TL Mafia LXXIII: The Nutcracker - Page 25

On December 16 2015 04:51 Tictock wrote:
Just got home, got out a little early kus it's Blizzarding here.

I'll do the filter dive of Gig I promised Rels and then catchup with what I've missed thus far.

While at work I was thinking about the whole Rit hardreading Shape. It's possible that what he said about "One moment defines a player" is just really how he's approaching this game (I don't recall him ever useing thinking like this before though, so it's weird) but I think it might be an indication that Rit is mafia.

So I know for sure we aren't looking at a Rit/Shape team here, kus I just don't believe Rit would hard defend a teammate like he is. I'm wondering now if the hard townread is a sign of TMI?

Like it dosn't make a ton of sense for Rit to have such a hard townread on Shape if he's town, he even made a post pointing out that Shape was doing some stuff that was stupid or looked bad, it also makes no sense for Rit to hard defend a scummate. However it makes perfect sense for a scum!Rit to hard defend a new-to-our-fourms town!Shape who people might have a hard time reading well. Would give him a nice platform to push from while seeming like he wants to prevent a mislynch.

The other thing that I was thinking about, is why am I the only person to have irked Rit for my read on Shape? I know he posted out his thoughts on why he thought I was scum for rethinking my read but he's given little to no reaction to anyone else scumreading Shape.

I realize my view on Rit is rather tainted with OMGUS kus he has a fordrawn conclusion to lynch me here, and my thinking here is more WIFOM than real evidence but I'm thinking Rit might be scum here. Only thing making me a bit unsure is that Rit is rather invested in his reads (pushing them etc) and cares about the lynch. So right now I'd put Rit as a OMGUS tainted scumlean.

On December 14 2015 08:39 Damdred wrote:


You obviously!

Though shape is a good chance at town

On December 15 2015 05:07 Damdred wrote:
Games not to bad I have a few ok town reads so far I'll post more when I get home.

On December 15 2015 07:15 Damdred wrote:


I'm a bit behind tbh but my initial gut was town on Tt other idk yet

On December 15 2015 09:59 Damdred wrote:
For the record ls is town this game, tone/actions and how he does the game totally point to it. I'll go to war over this read.

On December 14 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote:
It's honestly be the most helpful to everyone if you basically ignored koshi for the first 24 and see what kind of smart things he says and then make a decision going into,the lynch. If you keep badgering him about low posting you will just have a horrendous amount of non information.

Tt I think ls is town should I get my head checked?

On December 14 2015 10:30 Damdred wrote:
Let me tell you why you are totally wrong in how you are approaching koshi.

1) you say that koshi is going to be super lazy and you are content voting him because that's his scum meta.

In actuality you are right about his meta but dead wrong in your interpretation of what koshi said. If you read koshis post he clearly states he's going to focus on building cases and finding mafia. A clearly different thing especially since generally cases take a decent bit of effort which scum koshi lacks.

2) you say my post is terrible because you read koshi on his d1. Though you correct yourself by saying I said 24 hours.

In actuality I a aid we shouldn't bother koshi so that we can see what he comes up with. Since you know he said he would focus on cases and finding scum instead of spamming the thread.

....like I said give koshi space and some time see what he comes up with.

On December 12 2015 20:15 Damdred wrote:


I'd probably agree with the part on my greymist post. I'm not hard town reading him at this point.

like it sort of looks like this

Damdred
Rayn

probably town
Rsoultin/art
Darth

liking them
greymist

?
Marv
Rels

On December 02 2015 09:36 Damdred wrote:
Disinformation
Eels
Damdred
Shining
Palmar

Leans
Trfel
Fid (falling)
Ls

Honestly it's notso bad so far even though I've read 0 filters.

On December 15 2015 15:45 Tubesock wrote:
I didn't notice the time change. I think LightningStrike kinda falls into the Chezinu Rule (weird posters get attacked by mafia since they are so easy to lynch). I really didn't like how he came in scummed LS and bailed. Koshi has good points on him too. Plus, maybe he will spew townbows.

##Vote: Rels

On December 16 2015 05:30 Koshi wrote:
Damdred is flying way under the radar though. I should have noticed that. Good on you Rels!

On December 16 2015 05:31 Koshi wrote:
Ok. Rels is officially not mafia at all. Never ever.

On December 16 2015 05:31 Rels wrote:

Yep it's quite different from the two last games I played. I think he has a good chance at flipping scum.

On December 16 2015 05:32 Shapelog wrote:
Oh yeah wasn't he suppose to drop a bomb or something? even wrote him down in my notes as Null until bomb.
Maybe he ment a real bomb. But i am not watching the news for it.

On December 15 2015 08:44 Damdred wrote:
Ls why should I not vote you ^^. Will be home to read and bomb soon

On December 16 2015 01:29 Damdred wrote:
Ok so I fell asleep and just woke up.

give me three filters to read and I'll find acum if there is between them!

Besides ls, koshi they are hard town reads atm.

On December 15 2015 02:58 GiygaS wrote:
Thanks for NAI help.



This is only true if I was that focused on Damdred in the first place. The first was only because I was initially confused why he posted the miller claim. The second was because I just didn't agree with his reasoning and wanted to point it out, it wasn't because I had a scum read on him.

I'll reread tt filter and see, but all I have is null or town reads on everyone, except a tiny lean on Koshi from meta that I haven't even experienced.

On December 15 2015 04:09 GiygaS wrote:
Woops forgot vote. I'll add I have a town read on ritoky as well since his posts have been short but decently high quality.

##Vote ticktock

On December 15 2015 06:48 GiygaS wrote:
##Unvote tictock

He's swapped back to null for me, will look over more when I get home from studying.

On December 15 2015 10:38 GiygaS wrote:
Home from studying. Since I'm in the note-taking mood I'm going to go through the thread again writing in a notebook to organize my thoughts a bit. I'll keep looking at the newer posts though so I'll be around. So far have null or town reads on everybody, but hoping to change that within the next 2-ish hours.

On December 15 2015 14:36 GiygaS wrote:
Finished reading through and writing general notes. Going to go through filters and hang around still. Current scum reads are on tt (again, I really don't like that list of townread retraction with NAI stuff) and shape (holy shit that random asslist in to weird sukrit fos). Might get some more/less post-filters, but we'll see.

For the record, my name has been spelled 9 different ways, so that's pretty neat. Also, these posts :D

On December 16 2015 05:34 Koshi wrote:
Damdred his scumgame is better than this though. He is really good at it. So there are time restrictions at play either alignment. Hmm not sure if I want to lynch him. He is pretty on point in those few posts. He is just not solving anything... It is pure lack of solving the game that makes him mafia right?

On December 14 2015 08:39 Damdred wrote:


You obviously!

Though shape is a good chance at town

On December 14 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote:
It's honestly be the most helpful to everyone if you basically ignored koshi for the first 24 and see what kind of smart things he says and then make a decision going into,the lynch. If you keep badgering him about low posting you will just have a horrendous amount of non information.

Tt I think ls is town should I get my head checked?

On December 15 2015 07:15 Damdred wrote:


I'm a bit behind tbh but my initial gut was town on Tt other idk yet

On December 12 2015 08:21 Damdred wrote:
There's two reasons why I like greymist both are shitty to a degree one more so than the last.

The most simple and superficial reason was that after a super rough week he made me chuckle and put me in a good mood in the game.

The second shitty reason was he answered my question in a way that wasn't over confident in how he approached me or rather betraying a knowledge he shouldn't have.

Both are nai but it's a place to start liking someone

On December 12 2015 15:18 Damdred wrote:
Eh screw it I'm awake so I'll post.

Rs/Art go after Darth in what amounts to there opening post and follow up post. While I don't think its out of the scope of what they could do as scum going after dp so fast is something I don't really consider either of them to do.

It seems to me its more motivated at this instance coming from town trying to catch someone on a meta irregularity that they feel. It isn't quite the gorcha moment to total town read but it makes sense and fives me somewhat town feelings motive wise.

On December 14 2015 16:59 Tictock wrote:
Ok gave this game a quick reread now that I'm home and not being distracted or as constrained on time.

Damdred is prob town for the Miller thing, plus he made a good point about meta-ing Koshi (or rather not rushing to meta Koshi). Easy start to a townpile.

Gunna retract my town read on Shape from earlier, though I think I just need to see more out of him.
Scummy Stuff: Jumped on the LS vote real fast, applying meta based on one game, kinda all over the place with reads
Towny Stuff: Throwing out lots of thoughts/ideas, engaged, not concerned with how his suggestions make him look


@Shape, have you read other games or just Haunted Mansion?
Also welcome to the forums!

On December 14 2015 17:03 Tictock wrote:




Not sure why you are fixated on Damdred.

Do you have any thoughts on how LS (or anyone else) reacted to Damdred's claim?

Whats your opinion oh Shape?