Unfortunate shot :/

Phone posting. I'm town, guys. If you need a rebuttal I'll get to it when I'm at a computer but the short version is basically:

1. LS is objectively shimmy lynchbait. Not using other means to read him is retarded.
2. Only valid if I don't latch onto scumreads d1 and push the shot out of them as town. I do. Bad meat is bad.
3. Irrelevant. The town mindset is missing behind his play and a play like that has nothing to do with how I normally read him + he's just been calling me scrum and associating from there. What amazing content?
4. Rit is scum. Invalid.
5. Untrue. Will prove if have to but don't feel that's needed.
6. Consolidating on a scrum or non-town read over getting lynched is never a mafia tell, and I have a long history of doing that whether getting lynched or not.
7. I'm town so whatever lol ><

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

March 27 2016 00:45 GMT

#1526

On March 27 2016 09:25 Tumblewood wrote:
Also you called the entire basis of your Rels read (activity) NAI...

When he was around his presence wasn't exactly felt by us.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

March 27 2016 00:52 GMT

#1527

why are all my scumreads calling each other town. That is really annoying.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 00:53 GMT

#1528

@rsoul if you are town we are in a really bad spot, since I really think you are mafia and multiple people I think are town do as well. Also your assertion that ritoky is scum is getting old and needs to be more substanciated if you are going to insist on it. Honestly this short rebutal post helps with nothing, if you are town you need to be doing a ton of work and shitting rainbows. Probably claiming as well.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

March 27 2016 00:56 GMT

#1529

why would we be in a bad spot?

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

March 27 2016 00:57 GMT

#1530

that being said. If mafia decided to shoot sicklucker we actually might be in an horrendous spot.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

March 27 2016 00:59 GMT

#1531

On March 27 2016 09:53 sandroba wrote:
@rsoul if you are town we are in a really bad spot, since I really think you are mafia and multiple people I think are town do as well. Also your assertion that ritoky is scum is getting old and needs to be more substanciated if you are going to insist on it. Honestly this short rebutal post helps with nothing, if you are town you need to be doing a ton of work and shitting rainbows. Probably claiming as well.

Look I'm not going to make excuses. My activity will be shot for awhile and there's nothing I can do about it.

I'm willing to talk about whatever y'all want to talk about when I get the chance but the fact that no one seems to notice rit's only contributions are the shot play and this b.s. scumread on me while I've put in a lot more work is pretty retarded. What has he done that makes you so sure he's town?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 01:11 GMT

#1532

His plan is too stupid to come from mafia, he seemed too proud of it to be mafia, him coming out and bragging about his plan after a townie just got shot is too balsy to be mafia, multiple posts from him I find thoughtfull and none sound fake to me.
What makes you so sure he is mafia? All I can read is that you think he could do that plan thing as mafia, which doesn't make him mafia at all. He is right that you are not considering anything else and is tunneled on this idea without adding any other value to the thread. You can't say he is mafia for having a scum read on you because I'm town and I do as well, calling it BS doesn't make it go away.
Suppose you are wrong about ritoky, who is mafia?
If you are town you should be in a unique position to analyse day 1 wagons, should maybe start with that?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

March 27 2016 01:22 GMT

#1533

This post says to me, "rsoul, if you're town, we're lynching you unless you make it unjustifiable." I expect town to approach this from a different standpoint-- not sure how to describe it, maybe more careful?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 01:30 GMT

#1534

That comment is precious coming from someone who said:

On March 27 2016 09:10 Tumblewood wrote:
My inner contrarian wants to think "come on, this is too perfect, this can't be right" but last time I saw a case as good as ritoky's was when Trfel nailed me as scum. I am actually totally okay with sheeping that read.

It looks like the kind of hypocrisy present on your comments last game questioning my motives when I was lynching FF last game and you were scum.

Damdred

15669 Posts

March 27 2016 01:31 GMT

#1535

Idk I still feel like the wagon really points to a town vs town.

I don't think RS lack of activity makes her 100% scum, I also don't think rits case makes him lock town either though. Both those things he can do as scum imo.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

March 27 2016 01:39 GMT

#1536

On March 27 2016 10:11 sandroba wrote:
His plan is too stupid to come from mafia, he seemed too proud of it to be mafia, him coming out and bragging about his plan after a townie just got shot is too balsy to be mafia, multiple posts from him I find thoughtfull and none sound fake to me.
What makes you so sure he is mafia? All I can read is that you think he could do that plan thing as mafia, which doesn't make him mafia at all. He is right that you are not considering anything else and is tunneled on this idea without adding any other value to the thread. You can't say he is mafia for having a scum read on you because I'm town and I do as well, calling it BS doesn't make it go away.
Suppose you are wrong about ritoky, who is mafia?
If you are town you should be in a unique position to analyse day 1 wagons, should maybe start with that?

Well honestly I thought you,rit,Kuru ark voters but between your claim which I don't see coming from scrum there and how you're treating me now like you actually care about getting it right, wrong on that

Could be wrong on Kurt too but I don't actually think that extreme deep post actually clears him given anyone reading the thread has to know fit and I have been gunning for each other for days