[M][N]A Wonderful Normal Game of Mafia

On April 26 2016 06:44 Half the Sky wrote:
/obs

(most likely final game on TL is the game I'm currently involved in now, just saying)

On April 27 2016 11:42 Mig wrote:
/in

On May 03 2016 08:02 Tubesock wrote:
Just finished filter diving Kush. I think he's town.

I'll just look at his most important posts.



Entered the thread with a ready critical eye looking to find the scums.



Most "scummy" post. Yet it is really NAI because he just says that he hasn't checked his PM yet. So, maybe going for his ole "not check the PM till the end of Day 1" trick. (I think I read he's done that before).



But see here? Drawing Thrawn in to gain a read. Obviously town leader thus far.

Also, he has 75% of the posts in the game which with high activity auto means town, right?

On May 03 2016 08:50 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:


What have you done that someone could consider scummy?

On May 03 2016 15:22 Tubesock wrote:


You're claiming the ability to PM so obvious Mafia with the Dr. And also telling us that he hasn't shown up in the qt yet.

Also you exaggerate and twist how to spell his name which is definitely Mafia motivation. Also it can confuse town!

Games 49.9995% solved.

On May 03 2016 18:56 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
Slam
Do you actually think scum or anyone else is going to attack you what is obviously a joke?
To me it looks awkward and like you are tryharding to look town.

On May 03 2016 23:18 Killing wrote:
I'd like to confirm that i am safe for d1. please and thank you

On May 04 2016 09:12 Tubesock wrote:
Slam the man:

3 people saw your trap and mentioned something showing they understood it. Does this bother you? Are you goign to follow up on this?

On May 04 2016 13:44 Etellex wrote:


I'm familiar with casualized forms of Mafia like Town of Salem where there's a lot less reading into what people say and more logic/evidence. I've been quiet because I'm at a loss for what to go off of for suspicion.

On May 04 2016 13:54 Tubesock wrote:


Well...guess you better start reading some of the guides that are stickied on this very forum.

On May 04 2016 14:02 Tubesock wrote:


I'd be down for Mig although he's on track for being mod killed.

Dr Thrawn would be my pick of the 4 you listed. I don't think he was buddying Kush at all, but he did not produce any content and had a great chance to and it would have been pretty easy to do.

Slam only because an obsolete metric I used was how much effort he placed in his fishing expeditions. When he was town he would fish till he got something. As mafia he well gave a couple casts and gave up. Kinda like here. But this is a year old at least and he constantly changes his play. Soooo....yeah.

Etellex...I don't even know.

On May 04 2016 14:30 justanothertownie wrote:
Rehearsed? lol
Do you really think if I was mafia with marv we would make such a stupid and completely unnecessary play? Why?

I never lie about rl stuff regardless of my alignment.


I think I agree that thrawn looks the worst from the list I gave based on solely on the fact that Mig didn't post at all while he was clearly around at some point. But saying "slam did more" is like saying homeopathic medicine does more than placebo pills.

On May 04 2016 15:02 Tubesock wrote:
Slam do you want anyone lynched? Or do you have a shortlist you'd be ok lynching?

Do you think anyone is town?

It sounded like Saitama was super intense effort. Maybe there is a happy medium somewhere.

On May 04 2016 14:54 justanothertownie wrote:

I would gladly welcome the saitama. Didn't the saitama post quite a bit though?

On May 04 2016 15:02 Tubesock wrote:
Slam do you want anyone lynched? Or do you have a shortlist you'd be ok lynching?

Do you think anyone is town?

It sounded like Saitama was super intense effort. Maybe there is a happy medium somewhere.

On May 04 2016 15:16 Tubesock wrote:
headed out for drinks and dinner. Will be back in a few hours. In the mean time:

Towns:

Kush
Shape
Slam
Marvish
Ricey
jat

If I were to pick who to lynch of the "actives" as it were I'd take time deciding between killing and Fazer. I didnt' really like their answers but they are actually closer to null than anything. You can probably infer what I didn't like about them by some of the questions I directed at them.

for the inactives I'd lynch in this orderish

Dr Thrawn
Etellex
Mig (modkill though?)
Palmar

On May 04 2016 15:33 justanothertownie wrote:

I don't see how ricey or shape can be in a townlist.

I have no problem with Killing so far.

I would not add Palmar to the inactivity policy lynches.

On May 04 2016 15:37 justanothertownie wrote:

Are you talking to me?

On May 04 2016 20:50 marvellosity wrote:
oh yeah.

so... why is he voting him then

On May 04 2016 20:51 justanothertownie wrote:
I have no idea actually. Your post made me remember that one.

On May 04 2016 15:04 Alakaslam wrote:

This is epic

Bro-fist on the seeing through homeopathic stuff "lemonade will cure your cancer!" Lol. Riiiiiiiight so my cousin's UCLA grad level research in the matter is pointless because lemons. That literally insults her work.

Yet it is like my posting, I post half-ass jokes and that gets me a town pass? Isn't half the joke based on the fact that this usually happens? I have set the bar for myself so low that I can cruise through 90% of my games suspicion free.

So I find we are a bit too inactive here and will probably need to start voting video people to get them to start talking. Fear of talking is a factor, but when you are already up for lunch you have nothing to lose and start talking.

So let's do that. ##Vote: Etellex

Get my vote off you sir. Why aren't you just lurking scum? You can't get a read; fine. But nothing at all to say? Scum is a lot scarier then town, sir, so... New or not I am inclined to actually lean scum on you. Prove me wrong.

On May 04 2016 20:59 marvellosity wrote:

the problem is, when i have a similar feeling in response to Etellex's post (empathising, understanding how it could be the case) and yet Slam ends up voting for him while I'm leaning town.

So that's 2 different results from the same response to his post. Obviously a different response doesn't have to mean scum, but it definitely merits trying to figure out what and why.

I find your vote scummier than Slam's tbh. It's a weak follow.

On May 04 2016 21:55 marvellosity wrote:

i might rather kill tubesock though

but i don't know yet

On May 04 2016 22:59 RiceyKins wrote:


@Slam were you trying to imply Tubesock is scummy based on town reads on myself and Shape based on how you and JAT were reading the game at the time? I'd like to know what else you were getting at here when you're around

On May 05 2016 00:20 justanothertownie wrote:

If you think he isn't lying then wtf is your policy on about? Do you like random lynching or what?

I haven't decided who I want to lynch yet but yes, consolidation needs to happen at some point in the near future.

On May 05 2016 00:24 justanothertownie wrote:

Yeah, maybe. His reads were pretty random. I especially didn't like the scumreads and marv seems to agree with you (even though I don't know how much of that is OMGUS).

On May 05 2016 00:31 justanothertownie wrote:

Yeah, he openly antagonized him. Exceptionally dumb move if tube is mafia and marv is town since we all know how marv reacts to this though.

On May 05 2016 00:35 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:


Here's the quote in question. Not sure what to think about it. Looks like he's nitpicking marv rather than trying to form a read on him.

On May 05 2016 00:35 justanothertownie wrote:

I mean it is not impossible at all that he does this as mafia but it's not very smart.

On May 05 2016 00:37 justanothertownie wrote:

Why would I be afraid of marv? :/

Fact is town marv tends to lynch people who openly oppose him. On second thought I don't know if tubesock has been playing long enough to know this though.

On May 05 2016 00:37 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
I don't beleive that "Scared of marv" argument holds much weight.
Something that does make me think he might be town is the willingness to lynch a lot of different people.
He did the same thing in storm. And he was mislynched day1.

On May 05 2016 00:55 Shapelog wrote:

Tricked me into fucking writing a big WoT that game as scum.

Eh,

I mean, I see more paraells from storm here, than I do Nut. From a meta point.

I honestly have no clue about the treatment of Marv (never played with marv except once, in hydra) or that marv pushings who ever goes after him.

But nothing strikes me as off going into his filter.

On May 05 2016 00:59 Alakaslam wrote:

Lol immediately read that as

On May 05 2016 01:27 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
wahtever i dont want to argue about this with you. I do want to consolidate on someone sensible so we can maximize our chances to get a claim.

On May 05 2016 01:40 justanothertownie wrote:

You are just pulling shit out of your ass. Your argumentation for the last minutes was the dumbest shit I had to read in ages.

On May 05 2016 02:35 Mig wrote:
quick thoughts

Kush, you have been the most active player in the game I assume you must have a scum read on someone? Policy lynching palmar is pointless.

JAT, your filter is 20% of the total game and I dont see you calling anyone a scum really? Seems weird for you. As a town I would expect...

...Tubesock, entrance felt really weird to me. Overly forced/jokey. A lot of random questions to people with 0 follow up. And none of the questions seem to really impact his reads. Seems way more confident marv is scum but still voting etellex? I still have to read the nutcracker filter.

Fazers - Weird, his thinking is completely nonsensical. Doesnt appear to actually care about finding scum?


This is weird also, unnecessary buddying up when shape hasnt done anything.

Right now I would be fine lynching any of JAT/tube/faze. Probably JAT #1 unless he actually contributes something. Feels like JAT is around a lot but just commenting on the side as things go on and not actually doing anything. A lot of fake activity.

On May 05 2016 04:44 Mig wrote:
slam who are you going to vote for?

On May 05 2016 04:58 Mig wrote:
I don't know tubesock. Does he know marv? Has he played with him before? And even if he has, marv isnt some sort of supernatural force, especially when he is barely doing anything. Seems a bit much to call anyone town just for lightly attacking him, especially if they arent even voting or pushing for his lynch.

On May 06 2016 11:35 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

If u had to guess what would you guess

On May 06 2016 12:18 Mig wrote:
Palmar is there any reason not to lynch you? You have played 8000 games surely 40 pages in you have at least some leanings on who is likely to be scum.

On May 06 2016 06:17 marvellosity wrote:

i'm a terrible save because i've done nothing and my play is suspcious on its own

so if i'm town and palmar is mafia i should be a very safe shot and i am by far the biggest danger to palmar getting lynched

On May 07 2016 02:32 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
if he's town i mean...
scumslip.

On May 07 2016 02:38 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

what i said was a scumslip. You don't see it or you don't agree?

On May 07 2016 02:40 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:


what did he say to convince you? i saw no convincing.

Even if you disregard that argument, palmar is still a great lynch. Why do you disagree?

On May 07 2016 08:51 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
What does he gets going when he is going mean? And how is that an answer to my question?

On May 07 2016 12:18 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

i dont see how that convinced you he's not scum

On May 08 2016 05:03 Shapelog wrote:

Is the fact that I forgot you where even in the game, a troll play.

I think i might pay your filter a visit before I start on Etellex's. Lets see if you are just trying to get townread for not doing anything, which is the scum game you told me you were working/wanted towards when you coached me.

On May 08 2016 05:08 justanothertownie wrote:

Ok, he made some posts.
You seem to think they make him town, yes? Why?

On May 08 2016 05:25 Shapelog wrote:
Anyways,

Using a D1 post, I now can official pressure the fuck out of Slam, at his own request!

I Shall play the magic card known as Toon World!

While In toon World Slam, you must talk like a toon.

So what is your current reads?

On May 08 2016 07:34 Alakaslam wrote:


We all now must recognize townmarv is in that picture.

We must very humbly ask whether there is any merit to lynching Etellex? Let it be done as Marv would say, whether yea or nay

On May 11 2016 00:32 Shapelog wrote:

Stop talking to talk and post your read list slam.

Or I will play final countdown and spam shatter swords.

On May 11 2016 07:26 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
everybody: kill etellex
etellex: surrender

if Etellex flips town, which won't happen, kill alakaslam then jat.

On May 12 2016 07:59 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
slam, you really think im mafia after that claim?

On May 12 2016 06:07 Mig wrote:
So which cop was for real? Also

##vote alakaslam

Death to slam hes mafia!

On May 12 2016 09:41 Etellex wrote:
Yo.

I went on a filter-reading spree and I have some new thoughts on who is and isn't mafia.

I noticed that killing was scumreading both Sandroba and Palmer, which would be a stupid thing to do as scum, and kush did the same. What this leads me to believe is that Killing isn't scum, just intentionally confusing. Kush also appears to be town. I don't have any scumreads but this is what I noticed.

Also Killing jesus christ lay off of Ricey, you have no reason to be this suspicious.

On May 12 2016 13:16 Mig wrote:
Slam if etellex isnt the last mafia who is? It isnt kush

On May 13 2016 04:36 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
ALAKASLAM ADDRESS HOW THERE'S NO CC