EPTI want us to be able to form 1 big wagon, and not like 1-2 seperate votes on multiple people so that scum can decide the lynch etc.
But I need a good case before I'll vote someone, I won't vote someone if I have no reason to believe they're scum
[M][N] Generic Mini Mafia II - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
I want us to be able to form 1 big wagon, and not like 1-2 seperate votes on multiple people so that scum can decide the lynch etc. But I need a good case before I'll vote someone, I won't vote someone if I have no reason to believe they're scum | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
Why would scum ever shoot the cop if they can rb? I can't make sense out of that. Unless if you're scum and you roleblocked HF? Also did grack retract his claim at all? | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 20 2017 05:08 Holyflare wrote: Still not mafia. Calling sicklucker mafia but don't want to lynch him though. Noted. Hey are you claiming doc or not. Or if you're mindgaming and don't want to answer, at least tell me you're mindgaming. Because I can't make reads if I don't know who is even claiming what anymore | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 20 2017 05:11 Vivax wrote: I'm confident that TW was the type of mafia that hard townread towns and left everyone else including his buddies and his daily mislynch at something more obfuscate. What do you base this one? Link me to earlier mafia games where he did this? | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 20 2017 05:19 Vivax wrote: He's mentioning all players currently alive here, including yourself and a flipped rayn as town. The only ones he keeps at a waffly level are Palmar, HF, me and SL and to a small extent you. And those are exactly who I'm aiming to lynch this game. Always 1 scum in Palmar and HF and if we don't win, then we get SL. Also this heavily implies one or both of Palmar and HF. Sorry but if you don't see that TW had trouble not keeping his perfect information out of his posts, I don't know how to explain it better to you. So you're aiming to lynch palmar, HF, SL, and maybe me? And somehow this should convince me that you're town? You're stretching. You're either doc or scum which is the reason you're never the lynch today, but your logic is bad You could've easily told him to do that btw because you keep bringing it up now... also you didn't link me to earlier games, where HF did | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
outside of cherry picking TW's posts please, I don't buy that | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 20 2017 12:25 sicklucker wrote: vivax is the doctor... hell I even soft claimed doctor your so tunneled its insane what, you softclaimed doc? so we have 4 doc claims? like I said I'll buy vivax being doc if and only if grack and HF acknowledge this as well I'm here | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
and right now I only receive mystery and sandbagging, nothing I can work with | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
if HF unclaims I'll take vivax as confirmed town if not, it's between the 2 of them, and vivax isn't looking good at all. only reason I'd consider him town is if HF unclaims | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
I'll vote HF because I don't want scum to decide the lynch Still not convinced you're town for the record but I'm not going to be able to convince 4 people after I've already brought up all arguments, and we need a lynch. If HF flips scum you'll receive townie points for pushing it through though At least this lynch is better than palmars because palmar got greenchecked day 1, which gives him over 67% of being town (can only frame 1 of the 3 members, aka 33% it was palmar) | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
But no way we're not lynching HF after everyone wants him dead + he retracted being doc So vivax being doc, palmar being green checked. If it's not grack then it must be LS + SL | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
If HF Flips scum then SL is town | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
We need to come to a consensus once HF flips I don't think they're a likely team tbh | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
I think he's scum regardless of HF's flip tbh If HF is scum I can see him bussing here because if HF dies, it makes LS look better If HF is town then everyone voting him (and palmar before) instead of LS/SL is something to be concerned about | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
Sicklurker is clear for pushing HF over others extremely hard Palmar had green check + opposed HF entire game so also clear Vivax doc | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 21 2017 20:44 Vivax wrote: This is what you call a checkmate by the way. Nobody can ever argue against this, it's cristalline, hard logic. While I understand the frustration for being scumread for this without a chance to defend yourself, it's the nail in the coffin and nothing else is required. While this is indeed a strong argument that makes me want to consider Palmar again, there are 3 even stronger reasons why I won't, and they are: - palmars green check which means even if he's mafia - there's only 33% chance he framed himself - palmar has raised a good point where he said that HF is mafia, and based on palmars play himself it seems townie - HF suiciding and wanting LS dead is something I interpret it as him trying to get people to townread LS and it's working. I also didnt like LS' posting that day I don't think I'd ever vote palmar here | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
Apparently not TW because of the red check. You'd assume they frame the same person every night for consistency' sake. So between HF and Palmar which one is the better frame? | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
On May 22 2017 02:44 Vivax wrote: Why do you assume that mafia picks the frame randomly? Palmar is the roleblocker, had some soft suspicion on him D1, and is generally speaking the most experienced player in the game, with mafias strongest role. He gets checked N1. Do you think that he didn't see that coming? To be honest I didn't think about it that way. In general when someone gets green checked I auto-assume it's correct because often it is, and stuff like godfather, or in this case, framer, are often unlikely. If you guys are certain they'd frame palmar over HF i'd have to reconsider... But it still seems strange that HF would connect to palmar so obviously by outright wanting anyone dead except him? Not sure what to think about that tbh. Palmars posts today seem very townie to me | ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
| ||
|
Prison Break
326 Posts
But I think HF would be trying to kill his teammate there. Because defending makes palmar look bad if HF flips, he seems like a good player so he'd do the opposite. Like he would probably attack LS Because it's so unexpected and people would assume palmar scum instead of LS... which is exactly what he wants. And setting up a mislynch before or after your death is about as good - but this way, he'd also make LS look townier. So I'm inversing my immediate thoughts (defending = scummates), because HF seems like the type to do the opposite. Basically what palmar says: mafia is manipulating people, and intentionally pocketing townies etc. I really doubt palmar would flip mafia to be honest. | ||
| ||
