[M][N] Elementary Mafia - Page 59

On June 01 2018 04:41 byj wrote:
##Vote: fuba

What somewhat bothers me is that, if fuba really was town, he didn't get lynched. In that case Mafia probably would've had an easy time to get me lynched considering many people seem to be suspicious of me. That would allow them to be 1 step from victory, and maybe help them with a later Koshi lynch. If both fuba and Koshi were town I see no reason for them to choose Koshi.

On June 01 2018 04:45 GlowingBear wrote:
So your argument doesn't make fuba mafia.

On June 01 2018 05:13 LightningStrike wrote:

They could split their vote to 1:1 on both wagons if both are town though you never thought of that?

On June 01 2018 03:53 fuba wrote:
My two scum are DF and HF, but mostly from a paranoia POV. I'm not entirely sure of it, and generally from my way of scumhunting it's harder to read high-content posters, but I feel like since the moment Jealous was pretty locked in as the lynch, HF's been playing the long game. If DF is scum, then HF was basically able to pull the trigger on one of his scumbuddies D1 without fear and make himself look better in the process (and also making the alternative lynch candidate look townier because they were the counterwagon). He railed against rayn, he railed against GB, he railed against Koshi - either all high content posters who will oppose him or people that had the potential to read him well. People who can oppose his outspoken personality late game. He hasn't gone after (from what I can remember) me, DF, or byj - not sure about LS or Rels - I think they're kinda in the middle. If scum HF is going to survive with a team of himself, Jealous, and DF, he needs to take out those that can oppose him end game and will pursue it to his lynch. He tried to get the doc to protect himself over you, scum tried to take you out last night instead of him. He's not really trying to get other people to post more than they are - he's settling on high content posters and, if he's town, just kind of assuming the low content posters are town for no reason.

DF is kinda there as an afterthought and somewhat because of what I said yesterday. His spot could be filled by someone else - dunno who though. And I'm kind of locked in the thought of HF choosing between which of his two scum mates to hammer D1.

On June 01 2018 05:17 byj wrote:

Why 1:1 if you can just 0:1 and get fuba through?

On June 01 2018 05:24 Holyflare wrote:
On a really surface level kind of bull shit way I think the way LS has been repeatedly defending me is kind of off. Sure, I voted for mafia but that hasn't really stopped a lot of you (rightly) pointing out that I've been underwhelming and ham fisting my way into votes.

On June 01 2018 05:29 Holyflare wrote:
Why are you martyring against nothing LS?

On June 01 2018 05:16 GlowingBear wrote:
You know what, LS?

I'll meta you later at night. For now, there are some posts that makes me think you might be town despite those problems I pointed out. Maybe you truly believe that.

Our best bet today is darthfoley. I'll show why.

On June 01 2018 05:35 LightningStrike wrote:

It was a reaction test did you not read the thread lmao.

On June 01 2018 05:35 GlowingBear wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +

Meh, I started the analysis but it's taking too much effort, maybe I'll do it later. Besides, as I was analysing, I got really confused lol. I'll save this here anyway

On June 01 2018 06:34 Holyflare wrote:


I guess I missed it. Why were you reaction testing GB though and what did you get out of it?

On June 01 2018 05:19 Holyflare wrote:


If I am trying to eliminate people that are capable of talking against me in a game that I have not much time to play in then why do I try and lynch those people instead of just placating them and nking them instead? Why would I sit on an afk jealous and not kill Koshi? Doesn't really add up I'm afraid.

Honestly, I thought Koshi was playing like shit. He wasn't involved in the thread, he threw out random reads that did not align with what I was thinking at all and there was no back and forth with people. He didn't have the Koshi spark at all. Thus, I've been pretty much using this unflipped association to base my entire game off of and it's pretty much backfired. I thought GB's pushes most of the game had ended up nowhere, with him not pushing anything in any direction and then him just looking for outs so that he could afk and do nothing (such as "omg vote hf I'll do nothing more").

Obviously now with the nk things have changed quite a lot. I don't know if he was shot or not. I have no actual reason to believe he was shot at all and think it's quite likely mafia held their shot if they were going to shoot because they'd have to basically kill grack or myself if GB is mafia and that narrows it down later in the game.

I've just tried to apply logic to the day 1 vote count where we lynched mafia with 3 votes but apparently logic does not actually apply since mafia did not try and save their partner in any way, shape or form if GB is town.

On June 01 2018 03:29 GlowingBear wrote:
I have a strong feeling byj is town. His posts seems relaxed, are original, he seems to believe in what he is posting, and seems interesting to get the discussion going. If he is newbie at mafia, I'd expect him to just get silent and let town drown in the lack of information.

So at the moment this is the town circle under my POV:

Byj
Grack
Glowingbear

The three of us must stick together if we want to win this game. Let's discuss a little, okay?
Who should we lynch and why?