[M][N] Murder on the Cruise Trip Mafia - Page 99

On October 07 2016 20:13 Superbia wrote:


So let me get this straight. You haven't decided if Palmar is mafia or town yet but you're already putting up a defense?

Why not first decide he's mafia or town and then approach from there?

On October 07 2016 20:14 marvellosity wrote:

why? i don't even understand why you're asking this, so i'm just going to ignore it as unimportant

On October 07 2016 20:15 marvellosity wrote:
okay I kinda see Superbia. I'm asking Palmar to explain my motivation for my actions in the scenario I outlined.

That's not a defence, that's me wanting to know if he has a reasonable explanation.

On October 07 2016 20:16 Superbia wrote:


Read his stuff and then call him mafia or town plox.

On October 07 2016 20:16 Superbia wrote:


Read his stuff and then call him mafia or town plox.

On October 07 2016 20:17 Koshi wrote:

This. Make it really simple for the simple souls pls.

On October 07 2016 20:17 marvellosity wrote:

go away. every time you talk to me you ask me stupid things or want me to do things. do your own things. i'll do my things.

thx.

On October 07 2016 20:18 Superbia wrote:


I thought my posts were making you smile earlier? ;(

On October 07 2016 20:15 marvellosity wrote:
okay I kinda see Superbia. I'm asking Palmar to explain my motivation for my actions in the scenario I outlined.

That's not a defence, that's me wanting to know if he has a reasonable explanation.

On October 07 2016 20:16 marvellosity wrote:
Palmar: please explain your EoD / HF reads

thank you

(you've really not done enough to justify me coming off you - saying with great certainty that i should be coming off you by now is a falsehood, as you and i both know i have voted for you for certain periods of time when you were town in many, many games)

On October 07 2016 20:17 marvellosity wrote:

go away. every time you talk to me you ask me stupid things or want me to do things. do your own things. i'll do my things.

thx.

On October 06 2016 02:35 justanothertownie wrote:
So, those are the people I would not be willing to lynch today as of now:

Koshi: There is no point in wasting my time on him. When he comes back he is either normal town Koshi or you lynch him. Pretty straight forward.

Marv: Not 100 % town but he has done enough typical stuff that I won't even entertain lynching him.

nu: Not gonna lie - his play since the very active start has been less than subpar. But he has that gamey shit going for him which almost always comes from town.

These I wouldn't lynch without a good case (which has to come between now and like 30 minutes later because I will be gone):

Palmar: If you want to lynch him you need to get the wagon going way earlier. You can never know his alignment before he is forced to actually play the damn game. He is really underwhelming though and his aimless rambling earlier did not feel very palmarlike.

Holyflare: Always hard to tell with him and like I said his push on me was really opportunistic and bad. Shitflingy if you want. But I think a mafia HF wouldn't have stopped going after me this easily once he had already started to. Felt like he actively avoided an unnecessary shitfight which I do not think scum HF would do. If he suddenly turns against me again when I am gone he is probably mafia.

Damdred: His presence is severely lacking and batsnacks is right when he says that there was very little damdy questioning going on. But I really liked his perspective on the game when he arrived. It mirrored my own quite well.

Oats: Made an easy thowaway scumread against me and then didn't care about me at all anymore (I might be biased but that seems quite disinterested to me). Some really bad logic that I pointed out but I guess thats par for the course for him. Really really forgettable though.

I could lynch (roughly in order from worst to best lynch):


Stutters: If this was an open setup with a vig I would be against lynching him but we don't know that. Maybe it still would be optimal to wait for a night and see if he gets shot by a vigilante before getting rid of him by a lynch but if you for some reason need to shennany onto someone eod he is a good target.

Calix: At first I was really sold by the fearless and aggressive way she plays but I have to remember that she is only new to this site and apparently a decent scumplayer. If you have that in mind then there are several problems with her play. Starting from the way she treated nu in the beginning despite him apparently being the easiest read in the world up to the total brainfart she made when asked about her grack read.

batsnacks: This is not the batsnacks I know. I don't know if it is mafia batsnacks but he is very different. Incomprehensible defense of Superbia because "being afraid makes no sense as mafia". But he has really been digging himself a hole all game if he is mafia. Besides the superbia read there is also his accusation against me (mafia for encouraging anti-town behaviour) which is so poor and weak that it is almost comical. Why does mafia batsnacks try to attack me like that? It is so pointless. Really horrible politician posts though...

Superbia: Refuses to play the game. Agressive/hostile tone fit his scummeta perfectly. Nowhere to be seen all day today.

Grackaroni:
Made a case against me immediately when 1-2 people suddenly started suspecting me when I was gone yesterday. A really lazy and factual problematic case as I have explained lately. He also just harddefended Calix without even knowing what the problem was with her posting. Otherwise he is just existing in this game without doing much.

On October 07 2016 20:14 Koshi wrote:
On the other hand. Grack busses superhard and supercold.

On October 07 2016 20:20 Palmar wrote:

I don't have a reasonable explantion.

On October 07 2016 20:22 Grackaroni wrote:

I don't think I'm that heavy of a busser. The last game was just me hedging on Tumblewood and then jumping on the wagon once it looked like he was getting lynched.

It only ended up looking super silly like that because when we were one vote away a string of people refused to lynch Tumblewood.

But the NK, his play, his lack of enthusiasm for some things and just some tonally weird things, all point to marv-mafia. Not to mention, both HF and I picked up a townie vibe from batsnacks, and marv completely failed to recognize it.