because he made an observation that required thinking and attention to detail rather than try to be funny, fit in, sound natural, or do nothing; like a vast majority of people thus far.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 04:01 GMT

#142

you gain anything from this?

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 04:14 GMT

#143

on the one hand i read the obs qt from the last game and see a degree of self-loathing about how you felt you underperformed and your aggression at the start being an overcompensation about that.

on the other hand i pushed some bullshit scum read on you the previous game and was scum with you the game before that and of your own admission you come out the gates very aggro as mafia so i think you are completely within your mafia meta regardless of the fact that you're pushing questioning on me.

currently trfel is slightly mafia leaning.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

January 14 2016 04:36 GMT

#144

trfel is slightly leaning cuz he might be drunk

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

January 14 2016 04:42 GMT

#145

Scumlean ritoky, townlean trfel

ritoky's scumlean on trfel doesn't make much sense. He is ignoring trfel's townread on me post, which is trfel's meatiest one so far, which should put him outside of the column of players that "try to be funny, fit in, sound natural, or do nothing". He finds trfel's pushing questioning of him a townie thing, but frames it as either null or scummy because it isn't outside of what trfel could do as scum. Basically has argued trfel to a null unless i'm reading him wrong. So the only reason I see to mafia-lean trfel would be a gut read. But if it is a gut read, that is a lot of explanation. It would make more sense for rito to be scumleaning someone in his do nothing category since the contrast against that category is what makes cephiro town in his eyes.

Trfel is engaging multiple people, generating content, and pressing for answers.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 04:52 GMT

#146

your description of his play is exactly what makes him more mafia than town.

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

January 14 2016 04:55 GMT

#147

Also Ace, I'm happy to describe how playstyle/preferences. However, I'm not terribly familiar with yours. Will you return the favor and describe yourself for me?

I am a low postcount player compared to the average on TL. It takes me a while to read and process. I prefer playing town though it could be argued that I'm better as scum. I tend to find scum through analyzing. When I have tried to find scum through heavy involvement and pressure I fall into tunneling and bias too easily. No real preference on specific roles, though I have had good luck with using abilities and NKs as both alignments (this part of your question is a little too close to bluehunting for my taste).

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

January 14 2016 04:58 GMT

#148

On January 14 2016 13:52 ritoky wrote:
your description of his play is exactly what makes him more mafia than town.

You are going to have to walk me through this then. Because I'm clearly not getting it from what you already posted.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

January 14 2016 04:58 GMT

#149

I don't have a style, I just post stuff

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 05:02 GMT

#150

from last game after i called trfel mafia for some BS reason.

On December 27 2015 15:02 Trfel wrote:
I mean, it's possible that you see my scum play as weak and wimpy, fine. Compared to my town play, though, it's extremely aggressive. I feel like you should know this, seeing as I kept mentioning that I was scared about hurting people's feelings in the scum QT? But there's no incentive for you to lie intentionally, so bleh.

I'm going to reread the thread now, so yeah.

in the previous game (don't remember the name off top of my head) we had been mafia, he opened similarly as aggro as this.

in outlaw he opened significantly less so. from a meta perspective his play is much more mafia indicative thus far.

the caveat being i saw in the obs qt that he was a bit upset with his play last game and his opening level of tryhard could be a direct response to feeling shitty about how he played last game. but currently gonna go with the meta read as superior.

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

January 14 2016 05:08 GMT

#151

I don't see this aggressiveness you are describing. He joked around, gave a townread on me, and has been questioning people and defending against you. Are you basing this on his initial satirical case on me?

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 05:14 GMT

#152

for myself for later: if trfel ever flips mafia, lynch dyh

DoYouHas

United States1140 Posts

January 14 2016 05:17 GMT

#153

On January 14 2016 13:58 Ace wrote:
I don't have a style, I just post stuff

This response reminded me of a phrase from your own mafia manifesto, "never give the town a damn thing". If you aren't aware of your own meta/preferences then I hope to wake up to some level of contribution from you.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

January 14 2016 05:25 GMT

#154

i am in a shit mood and should probably just stop playing until tomorrow, plus my wrist hurts like fuck.

cephiro is town
trfel could be mafia cuz shit i said
forced joke guy (alotsomuch) could be mafia cuz his post was awful

everyone else hasn't done anything worth a damn and any freebie reads they've been given are probably just made up. cya nerdz.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

January 14 2016 05:33 GMT

#155

On January 14 2016 14:17 DoYouHas wrote:

Show nested quote +

sleep well and keep hope alive

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

January 14 2016 05:37 GMT

#156

I think Trfel town for reasons. Rito seems more inclined to explain his read on Trfl than I'm used to. TBD what it means. Right now not inclined to lynch tho.

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

January 14 2016 05:39 GMT

#157

Also hi Ace. I still think I played well in The Game, suck it.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:10 GMT

#158

DYH seems town so far... Basically it just feels like he's analyzing the game objectively. Not pushing any specific thought(s) or avoiding attention. Early credit grab

Insufficient data to use my new heuristic on rayn, and marv hasn't even posted yet :/

Some mixed feelings about ritoky. Could be town though with that level of confident posting style and activity...

I'll refrain from mentioning who disturbed me the most for a little bit.