[M][N]A Wonderful Normal Game of Mafia

On May 04 2016 00:31 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
so you guys don't want to policy lynch palmar for not being here day 1?

On May 04 2016 15:37 Alakaslam wrote:

Yes. Indirectly enough though- I apologize.

Do you glean more than you are saying here or no?

On May 04 2016 22:04 Tubesock wrote:


Go ahead.

You've wasted how many pages talking about this thing that you already said you're not gunning for Ricey. You have not scum hunted at all. The one thing you did was ask about a question mark. Even that you said you thought he was town before and after.

On May 04 2016 23:13 Fazers wrote:
I want to lynch him possibly. Why do you guys assume I want to get this man killed?

Just doing what I can to contribute lol, now I look like a fool.

On May 04 2016 00:55 marvellosity wrote:

so why did you use a question mark when you were talking about what shape said

had you genuinely forgot who it was in the 50 posts the game has? could you not have checked if you weren't sure? etc

On May 06 2016 21:15 Killing wrote:
I still have mostly the same reads. It's unfortunate that marv is BP because he was already obvious town. I think our lynches should be Ricey and Ettelex.

There's no way I can't think Ricey is mafia. I personally thought most of his d1 was garbage and I was the only vote on him. I'm not down with the re-reading thing but I remember a few towns saying that he was indeed scummy. I mean I have to think that if he was actually town than some mafia would just BW behind me to get him lynched as I kinda wanted to kill him before you guys just went ham on tubesock for no reason. Point being is that I don't understand why nobody kinda agreed with me and tried to kill ricey when a few people thought he was scummy. Especially considering i'm a new player, I think it'd be super easy to just jump on board on me considering some may think I have no idea what i'm doing although for the most part that's true.

Etellex's giant wall this day felt exactly like a post I wrote in my first scum game. It was like excuse, sorry, weak content. He's prob mafia too.

Dunno who the last one is.

Towns are:
Marv
Kush
Shape
Mig

Fuck that guy:
Palmar

On May 05 2016 00:40 RiceyKins wrote:
Yeah thanks Slam you did answer my question in the other posts.

I'm not sure about a Tube lynch. I see what you're saying but I'm not convinced that just because he's quick to label his town reads he's definitely scum. His reason for voting isn't too great and looking at the last thing he wrote, I have to head out for like 30~ minutes but did Marv ever actually say he thought I was town? I'm skimming but I don't see it.



talking about the bolded

On May 04 2016 10:58 RiceyKins wrote:
I also think going after Shape at this point is just plain bad. At first I thought Shape was a little too friendly with Kush and trying to parrot his opinions but after re-reading his filter that isn't really the case and I think he's made the best points out of any of us so far. So I dunno why out of everybody here he would put the two of us on a list together when honestly speaking we're on opposite ends in terms of contributions for town. That's somewhat strange.

On May 08 2016 03:09 Etellex wrote:


Right now nothing I say holds water because of all the suspicion on me, so first I want to establish that I am in fact not scum before doing anything crazy. As for Kush, I do now think he's town.

What is an interesting possibility is that Palmer actually is scum and when he is revealed it will appear obvious that I am, despite being town. I don't know why someone would go through all that trouble to kill someone who's going to get lynched anyways so I don't think this is 100% the case but in case he does turn out to be mafia I want to have this on record.

On May 08 2016 04:44 justanothertownie wrote:

Why does Palmars read on me influence yours? Do you think he wouldn't townread a fellow scummer like that or what?

On May 08 2016 05:43 Shapelog wrote:

He meant that Ricey (you) is more towny, therefore not sus. And only 1 person on the etell wagon is really sus towards him?

On May 06 2016 18:35 Palmar wrote:
Like to be completely fair, my plan through most of day 1 was to sheep jat.

he's being mean now though so pls.

On May 07 2016 19:55 Palmar wrote:

Btw, Etellex is now my new friend. I don't trust slam as much.

On May 11 2016 02:32 justanothertownie wrote:

I don't think we should use arguments like the "he would concede" one in this situation. I mean, I agree - it would save us all time if that is the team but he is a complete newbie. He might want to fight it out - he might just want to use this opportunity to learn what to do/what not to do the next time he rolls mafia.

But yeah, I am not sold on him either. Seeing how today is going sandro is almost certainly mafia but to me it isn't obvious who number 3 is. It could be anyone out of Etellex/Ricey/Fazers/Slam/Shape as far as I am concerned. Killing has really fallen off a cliff too...

On May 12 2016 07:47 Etellex wrote:
Can someone explain how cop works? I've been searching around for like an hour and I can't find any info. kush said that "killing came back town which means nothing" and I have no idea what that means.

On May 13 2016 02:21 justanothertownie wrote:
Something weird is going on this game. Prior to today noone besides Mig really expressed any strong desire to kill slam over let's say Fazers/Etellex. And now everyone is just showing up to vote slam and leave and somehow he is #1 on everyones list.

On May 13 2016 05:22 Etellex wrote:
Wait, is it nighttime right now? Serious question, I lost track.

On May 13 2016 08:49 Etellex wrote:
So the consensus is that it's either me or Slam? If that's the case then I may as well vote for him.

##Vote: Alakaslam

On May 07 2016 19:55 Palmar wrote:
Which post is actually scummy jat?

Btw, Etellex is now my new friend. I don't trust slam as much.

Also, someone somewhere said I was townreading marv on day 1. That's not really true, I just prefer to not call him mafia until I have a reason to to make my life easier.

Killing still sounds overly hostile and annoyed. he's probably mafia.

On May 06 2016 05:12 Fazers wrote:
@Mig, Unlike Etellex, who posted




I didn't want to vote for Tubesock without reason. At that point in time, he was clearly going to be the one to be lynched with how much time was left. I feel Etellex vote is based simply by following the majority. Scum blending in with town?

On May 09 2016 06:50 Fazers wrote:
##Sandroba

RIP marv - thanks for your contributions. Although you didnt' like my filters :'(

On May 12 2016 23:22 Fazers wrote:
I'm not cop rofl but really, ##vote Alakslam

On May 13 2016 02:02 Fazers wrote:
^ I wouldn't mind Etellex first, actually. He's been on my list to lynch since he first started posting.

##unvote

##vote Etellex

On May 04 2016 10:31 Fazers wrote:
To address your questions:

I want to lynch Killing possibly, he's making a bit of noise. I guess activity is pretty good early on to form
initiative, but a lot of bold accusations imo.

I don't care about people who are inactive in this game so far. It's been a little quiet.

I have a strong opinion about Shapelog - imo he's a strong player from my observations. Thus I will not vote to lynch him on Day 1. However, that may change as days pass.

On May 04 2016 11:09 Fazers wrote:
Yeah I was just throwing it out there. I don't actually have any determination to make sure Killing gets lynched. However, why are the accusations not bold? He's making reads off such little information. He even admits he may sound like an idiot for not like a few posters on his list...it's baseless.

Activity and making reads though is definitely awesome on his part though!

On May 04 2016 23:18 Killing wrote:


It's ok man, I think you're a little townie. But only a little. Like just the tip amount

On May 06 2016 23:57 Killing wrote:


I'm basically on that exact same train except no real good read on alakaslam and I'm leaning a bit townier on fazers but very slight

On May 13 2016 01:47 Killing wrote:
I think that would be my plan. Evaluate meaning reach F3 and evaluate. I don't think JAT is particularly scummy but I'm pretty sure he's a good player and nobody in this game seems to have a solid read on him. I would only lynch him because I believe riceykins and ettelex aren't particularly strong so I think f3 wouldn't be too difficult.

1) Mig Town
3) Fazers Town
4) Etellex Evaluate
6) JAT Lynch
7) Riceykins Evaluate
8) Kush Town
10) Slam Lynch
13) Killing Town

On May 17 2016 01:31 Killing wrote:


Ah the classic concede. I knew it all along.

##vote Fazers

On May 17 2016 02:51 Killing wrote:


Nope because that would be against the rules. So if he is, he can kindly go fuck himself.

On May 14 2016 09:23 Etellex wrote:


What makes this whole situation so difficult is that I most likely would play very similarly if I were mafia. If anything, I suppose I could bring up the point that I've talked about myself a lot, which is one of the things I don't really like doing as mafia. Of course from your perspective there's no way to verify that claim, so it's on me to bring up more reasons.

I tend to be a lot more into mafia games when I'm scum because it's much more of an intense experience to have to carefully engineer my posts and replies in such a way that I appear to be town while simultaneously not giving away my allies. In my town games such as this one I tend to act more natural and relaxed, because I can somewhat rely on the fact that I actually am town to subconsciously write town-sounding posts.

I think I've had a tone of "knowledge is power" this game in regards to investigating me. I have been very open with my thoughts and I have even acknowledged possible arguments against me.

This is a very different post of mine from the rest, because at this time in the game I have much more of a responsibility to not get mislynched, so I'm going to start taking this more seriously and posting more like this.

On May 05 2016 01:09 RiceyKins wrote:


ah ok I can't tell if you meant to say me but said Killing instead there but fair enough.

Kush if we're going to policy lynch I'd rather it be Dr.P I'll copy JAT a bit here is there any reason to lynch Palmar over DrP or any of the others who haven't given us a reason for their absence?

On May 12 2016 17:43 justanothertownie wrote:

Please explain the bolded.

On May 08 2016 00:19 RiceyKins wrote:
hey look it's taken 5 days but Palmar admitted I exist.

On May 07 2016 20:20 marvellosity wrote:
i still don't think jat is mafia, kush.

it's not one of my super-i'm-sure-jat-is-townreads which is always right, but it's definitely stronger than my maybe-he's-town reads which usually means he's mafia.

On May 17 2016 04:09 Mig wrote:
I dont really have a better play that fazers. If one of the last mafia are ricey/killing/jat I would predict the town is going to lose