EPTYou're not giving us anything to work with here :\
Pick Your Power: Intriguing - Page 76
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
You're not giving us anything to work with here :\ | ||
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ | ||
|
CopCake
4378 Posts
I mean, GB can still be mafia but you just cleared and is a fact that someone else lied with the numbers thing with the picking order, so like he didnt lie he didnt pick like me. Get it? Everyone was going and was sure GB was mafia but you did the most townie thing of all, I don't get why someone would think YOU are mafia. | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
On January 21 2016 11:17 Keirathi wrote: Yo Shining. Literally the only person you've mentioned having a scumread on up until this point was SL. Everything else was just setup speculation stuff. Now 7 out of those 9 people are are in your scum reads list from out of nowhere. Give some reasoning? The SL read was based heavily on me being annoyed and upset at him suggesting me as a plynch when he knows from past games that I have little to no activity on Monday Tuesday, plus calling me useless when I'm far from the worst town player on TL. I also have a 95% town roll rate so plynching me at any point is going to flip me town 9.5 out of 10 times. But I admit that it was a bit omgus and decided to leave it at that for now. Since then, he's made a few posts about wanting town to work together and there's a slight town feel from some of them so I'm off of him. As for sheeping Palmars list, I just said it didn't look bad outside of kita and ceph because none of the people on that list scream town to me. And I don't necessarily believe the list in that order, either. You - no one bumped you from 1,1 which I expected scum would do if you're a good town player unless you're actually scum. And although I liked your catch on Palmar re: agreeing with Damdreds list that had you as top town, I found it weird that you scummed Damdred afterwards. Like if he's scum, why would Palmar agreeing with his list matter unless they're scum together? Vivax - he isn't cooperating with anyone and OMGUSd kita and Palmar, which just looked really weird. He also did some complaining about the setup and said its just a matter of which scum team wins so why even sign up? He seems pretty bitter for absolutely no reason. There's also literally no clue to what role he picked, which could mean he took a Mafia favored role. GB - so apathetic and clueless to pretty much everything going on in the game which just feels really off. Most if not all of the answers to his questions are in the OP, which he either didn't read or wants to make us think he didn't read. I can't see any towniness in any of those posts. Onegu - he's just a big question mark but his wanting to defy everyone and bring someone down with him felt weird. I am probably also a little biased becuz the last time he posted something that wasn't text(that pic), he was scum. And he's tried to appeal to Palmar more than once about carrying him as scum last game and asking what the problem is, as if he's trying to buddy him or win him over. Disfo - this is probably the weakest one but checking his filter the first half were just pregame questions and the second half was a ton of setup talk. He has more than one post saying he's catching up and asking for direction(any hot topics to discuss?) The things I did like from him was his willingness to discuss and claim his role and his wanting to cooperate. He also dropped a preliminary reads list which didn't look particularly scummy. I'm pretty waffly on this one. TT - I didn't like his "I probably won't put much effort into this one" post because it just feels like a reason to afk or not care later. And the last time he did that, he got lynched as blue and said he wouldn't do it again so I'm not sure why he's choosing to do it here. I also didn't like his reasoning for blocking Disfo. I have them both as possible scum, but they could very well be different teams. He also had a change in tone from "I won't put much effort into this one" to "I'll probably be invested d1-d2." I don't see how that's townie. Alotsomuch - no reads or really much of anything. Got directed into a role, claimed he got it and fucked off again. I didn't even realize Alot was playing until I saw this list, which was a red flag. | ||
|
AlotSomuch
95 Posts
| ||
|
sicklucker
Canada16987 Posts
| ||
|
AlotSomuch
95 Posts
| ||
|
AlotSomuch
95 Posts
I have no comments about the role picking and such, but while I think Kitoman's points about using the extra investigative roles were good, the tone I got off his responses struck me as non-town. Dunno. | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
On January 21 2016 12:39 The Shining wrote: The SL read was based heavily on me being annoyed and upset at him suggesting me as a plynch when he knows from past games that I have little to no activity on Monday Tuesday, plus calling me useless when I'm far from the worst town player on TL. I also have a 95% town roll rate so plynching me at any point is going to flip me town 9.5 out of 10 times. But I admit that it was a bit omgus and decided to leave it at that for now. Since then, he's made a few posts about wanting town to work together and there's a slight town feel from some of them so I'm off of him. As for sheeping Palmars list, I just said it didn't look bad outside of kita and ceph because none of the people on that list scream town to me. And I don't necessarily believe the list in that order, either. Fair enough. On January 21 2016 12:39 The Shining wrote: You - no one bumped you from 1,1 which I expected scum would do if you're a good town player unless you're actually scum. And although I liked your catch on Palmar re: agreeing with Damdreds list that had you as top town, I found it weird that you scummed Damdred afterwards. Like if he's scum, why would Palmar agreeing with his list matter unless they're scum together? Even if I'm scum, the other scum team wouldn't know that. So why wouldn't they try to bump me off of [1,1]? And if I'm town (and a good town, at that), then if someone does bump me off of first pick, then they would have to put up with extra scrutiny from me, yes? I mean, the draft order is public and everyone was claiming their numbers. It would be trivial to figure out who bumped me down. The point of the Palmar thing didn't have anything to do with Damdred at all. It had everything to do with how Palmar's read suddenly changed because I got [1,1] and THEN he decided to read my filter and decide I was scum. He could have done that before the draft phase ended and countered my [1,1] pick but didn't. And anyways, they could be on different teams. Or I could be wrong. Or whatever. I'm not sure how disliking Damdred in general is a conflict with not liking Palmars read switch? On January 21 2016 12:39 The Shining wrote: Disfo - this is probably the weakest one but checking his filter the first half were just pregame questions and the second half was a ton of setup talk. He has more than one post saying he's catching up and asking for direction(any hot topics to discuss?) The things I did like from him was his willingness to discuss and claim his role and his wanting to cooperate. He also dropped a preliminary reads list which didn't look particularly scummy. I'm pretty waffly on this one. I can tell you why I have him down as tentative town. First, this post - On January 19 2016 09:30 disformation wrote: Does that mean you have the alignment of 2.2 ppl figured out or that you have found 0.8 scum?  That kind of jokey/lighthearted response just immediately 'feels' townie. Weak +town points. But the big thing is that a lot of his setup talk was about getting town protective/investigative roles. And he took Watson, which is a pretty pro-town role. On January 21 2016 12:39 The Shining wrote: TT - I didn't like his "I probably won't put much effort into this one" post because it just feels like a reason to afk or not care later. And the last time he did that, he got lynched as blue and said he wouldn't do it again so I'm not sure why he's choosing to do it here. I also didn't like his reasoning for blocking Disfo. I have them both as possible scum, but they could very well be different teams. He also had a change in tone from "I won't put much effort into this one" to "I'll probably be invested d1-d2." I don't see how that's townie. If he's mafia, would he actually come out and SAY he wasn't going to much effort in? [I don't know TT and haven't read any of his games. I dunno what his personality is like or anything] | ||
|
Tictock
United States6052 Posts
On January 21 2016 12:39 The Shining wrote: TT - I didn't like his "I probably won't put much effort into this one" post because it just feels like a reason to afk or not care later. And the last time he did that, he got lynched as blue and said he wouldn't do it again so I'm not sure why he's choosing to do it here. I also didn't like his reasoning for blocking Disfo. I have them both as possible scum, but they could very well be different teams. He also had a change in tone from "I won't put much effort into this one" to "I'll probably be invested d1-d2." I don't see how that's townie. The bolded is pure Lies and Slander. Besides in this game i kinda feel like town starts out more fucked and the game is a little more about the 4v4 scumteam. Hell tbh I'm not even sure I trust my reads very much since Scum can do pretty legit town-looking plays looking for the opposing scumteam. Besides I think it's shit to judge me by how much effort I claim I'm gunna put into games. I usually play and post a fair bit as either alignment. | ||
|
GlowingBear
Brazil12446 Posts
That's weird, I don't remember being apathetic as scum | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
So if you're not mafia, who is? If you can't even come up with someone that is scummy, how do you expect people to think you're town? How to you expect to not get lynched? | ||
|
Tictock
United States6052 Posts
Speaking of dumbtells I don't really like SL making a big deal about his missed PM. Though my gut is leaning town on him kus of how upset he was that his "sweet spot" number didn't work out. | ||
|
Tictock
United States6052 Posts
On January 21 2016 13:34 Keirathi wrote: TT/GB: So if you're not mafia, who is? If you can't even come up with someone that is scummy, how do you expect people to think you're town? How to you expect to not get lynched? History has taught me to kinda just expect this since I'm an odd guy. I'm also tempted to focus a touch more on my town reads, which atm is something like. Koshi Superbia Rels* The Shining Damdred* Keir* Palmar* Sicklucker* FF - Shoehorned in for good behavior Obi (? Idk why I'm leaning town on him tbh) *I plan to reread filters and I may be forgetting one or two people. | ||
|
Tictock
United States6052 Posts
| ||
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
On January 21 2016 13:27 GlowingBear wrote: Oh so I'm being scum read because I am apathetic? That's weird, I don't remember being apathetic as scum I do! | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
I just double checked outlaw, tt is right. He apologized for the throw, said he failed hard but he didn't say he would tryhard next game. I guess I took the apology to imply that. GB have you ever rolled back to back scum games? Because I'm not toot familiar with your scum meta but I could see you being less invested in rolling scum in back to back large games. I also am not sure you've ever been so obvious about asking questions about the op. It's one of the only things you've done. | ||
|
GlowingBear
Brazil12446 Posts
On January 21 2016 13:34 Keirathi wrote: TT/GB: So if you're not mafia, who is? If you can't even come up with someone that is scummy, how do you expect people to think you're town? How to you expect to not get lynched? I'm not reading the thread since I'm working like hell and this will be my busiest week. Sometimes I come to the thread and skim stuff. One of these stuffs was SL's bad suspicion on me and his fake dumb tell. And I also remember me suspecting you of talking to me like you knew I'm town, but I knew this was weak so I kept it to myself I don't expect to be called town when I am inactive. But I also don't expect to be called mafja for it either. | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
Do tell | ||
|
GlowingBear
Brazil12446 Posts
On January 21 2016 13:36 Tictock wrote: Thats true GB, but you have to admit there's apathetic and forced dumbtells (asking questions about stuff in OP). Speaking of dumbtells I don't really like SL making a big deal about his missed PM. Though my gut is leaning town on him kus of how upset he was that his "sweet spot" number didn't work out. I didn't read the OP closely and I was busy so I was just desperate to have the answer instead of having to go to the OP and looking for it. I didn't send the numbers to the pick order because I was busy and I completely forgot. I've asked about how do I choose roles because I didn't really know. Palmar helped and I chose one of that list he made. Btw did SL claim picking a role? | ||
| ||
