[M][N] Star Wars: Rogue 1 Hype Mafia

On August 29 2016 10:33 Holyflare wrote:


Also, if you're using this metric why are you going after Koshi and not hopping aboard the Disformation is mafia train with me? None of disformation's post can be mistaken for jokes, a lot of them defend people (Rels) and then scum lean them (based off a 2 letter post....)?

Also, everyone that is following the Palmar wagon on Rels and has said nothing more is in major cop out mode and I will be coming after you big time.

On August 29 2016 06:35 Trfel wrote:
Please explain?

On August 30 2016 08:49 DanelerH wrote:
Tumblewood, do you mind clarifying something for me?



Why did you refuse to elaborate on Palmar being Mafia?

On August 29 2016 05:55 disformation wrote:
now that I am conf. town, you ppl can fight over who gets to carry me. <3

On August 29 2016 05:59 Trfel wrote:
Beentheredonethat is the worst cohost on TL.

I didn't think he would be cruel enough to make me mafia two games in a row

On August 30 2016 12:30 DanelerH wrote:
That reminds me. Tumblewood, in addition to Palmar, you also suspected Koshi of being Mafia. Why are they suddenly under "null/don't care yet"?

On August 31 2016 01:37 DanelerH wrote:
Vivax, at the beginning of the game, Disformation and Trfel each made a joke about being confirmed Town and Mafia (respectively). For some reason, you felt the need to respond to these. Why is this?

On August 29 2016 06:31 Palmar wrote:
ok is no one going to ask me how I came up with my theory? what is this?

On August 31 2016 03:23 DanelerH wrote:


This seems like an odd list. I don't recall you ever saying anything about Geript being suspcious.

On August 31 2016 03:49 disformation wrote:

hm.

Yo scott what happened?

On August 31 2016 05:44 DanelerH wrote:


There actually is a reason for that. I was going back over everyone's filters and found a few questions I wanted to ask. In each case, there was an answer they could have given that would have directly contradicted something that they said around the post I was quoting. Unfortunately, that ended up being fruitless. Luckily, I noticed Scott had disagreed with lynching Geript, despite having listed xym in the list of people to lynch. Because of this, I'm going to change my vote to Scott.

##vote Scott

On August 31 2016 04:03 scott31337 wrote:


It has to do with this posting I read yesterday - he did his "scroll through and point out" thing - but I have no idea where he stands of who he wants to lynch. I don't want to quote everything, but there's three townreads (HF, vivax, Koshi) and he likes your read progression - does he Scumread RB? Like I have no clue besides a few town reads where he stands.

He'd be at the bottom of the three I listed.

On September 02 2016 00:39 DanelerH wrote:
I have no qualms with lynching Palmar, however I thought I would look into some other people that are currently under suspicion. One of these people is Tictock. In xyr filter, I found something very interesting: + Show Spoiler +

Notice how Rels is listed under "Null," but Vivax is listed under "Scum lean." The reason why this is odd is because it doesn't match with Tictock's vote: + Show Spoiler +

If you look at the timestamps in each of these, you'll see that the Rels vote was on before being suspicious of Vivax. Yes, Tictock was an early supporter of the Rels lynch, but it's strange that xe never changed the vote to Vivax.

On September 02 2016 02:06 DanelerH wrote:
I'm fairly suspicious of Scott. In addition to the posts Vivax pointed out here, I still find the read on Geript strange: + Show Spoiler +

One of the strange things about this is Scott had previously stated that xe disagreed with the Geript case: + Show Spoiler +

Granted, Scott clarified it, but it's still strange that xe didn't say anything about Geript between the above two posts: + Show Spoiler +

What it doesn't clear up, though, is that xe never said anything about Tumblewood being suspicious, either (something that Trfel mentioned earlier). In fact, I may just be missing it, but I can't seem to find anything about Scott saying Tumblewood is suspicious. The last thing about Scott is the spreadsheet. More specifically, what happened when xe was asked for it. Scott was asked to post the spreadsheet xe has for this game (which xe mentioned xe has), but hasn't even acknowledged request, depsite having been online afterwards.

On September 03 2016 06:45 DanelerH wrote:
The person I want to look into right now is Geript. Day 1 was the only time Geript was suspicious of Tumblewood. As the game progressed to Night 1, the list xe gave for most likely being Mafia consisted of Tictock, Palmar, Scott, Race, and myself. + Show Spoiler +

Admittedly, quite some time has passed since then, but Geript never claimed suspicion on Tumblewood after the fact. Let's go over changes Geript made to the list:

Near the end of Day 2, the two xe was most suspicious of were Vivax and myself. + Show Spoiler +

Shortly afterwards, xe stated that Palmar was most likely Town: + Show Spoiler +

Assuming there were no other changes to the list, it would probably look something like this:
Vivax
DanelerH
Tictock
Scott

Despite all of this, Geript voted for Tumblewood. Xe didn't give any reasoning or even a post (except for in the voting thread). Geript, why is this?

On September 03 2016 22:41 DanelerH wrote:
After looking through Trfel's filter, I don't see anything that points to xem being Mafia. As such, I'm going to place xem under Town. Here is my current list:

Town:
Holyflare
Vivax
Geript
Koshi
Trfel

Mafia:
Tictock
Scott
Palmar

Out of the ones listed under Mafia, I think we should lynch either Scott or Palmar.

On September 03 2016 00:03 Palmar wrote:
I am not mafia, no idea why people still think that's really an option.

I don't have the energy to argue against the train of stupidity that's coming after me. so instead I'll just share what I think is relevant in this game and you guys can then either listen to me now, or you can listen to me later.


Koshi: Almost definitely town. He is, in his own bad way, trying to get the game solved. Also, it's literally his town meta to think I'm mafia and be wrong about it. He's also not just tunneling one thing (for example he's not just tunneling me, he's actually doing other stuff). I liked his case on TW at the time on day 1, although I don't really think TW is mafia but I might be wrong on that. He also gets a massive towncredit for pointing out geript's inconsistency during day 1.

Vivax: Essentially the same as Koshi, effort and stubbornness rating is through the roof compared to what I'd expect of mafia Vivax. He's also being a paranoid baddie which is something he excels at. He has also pointed out inconsistencies (specifically one by geript, I think) that was really good.

Trfel: To me, he's been completely under the radar this game. I might try to open his filter and read it before the evening, but so far I've essentially ignored most of his posts, which is often a good indication that someone is mafia (I tend to ignore mafia because their posts are usually bland and boring).

Scott: I liked one post by him on day 1 so weakest townread ever? I don't really know, another person I have less formed opinion on.

geript: Once again, he's almost lock mafia. His posting has been repeatedly proven to be out of touch with his own reality, and he's basically happy to sit back and let things happen.

Holyflare Another basically lock mafia. I'm almost more sure on him than geript. The main problem is that he barely cared during day 1, no matter how much he wants to make it look like he had a hand in the TW push. Then he came in late, helped with some shenanigans that to me made little sense (why didn't he try to shennie onto geript instead?). But even then he was light on actual content. Then during the night he starts hammering me for literally something he made up (trying to paint me bad for the Rels thing). there is 0% chance holyflare actually thinks what he says he's thinking. He's also quite a bit better at scumhunting than Koshi and Vivax and thus should know better than to think I'm mafia.

TW I don't know much about his posting today, but I sort of agreed with koshi's initial case, but he didn't sound like mafia when we were talking in the thread. So while I'm not gonna go overboard with it, I think he's more likely to be town.

Danieler No idea, not really read his filter much. I think I liked something he said, but I can't remember what or why. Like I don't have him in my mental "these people are scum" group.

Tictock Not really read up on him again. I basically gave him a townread when he posted the gif-reads on day 1 and I've not bothered with him since. Maybe it's time, but I think there's much higher mafia chance people.

On September 04 2016 23:56 DanelerH wrote:


This post specifically? It's odd that you want me to look at a specific post, but here:

The main problem is that Palmar doesn't have an opinion on one person (Scott) and hasn't read the filters of three others (Trfel, DanelerH, Tictock). At that point in the game, that was nearly half the players.

Another issue I have with the post is the Geript read. As I have already said, it doesn't make sense for Geript to be Mafia. Granted, this was before the Day 2 lynch, but Palmar's read on Geript hasn't changed.

The last issue I have is giving Town-reads for ridiculous reasons. For Scott, it was because of liking a post on Day 1 (granted, Palmar admitted to this being a weak read and classified it as "no opinion"). For me, xe thinks xe liked something I said (but can't remember) and I'm "not in [xyr] mental 'these people are scum' group". For Tictock, it was because of liking the images for reads.

On September 01 2016 10:39 scott31337 wrote:


This post has townie feels or you just changed your "meta" so much that I've read before, fuck it man.

I'm going back to watching Trump's speech though in my home town.

##Unvote

On September 06 2016 04:31 Tictock wrote:


Geript has been extreamly dull to me this game. I recall him having a bit more personality and drive. Votes/pushes have indeed felt pretty uninterested.

Yea I could sheep this.