|
On September 30 2019 12:20 FreezingFoot wrote:
@HF
I didn't realise Eywa didn't really believe in his points. I know he wrote he was mocking cases, but I didn't take it literally. I mean, he was scumreading Branch for reasons outside the game? I didn't see a post where he said that. I scumread him because I kept pushing him and he kept being evasive. I thought he was tunneled and that his tunnel was fake. That's an easy option for mafia IMO. Selecting a player, nitpicking his posts and keep being tunneled. So I thought he was mafia.
The thread wasn't moving on. There wasn't much to work with and he wasn't answering me. He just kept being sarcastic. I thought "Am I actually missing something?". Then I decided to re read the thread. What made me think Branch was mafia was the way he reacted to Eywa every time, and this read got stronger when he actually started posting only when I was pushing him too. It looked like he felt he was in danger and had to defend himself or he would get lynched.
I said that I could see why Eywa could be town because it appeared to me that he truly believed Branch slipped, and his reactions of being overly defensive and discrediting Eywa's ability to play the game was a strong indicative. I could see a townie so certain of his reads that every questioning of his reasons would be stupid.
I take issue with the bolded part. You are condusing cadaulity with coincidence. The reason I started posting at that time, was because it was ehen I got back to an internet connection.
|
On September 30 2019 08:22 CopCake wrote:This quote bothered me a lot. Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 00:59 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 30 2019 00:51 Tubesock wrote:
I’m here for a little bit.
I don’t think we should kill any of the actives. HF, Cop, GB are likely all town. CopCakes seems to misread nearly everything, just look at what she just said to Vivax concerning me. GB has always said inconsistent things and been a bit wild when he’s town. As HF said, he always thinks he’s mafia.
As this is a 20 page game on D2, I think the odds of mafia being afk and forgetting to submit the nk are not insignificant. And further being such a low activity game, it’s even more likely mafia is lurking. So, why are we trying to kill the actives? HF or GB whos side are you on? So I decided to filter you. Show nested quote +On September 29 2019 20:52 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 29 2019 19:03 Vivax wrote:
Good thing branch has posted. Bad thing he appeara really salty about being scumread.
Could use a few reads instead of a frothing mouth. Copcake and HF are obviously showing interested in cooperating to solve the game. Strongest town performance of d2 so far.
I appreciate HFs explanation + case on GB, it is built on logical foundations and well argued. As far as Im concerned GB could be a good lynch based on HFs work today. Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 06:14 Branch.AUT wrote:
It's too early to commit my vote for the day. Too mich can happen on the next 20 hours.
Right now I am excluding copcake, vivax and myself. You think HF made an excellent work on GB which is your top mafia read but he is not town enough to be on your list. Yeah, no. Posts like "which side are you on" are scummy, to me. It only invites people to take sides which you shouldn't if you are town, you look for the truth.
I agree, that was a horrible post. My coach already yelled at me, so theres no need to do so further.
As far as HF is concerned, I am not certain he is town yet. The last game I played with him, he really went after people, pushing and yelling at them to vote his target. Now he certainly lacks that fervor. His arguments are well prepared, and sound,but he himself is nowhere near invested enough in his read to force it into everybody. It is because of this lack of zeal from HF that I am not voting GB.
HF also was very eager to let everybody know multiple times that he "absorbed kp", which might already be a setup to counterclaim/discredit someone that eventually might claim the N1 nokill.
For this two reasons I am not sheeping him, and considering him to be possible scum.
|
Need to catch the train soon and Ill be in there for most of the day today.
|
|
|
On September 30 2019 12:45 FreezingFoot wrote:
I'm sure we should lynch Branch today. He seems the perfect "newbie mafia" player, and his flip would help a lot to figure out the game.
If anyone other than me, Cop and HF gets lynched today, I can't be really arsed since I didn't read anything really memorable from the other players.
I'm certain that lynching me gives zero information, as I am flipping green and you are none the wiser.
HF is a much better lynch in my opinion, as a redflip there confirms GB town.
##vote HF
|
On September 30 2019 15:18 Vivax wrote:
Kill BF
Kill HF instead!
|
On September 30 2019 08:22 CopCake wrote:This quote bothered me a lot. Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 00:59 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 30 2019 00:51 Tubesock wrote:
I’m here for a little bit.
I don’t think we should kill any of the actives. HF, Cop, GB are likely all town. CopCakes seems to misread nearly everything, just look at what she just said to Vivax concerning me. GB has always said inconsistent things and been a bit wild when he’s town. As HF said, he always thinks he’s mafia.
As this is a 20 page game on D2, I think the odds of mafia being afk and forgetting to submit the nk are not insignificant. And further being such a low activity game, it’s even more likely mafia is lurking. So, why are we trying to kill the actives? HF or GB whos side are you on? So I decided to filter you. Show nested quote +On September 29 2019 20:52 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 29 2019 19:03 Vivax wrote:
Good thing branch has posted. Bad thing he appeara really salty about being scumread.
Could use a few reads instead of a frothing mouth. Copcake and HF are obviously showing interested in cooperating to solve the game. Strongest town performance of d2 so far.
I appreciate HFs explanation + case on GB, it is built on logical foundations and well argued. As far as Im concerned GB could be a good lynch based on HFs work today. Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 06:14 Branch.AUT wrote:
It's too early to commit my vote for the day. Too mich can happen on the next 20 hours.
Right now I am excluding copcake, vivax and myself. You think HF made an excellent work on GB which is your top mafia read but he is not town enough to be on your list. Yeah, no. Posts like "which side are you on" are scummy, to me. It only invites people to take sides which you shouldn't if you are town, you look for the truth.
I would like to know how you arrive at this conclusion that GB is "my top scum read"? As far as Im aware all I did was comment on how HF put together a logiced case. And the narrative he spins fita the thread. As far as I remeber I never called GB scum, never even thought GB was scum.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On September 30 2019 15:14 Branch.AUT wrote:Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 08:22 CopCake wrote:This quote bothered me a lot. On September 30 2019 00:59 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 30 2019 00:51 Tubesock wrote:
I’m here for a little bit.
I don’t think we should kill any of the actives. HF, Cop, GB are likely all town. CopCakes seems to misread nearly everything, just look at what she just said to Vivax concerning me. GB has always said inconsistent things and been a bit wild when he’s town. As HF said, he always thinks he’s mafia.
As this is a 20 page game on D2, I think the odds of mafia being afk and forgetting to submit the nk are not insignificant. And further being such a low activity game, it’s even more likely mafia is lurking. So, why are we trying to kill the actives? HF or GB whos side are you on? So I decided to filter you. On September 29 2019 20:52 Branch.AUT wrote:On September 29 2019 19:03 Vivax wrote:
Good thing branch has posted. Bad thing he appeara really salty about being scumread.
Could use a few reads instead of a frothing mouth. Copcake and HF are obviously showing interested in cooperating to solve the game. Strongest town performance of d2 so far.
I appreciate HFs explanation + case on GB, it is built on logical foundations and well argued. As far as Im concerned GB could be a good lynch based on HFs work today. On September 30 2019 06:14 Branch.AUT wrote:
It's too early to commit my vote for the day. Too mich can happen on the next 20 hours.
Right now I am excluding copcake, vivax and myself. You think HF made an excellent work on GB which is your top mafia read but he is not town enough to be on your list. Yeah, no. Posts like "which side are you on" are scummy, to me. It only invites people to take sides which you shouldn't if you are town, you look for the truth. I agree, that was a horrible post. My coach already yelled at me, so theres no need to do so further. As far as HF is concerned, I am not certain he is town yet. The last game I played with him, he really went after people, pushing and yelling at them to vote his target. Now he certainly lacks that fervor. His arguments are well prepared, and sound,but he himself is nowhere near invested enough in his read to force it into everybody. It is because of this lack of zeal from HF that I am not voting GB. HF also was very eager to let everybody know multiple times that he "absorbed kp", which might already be a setup to counterclaim/discredit someone that eventually might claim the N1 nokill. For this two reasons I am not sheeping him, and considering him to be possible scum.
Lol this guy is confirmed town answer I will never ever vote him
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I did read your case cop and I'll get back to it at some point
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Tempting to let gb live because I didn't hate his response.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
But then he wrote 3 lines about other people and none of it was original thought.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Fuck it.
##unvote
##vote boxerfred
|
Now youre just throwing out weird shit to get people to post. It worked!
|
On September 30 2019 18:37 Holyflare wrote:
I did read your case cop and I'll get back to it at some point
So what you think of shockey, who I somehow "piggyback off all game" and scumread as a likeable lynch at the same time?
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On September 30 2019 21:10 Branch.AUT wrote:Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 18:37 Holyflare wrote:
I did read your case cop and I'll get back to it at some point So what you think of shockey, who I somehow "piggyback off all game" and scumread as a likeable lynch at the same time?
I thought he was really townie from reading through but today he's not at all. I skimmed through cop's case last night but don't really remember it and I feel like there were a few non-points. The donating his vote to someone else every single day seems important though.
I'll read him at some point I guess but boxerfred promised activity and didn't deliver and we have what, 3 hours to deadline?
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
And I don't know what you're talking about "somehow piggybacked" if you read my first big catch up post you'd see exactly what I'm talking about. Did you not read it but say you did?
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Just so you know, it's against the rules to talk about your coach in the thread so you're basically confirmed town. Don't waste a vote on me, especially if you like the content I've produced? I don't know who I'm supposed to be yelling at to lynch because I've been pretty vocal about lynching gb until his return.
|
On September 30 2019 23:09 Holyflare wrote:
And I don't know what you're talking about "somehow piggybacked" if you read my first big catch up post you'd see exactly what I'm talking about. Did you not read it but say you did?
I didn't get it either. It's you that came up with it.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On September 30 2019 23:13 Branch.AUT wrote:Show nested quote +On September 30 2019 23:09 Holyflare wrote:
And I don't know what you're talking about "somehow piggybacked" if you read my first big catch up post you'd see exactly what I'm talking about. Did you not read it but say you did? I didn't get it either. It's you that came up with it.
ShoCkeyy came up with something on copcake and you essentially said the same post as him when you came back later to apply pressure on copcake. It was good pressure but not original thought.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
