia all of a sudden. The sudden change of personality just looks like he's attempting to get people on his side (especially me, so many attempts to try and buddy me).

Then he miraculously decides shockey isn't the lynch over vivax even though he's called shockey mafia for the past 2 days with almost no content from either? Don't buy it.