|
I wrote some thoughts down today without editing or whatever so I guess I'll post it here.
players alive:
BTDT
Grack
ritoky
Holyflare
Blazinghand
Prison Break
LightningStrike
Tumblewood
Me!
BH/HF dies, or after N2 and someone else dies:
Tumblewood:
Need Tumblewood to “claim” who he saved. Was he RB’d again? Typical setup I assume includes a Mafia RB with a doctor—although, could he be scum saying he got “RB’d” to get a free townie pass? Brags about how good he is at mafia, flies under the radar, names people for an optimal lynch, but just hides under his doctor claim and really does nothing.
Pretty shaky at best if doc/RB doesn’t exist (I have no idea how setups work, so yell at me if I'm being stupid pls), when do we stop giving him a free pass because of his doctor claim, or do we just buy into him being doctor and not contributing to the game with his godly mafia skillz (self-proclaimed)
BH/HF:
Whichever one of BH/HF dies I’m inclined to look into, as both are pretty much in control of town’s direction and information. Very strong possibility of them working together for an endgame by establishing themselves as town leaders (although might be unlikely with the Fidei lynch.. although HF and BH both were not at the beginning of that wagon. this is a speculation at best I’d need to flesh it out more as BH pushed Fidei iirc)
Good possibility of TW-BH/HF team as well. Doctor claim could have been instrumented.. idk this is getting pretty tin foil hatty so I’ll stop
BTDT and PB might be just two townies bickering at each other at who is more scummy. TBH I’m not really suspicious of either of them. PB isn’t actively pushing for anything except replying to BTDT and BTDT is just tunneling in on PB. Not sure(?) why he’s not pursuing anyone else if there’s five people on his list, but eh.
Between these two I’m still more wary of BTDT, but his play seemed much better D2? Still flashes of his D1 “I’m insulted and I’m going to rage” in his last few posts, but honestly dude push other people than PB. You two are shitting up the thread by bickering with each other like HF and Vivax usually did. Push me, push LS, push anyone else on your list and stop quitting halfway through when people argue back. Why do you quote your list of 5 people that are unsure, go “this is a good list” and then not do anything but tunnel on PB for like 10 posts?
Tubesock is still my top town read.
Grack I still have no idea how to read. Lots of jokes, questions, a back and forth with ritoky, jabs here and there, more jokes. shrug. wants to lynch between me and ritoky and I’m town soo what makes me scummy and worthy of a D3 lynch Grack? How about ritoky? especially if you mislynch D3 you’re at LYLO (3 town 2 mafia, is LYLO, right?), assuming TW gets "roleblocked" again and we don't save anyone.
LS just seems lazy.. or doesn’t care as much. I know I stopped caring about D2 basically because game was unfun and I left it to grind other games. hopefully he’ll say more once we get the NK info and on D3.
I want to believe ritoky is town but I might just be biased because he guided me to make reads and helped me make attempts to contribute with reads, but his posts since then have been less than good.
Honestly after N2 I want to hone in on whatever TW is doing because it’s not much (if he’s not dead). I’m not sure why he’s being so inactive if being RB’d means he gets to live and make a lot of good townie plays with him not being NK’d if Mafia are just content. Whoever dies between BH/HF might be scum, but seems a little far-fetched, imo.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
there are no other blues in this game because they would have claimed to save me from vivax and should have traded
I don't think this is an all vanilla game that would just seem really random tbh so I'm just giving TW a pass
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
and I like your above post so keep doing the same
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I don't think you should town read BH here though
|
I'm not really townreading BH. If you or BH dies I'm going to zone in pretty hard on whoever's alive tbh-- I think I just have to be careful because mafia might just end up NKing both of you over 2 days anyways.
That was a post I made after filtering through some of the earlier posts, filters, and reading through D2. I'm hopefully going to be able to get some more answers on D3 as a mislynch would put us in a game-losing situation unless someone not named you or BH steps up... pretty dangerous for town to be two people generating content or posting more and the others either AFKing or tunneling on people instead of trying to force information out of others
I'm going to go get groceries and cook dinner now. I'll be back after NK flip.
|
Blazinghand
United States25559 Posts
On June 09 2017 06:09 Holyflare wrote:
there are no other blues in this game because they would have claimed to save me from vivax and should have traded
I don't think this is an all vanilla game that would just seem really random tbh so I'm just giving TW a pass
I disagree with your setup speculation that there are no non-TW blues.
If you're a blue and you see Vivax vs Holyflare going down, and basically ALL DAY Vivax has more votes on him then HF (which was true, btw! you were never in serious danger or leading in votes except maybe at the very start)... especially if you're someone like the Cop who benefits from more time and not being RBed and so on, there's no need to cc Vivax.
Like, again, Vivax had more votes on him basically all day. He was generally considered scummy. You were not in a significant irrecoverable danger, and by about the halfway point it was clear Vivax would be lynched.
If I were a town cop in this situation I'd keep my mouth shut.
|
Blazinghand
United States25559 Posts
On June 09 2017 06:17 Holyflare wrote:
I don't think you should town read BH here though
I disagree! Everyone should townread me always
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
All right you convinced me, have a town read.
|
Blazinghand
United States25559 Posts
On June 09 2017 06:27 Holyflare wrote:
All right you convinced me, have a town read.
yessssssssss
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
And yeah, you're right about the blue but they should absolutely claim tomorrow, no doubt in my mind.
|
EBWOP: Not an actual game losing situation, but if both of you are town I don't really have a lot of confidence in myself and current town in its state to be able to pull a win out of LYLO
 call me a pessimist
okay gone for real now bbl
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
the problem I have with grack is he's town read almost everybody in the game at some point and I feel like he's narrowed himself down to himself?
I dunno, every time I post a super solid scum read then Grack comes out of left field hard defending them as town or throwing shade and it just feels offffffff and that's my main gripe with him
but then that "i know this is scummy but this is what I would do" post kinda felt good sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
|
town:
tube
btdt
less town:
conv
bh
town edgelord:
hf
not town:
pb
ls
mafia:
grack
tw:
tw
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
if there is a vig they should just RNG their shot, I have faith in the RNG this time
|
grack snap defended vivax not just as town, but as VT for no real reason. he reaches conclusions, then goes and finds justifications. he claims to have read my filter, but demonstrates he hasn't, he wanted the shennanie to land on PB not fid...and also his PB boner disappeared cuz?
i shut up about it yesterday because it is irrelevant, but shit hasn't changed he is still mafia.
|
On June 09 2017 06:34 ritoky wrote:
grack snap defended vivax not just as town, but as VT for no real reason. he reaches conclusions, then goes and finds justifications. he claims to have read my filter, but demonstrates he hasn't, he wanted the shennanie to land on PB not fid...and also his PB boner disappeared cuz?
i shut up about it yesterday because it is irrelevant, but shit hasn't changed he is still mafia.
Could you be a dear and show me where I haven't read your filter?
I also have no clue what my PB boner is but I'd love to hear about it.
|
I think the PB boner may be the last townie you killed.
|
I have conversion and btdt scum
I have the others town
But willing to look into my townreads again
|
On June 09 2017 06:37 Grackaroni wrote:Show nested quote +On June 09 2017 06:34 ritoky wrote:
grack snap defended vivax not just as town, but as VT for no real reason. he reaches conclusions, then goes and finds justifications. he claims to have read my filter, but demonstrates he hasn't, he wanted the shennanie to land on PB not fid...and also his PB boner disappeared cuz?
i shut up about it yesterday because it is irrelevant, but shit hasn't changed he is still mafia. Could you be a dear and show me where I haven't read your filter? I also have no clue what my PB boner is but I'd love to hear about it.
Speak his name and he shall be summoned!
You claimed to have read my filter thoroughly when you made a case on me after I apparently "framed you" with an onegu quote. To which you were completely unaware that I had quoted it 2 days prior as well and was re-quoting it from my own filter. Ergo, someone didn't read like they said they did.
PB boner mostly referencing how he was your top shennanie target but then you did nothing to pursue of further that read...also not too sure how you got there either, until you just randomly declared him town.
I also forgot how you was like. "HF is mafia cuz he doesn't agree with my fid read." Then "I didn't have a strong fid read."
Yeah, mafia.
|
If you want to start an argument we can start one, but don't you dare run off whining and try to guilt trip me again.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
