Newbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 76

On January 14 2017 04:17 darthfoley wrote:


1. She was literally universally townread; basically she was like Kmatt but without the role so she was never gonna MLK
2. Her inquisitive questions towards other people might've scared scum

On January 14 2017 04:15 darthfoley wrote:
Dude you haven't even tried to explain your reasoning behind your scum reads. As Damdred said, if you think Calix is scum, please explain why. The game will continue if we're right about B0ston and it will end if we're wrong so please give a shit?

On January 14 2017 04:17 darthfoley wrote:


1. She was literally universally townread; basically she was like Kmatt but without the role so she was never gonna MLK
2. Her inquisitive questions towards other people might've scared scum

On January 14 2017 04:24 ika42 wrote:


1) she had 2 towns voting her at EOD. not really "universally town read"
2) already gave that idea out on the "she was narrowing the scum pool of who it was"

On January 14 2017 04:22 ika42 wrote:


here the thing, to get any other lynch we need bos in event hes town otherwise he will:

A)be modkilled
B) replaced and still be the scummiest slot

as for explanations: guts and meta and trusting SW.

calix can shit on the dead all she like, it does not change that they are town and thir ideas and thoughts come form a towns mind. thats why i vaule her reads over mine, shes a better player then i cna veer be

On January 14 2017 04:20 Damdred wrote:
How about this ika.

I don't think DarthFoley would take so much of his time (while a lynch is secure) to try to get reads or reactions/reasoning from you as scum.

Do you disagree or agree with this statement and why?

On January 14 2017 04:24 ika42 wrote:


1) she had 2 towns voting her at EOD. not really "universally town read"
2) already gave that idea out on the "she was narrowing the scum pool of who it was"

On January 14 2017 04:25 Calix wrote:


I see a glimmer of a valid point here with your first line if you're arguing what I think you're arguing.

On January 14 2017 04:27 Damdred wrote:


Both towns were dead by the time the kill happened, and one of the town voting on her was lynched. So your first point is kinda a non point all alive players were town reading SK basically.

While I appreciate teh sentiment about peoples reads beig better she never really finished her reads list we just have three people thrown out asked if someone else liked the team. The thread can't really know where she was going with it really.

On January 14 2017 04:25 darthfoley wrote:


ME's vote was pure salt, and as we know btdt didn't know what the hell he was doing this game

On January 14 2017 04:26 ika42 wrote:


yes. if theres anythingn that makes me more paranoid then ever is when someoen does this kind of stuff or makes this kind of reasonsing

i cant even begin to count the number of games scums have used the "well treat him like town and work with him" meathod to try to manipulate me.

this is why i just want the god damned day to be over, im paranoid about fucking everything and i have nobody i can trust to tlak ot

On January 14 2017 04:27 ika42 wrote:


go ahead and say it, im too tired to try to see if this mirrors the reason im thinking

On January 14 2017 04:29 ika42 wrote:





both of these do not change the point they were town nor does it change that she had votes on her.

i mean if you really want to make the argument about it, matt is confirmed town and he didnt die. so it leads to one or more of the reasons that have beens tated. i dont get why all the reasons have to be exclusive to each other

On January 14 2017 04:27 ika42 wrote:


go ahead and say it, im too tired to try to see if this mirrors the reason im thinking

On January 14 2017 04:29 Damdred wrote:


If you think B0ston is town (which you still haven't answered yet) then it doesn't matter and he should just fuck off as the game is over at this point.

Darths other scum games though don't really even remotely look like doing things to make myself look good when I don't have to but meh. That part really isn't important, and honestly theres probably three easy town reads in the thread in my mind so just need to make the effort.

On January 14 2017 04:30 Calix wrote:


What I got out of that was that you are put at a disadvantage with trying to lynch anyone else because if Boston is town then you have one less town vote to stack on your scum-reads.

Although I'm not sure why you wouldn't be voting Onegu if that was the case so idk.

On January 14 2017 04:32 Calix wrote:
Wait, I thought your scum team was Onegu/ Calix/ DF. What changed?

On January 14 2017 04:34 ika42 wrote:


im gonna say this once as calmly as possible cus im about to reach overtilt: i have no clue who the scum team is at this point and until the bos lynch is done i don't feel like trying to make worlds out of it