[M][N]MafiacalFeast I - Page 157

On April 21 2018 06:49 Calix wrote:
After some cursory thought, I'm thinking my reads haven't changed much.

Sure, CH's claim seems too dumb to come from scum but it also doesn't make any sense coming from town. His uncritical acceptance of Tubesock's D3 claim, for example, does not seem legitimate to me. You can evaluate Tubesock and conclude he's more likely town after filter-diving or something but thinking he's just straight up town despite his 2nd Protective claim doesn't square up from a Jailkeeper's POV to me.

In short, I'm concluding that if there's no town motivation behind the claim then it must be mafia even if it makes little sense from mafia perspective.

Rayn can still be mafia because he's seemingly just done a total 180 on his HF read and now thinks one of HF/ himself is Miller (?) but couldn't care less who the hypothetical second mafia in a CH/??? world would be.

This post isn't that intelligent, insightful or even necessarily coherent but I'm too tired right now to care. If Tubesock and/ or HF are mafia then they can count themselves blessed for having the worst town evah!

##vote raynpelikoneet

On April 21 2018 07:50 currentlyhomeless wrote:


have you actually read my posts? Like you say I misrepresent you and then you write that I accepted tube as town with no critical thinking lol.

Go back and reread my posts. I toneread tube as town going into d3, before he claimed. Specifically, I thought max one of tube/exo/skynx was scum. Also due to the way

D3 tube and exo claim, we killed Skynx. I didn’t really talk about it much in thread except for the miller shit, but I was skeptical of exo at that point more than I was skeptical of tube.

However I decided to accept both of the claims eventually because I thought the timing was too good to be scum. Clearly I was wrong.

After that, we flipped skynx and I had to reeval. I became less confident in all my townreads, but that’s not something I talk about in thread because townreads are easily manipulable. At the time I thought Vivax might be scum due to the fact that I felt he wasn’t reading the thread at all.

Anyway you can go back and reread my posts if you like. Town motivation for my claim is pretty clear. Vivax posted some scenarios before dying. I actually thought he had solved the game with HF & Calix scumteam and that’s why he was going to get shot. If I were scum I would have no reason to shoot Vivax, and then claim jailer when I could have just shot tube and then voted HF with Vivax and rayn.

On April 21 2018 08:09 Tubesock wrote:
CH making the good effort. This is probably the only possible play you have left to do. Get the wifom going on my claim to possibly get me lynched in final three. Or switching my vote to HF due rayn bussing you here.

Best part is if we lynch you now, there will still be enough doubt of why rayn voted you instead of HF for a chance to win in final three.

It’s really good.