A normal game just for JAT <3 - Page 3

On April 16 2016 03:22 Fazers wrote:
Day 1 usually seems where users point fingers at one another, and for what reason?

I think we should wait for a Day 1 post before coming to a conclusion..it's kind of hard to tell who is mafia or not at this point. Just my two cents..

On April 16 2016 08:35 sicklucker wrote:


like wut this is after 3 posts. Maybe palmar just saw 3 town votes and decided to make up reasons to scum read her later lol

On April 16 2016 21:28 Superbia wrote:
Want to call gumshoe mafia but 1st post tryhard is at most NAI for him.

On April 17 2016 04:00 Tumblewood wrote:

Yeah but I never bothered to check when it started

On April 16 2016 21:55 Superbia wrote:
Actually why not.

##vote: rsoultin

Let's see what this brings.

On April 17 2016 03:02 Superbia wrote:
Now: Palmar:

Town palmar would've taken a grip on the game already. Tbf the game is going pretty much nowhere this close to EoD (imo). It's very undirected. Town palmar takes control and leads a direction. The push on rso is not.

In fact, Palmar's push on rso indicates a plan. And from all my games with palmar, he always has some sort of planned d1 as scum. He makes up some sort of plan or method to determine who is scum or something similar. This push on rso seems the exact same way (though I do not know what it says about rso's alignment). Pre-planned.

His read on me adds on to the lack of town direction he's taken this game. As town you are usually aligned to the people who have similar reads. That's why it is not weird for me to half-flip on rso. The fact that Palmar groups us together cements this un-townie, overfocused mindset.

I encourage everyone to check out Palmar's scum games and look at his play d1 (specifically the ones I was in as well, I believe it was russia or titanic or something). It's pre-planned and lazy.

Now look at his town games. It starts off super lazy but he always picks up very quickly. Especially when the town has no leader (i.e. as we have now). He is nowhere this game. This some prepackaged bullshit plan.

##Vote: Palmar

On April 17 2016 04:28 gumshoe wrote:


if hes scum, then he probally thinks he can get away with this kind of play exactly because of his last game, as people will be less likely to kill him / :

The point is, outside his meta hes playing anti town and within his meta he could easily be town or scum as this kind of play is not at all hard to enact.

On April 17 2016 04:46 gumshoe wrote:


I suppose / : I just expect more out of him than someone like Onegu, you know?

On April 17 2016 04:50 rsoultin wrote:


actually what that should say is his case is wrong but his read could be right

On April 16 2016 02:57 Tumblewood wrote:
rsoul, why do you townread rels after just posting disagreements/question marks in response to him?

On April 16 2016 13:39 Tumblewood wrote:
And by that I mean your only evidence is Superbia saying "Hey I'm not going to be here" and then not being here. Attributing that to scum burnout is a huge conclusion-leap.

On April 16 2016 14:11 Tumblewood wrote:
where I'm at right now:

null
most people

don't want to lynch
gumshoe because innocent town
rels because actually trying
ows because actually trying
palmar because in Devil I lynched him day 1 and I never got to play with him

could lynch today
rsoul because all her answers are kind of meh
superbia because AFK; prefer vig shot

On April 16 2016 14:21 Tumblewood wrote:

pls, I hold everyone + Show Spoiler + to a higher standard than I hold myself
My scum meter for you is, when I ask you a question, if your answer is kinda disappointing but not really scummy, you're probably scum
The problem with this is I haven't played with town rsoul\

Why do you like my previous posting, though, enough to outweigh that thing you didn't like?

On April 16 2016 14:43 Tumblewood wrote:
I read through a random rsoul town game. Well, 3/23 of it. She was a lot more emotional, but has probably moved away from that meta. I'll update when I read one that wasn't from nine months ago.

On April 16 2016 14:57 Tumblewood wrote:
I read gaiden, that's only like six months ago
Perhaps what I'm saying is that I expect rsoul to be more... disagreeable? That's the distinguishing factor I see between her town and scum games.
Going to sleep soon so if you have any questions ask now.

On April 17 2016 02:38 Tumblewood wrote:
Many disappointed ohs were uttered during the course of catching up.
Idk how you can read Palmar's case, think "this is a bad case," and then townread Palmar for it on the assumption that, if he's scum, it would be a suicide attack or a failure.

On April 17 2016 05:07 Tumblewood wrote:

I didn't think you actually thought that was alignment indicative, so your "OK to lynch him" felt off. Cleared it up though.

On April 17 2016 05:19 gumshoe wrote:


this post is fine, as me and superbia just played a game where he attacked me for a try hard post first thing. I was town of course.

So this game starts and superbia sees my post, his first instinct is it's scummy, but then remembers the game we just played.

Hence -scummy, but nai.

So this post rels that caught your attention first, actually just shows him taking my meta in mind after you know, killing me that one time(super built the gun that slam held in his hand). Which is frankly something I applaud XD

On April 17 2016 05:28 justanothertownie wrote:

It is actually not impossible at all. The question is how likely it is. But let's see his defense.

On April 17 2016 05:30 Tumblewood wrote:
"Oh but Tumblewood you didn't say that last part earlier."
"Scum scum scum for changing his reasons on rsoul."