EPT[M][T] Secret Hitler, Act I, Take II - Page 40
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 08 2018 08:07 Rels wrote: I think your plan is a good way to play the game from your position, where you're unsure of kita / me. But you still should push for who you think is townier to pass their teams. The problem is there might be some dumb townspeople who can ruin this shit, so i'd rather take my chances on having two chances on passing one team before me than one. If you can convince people to accept you+grack over kita+grack then i can vote no here. It's up to you. | ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
On November 08 2018 08:11 raynpelikoneet wrote: The problem is there might be some dumb townspeople who can ruin this shit, so i'd rather take my chances on having two chances on passing one team before me than one. If you can convince people to accept you+grack over kita+grack then i can vote no here. It's up to you. I'm pretty sure everyone outside of kita / krogan likes me more than kita. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
| ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
 finally it feels good to play this game | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On November 08 2018 08:13 Rels wrote: finally it feels good to play this gamelol passing 3 straight liberal policies didn't feel good, but getting a shot at getting elected does? Okay  | ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
On November 08 2018 09:19 kitaman27 wrote: lol passing 3 straight liberal policies didn't feel good, but getting a shot at getting elected does? Okay nope, having a real conversation feels a lot better than everyone scumreading me or telling me I'm bad | ||
|
Rels
France13467 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
Unless you for some reason think i am mafia (Conversion's alignment doesn't even matter here). It is true i would have maybe played liberal card as scum in the first mission with krogan in case i was scum, but i would sure as hell not played a liberal card in the last mission, because there is simply almost no way for me to win giving town 3-0 lead at this point, regardless of how much town credit it gives me. Ironically, if you think both kitaman and Rels are scum, you need to vote yes there too. Because we need to accept one of kita's/Rels' team and pass the other one regardless of the outcome. That way either the investigation will go to closest confirmed town (which is me, feel free to disagree with actual reasoning that is not "i know i am town" -- that's not really any sort of reasoning since it's just stupid), or we enact a liberal policy in either kita's / rels' team, or after that in my team. That would put us in 4-0 (4-1) and it's basically impossible to lose. If i get the investigation i will inv prplhz, i either get town which always wins us the game, or i get mafia, which basically guarantees Rels as town. If that happens, then Conversion's affiliation comes into play. You can always argue that "he got 2L1F and had to pass at least 1L to you" but yeah, other presidents had that chance too, and well.. we can discuss that then, i don't wanna give answers to anyone here. So, please, make use of your time today. Make some actual reads now if you haven't. This is probably the most significant point of the game. Please do not fuck this up if you are town. I'm gonna go to work and i'll be back at last ~2 hrs before the deadline. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 07 2018 06:46 raynpelikoneet wrote: happykrogan have you played secret hitler before? no | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 07 2018 12:42 Rels wrote: The bolded is ridiculous. First, what possible gain would scum would have to lie about something so easily disproved ? Second, there is a disconnect between your two posts. In the first, you say to have assumed that fascists know each other, but you're not 100% sure. In the second post, you're so sure that fascists know each other, so you accuse someone else of lying about it. That makes no sense. the gain is town cred. Also it is a potential scenario if it was correct what I assumed the whole game To your treating players differently scum knows each other: you asked the question first while byj just made one random post about it kita/byj kita has a way bigger filter and talked a lot about other things too, his oneliner was: I don't think X is hitler byj talked in his small filter a lot about hitler and had this random post I think X is scum.because he knows who hitler is In both cases there is a difference | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
| ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 08 2018 20:17 happykrogan wrote: To your treating players differently scum knows each other: you asked the question first while byj just made one random post about it Rels this is 100% correct. He wasnt necessarily doing what you suggested, because this makes perfect sense and is even way more likely than what you said. | ||
|
raynpelikoneet
Finland43270 Posts
On November 08 2018 20:36 raynpelikoneet wrote: Rels this is 100% correct. He wasnt necessarily doing what you suggested, because this makes perfect sense and is even way more likely than what you said. Here is what i have a hard time believing Rels. If you have a narrative (which in itself isnt necessarily scummy) that treating players differently when they had the same thought (which isnt even what happened there -- but thats another thing), then regarding the prplhz chancellor election, why is it a scumtell for krpgan when what he did was all +1'ing me? Like literally, i started questioning prplhz for his jesitative stance, krogan made almoat the same posts i did, i eventually decided to vote yes, krogan followed me. Why is this different? It doesnt matter that you have a townread on me from different things, but you know or think a townie -- aka me -- did that, krogan should never get "scum credit" from that if you actually believe in what you say about how krogan treated you/byj. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 08 2018 13:55 Rels wrote: going to sleep. Grack, Conversion, byj, could you say that you will vote YES to a Grack / Rels team if kita / Grack doesn't pass ? So rayn is happy I know this is not adressed to me, but if kita/grack doesn't go through I would vote yes to a Rels/Grack Team, because I think the plan is good. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
He mentioned that he scumread kita a few times though, before he started with his team. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
So I'll try to do it again later today. Kita hasn't really anything that screams either town or scum. The way rels thinks he has found a scumteam is rather towny (because he built it up from the beginning with adding more pieces - even though I still don't really know what his problem with kita was, he seems to already have had one), but he has a few arguments against me that aren't that great. Also this one I didn't mention yet: On November 07 2018 13:39 Rels wrote: yeah having finished reasing byj and happykrogan's filter, I think byj is town and happykrogan is scum. I expected the opposite to happen when I started reading them. p: I quoted the more damning things above about happykrogan. But even more than that, he posts a lot, but most of his reads are very surface level. He has a lot of posts, but not a lot of reads that are interesting. His "byj is Hitler" post above is one of the exception, as in it's a pretty interesting one, but as said above it doesn't match with his previous stance. His post about prp D2 is also a good read, but he ends up dismissing it and voting YES to the prp team for no apparent reason. The rest is pretty bland. Attacking me because I made lazy oneliners and because my thought process didn't show in the posts I wrote, even though, I told him multiple times that it's actually a town tell for me. Attacking byj about his "plan". The stuff he attacks Conversion with is pretty weak too. the bolded let it look like I attacked him for it, after he said it doesn't apply to him, what I didn't do (I just told Conversion, that I didn't scumread you for inactivity, but wasn't attacking you again) I don't know if that makes him anything. Also now I think that the rayn blowing his thought out of proportion thing could be true, so right now I actually don't prefer kita over Rels, but I plan on looking into both again. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 08 2018 22:14 happykrogan wrote: After reading both filters one time, I am kind of neutral on both. So I'll try to do it again later today. Kita hasn't really anything that screams either town or scum. The way rels thinks he has found a scumteam is rather towny (because he built it up from the beginning with adding more pieces - even though I still don't really know what his problem with kita was, he seems to already have had one), but he has a few arguments against me that aren't that great. Also this one I didn't mention yet: the bolded let it look like I attacked him for it, after he said it doesn't apply to him, what I didn't do (I just told Conversion, that I didn't scumread you for inactivity, but wasn't attacking you again) I don't know if that makes him anything. Also now I think that the rayn blowing his thought out of proportion thing could be true, so right now I actually don't prefer kita over Rels, but I plan on looking into both again. To clarify, I don't have a townread on rels yet, because of some arguments against me, that I don't think are vaild. | ||
|
happykrogan
Germany408 Posts
On November 08 2018 22:16 happykrogan wrote: To clarify, I don't have a townread on rels yet, because of some arguments against me, that I don't think are vaild. and because I don't know where his kita read originally came from | ||
|
prplhz
Denmark8045 Posts
| ||
| ||
