first impressions: i am sexy, vivax and hopeless have voted together every vote, chroma/vivax/hopeless have never voted on conf mafia, no hipster mafia day 1
also I'm totally okay with either GB or Hopeless, slight preference for GB but I don't think there's any real reason for that other than "information" and he's more likely to wiggle out of it later
first impressions: i am sexy, vivax and hopeless have voted together every vote, chroma/vivax/hopeless have never voted on conf mafia, no hipster mafia day 1
I see you've also taken the liberty of coloring yourself in green there
On October 31 2015 08:13 Chromatically wrote: modest effort BH? I'm offended
also I'm totally okay with either GB or Hopeless, slight preference for GB but I don't think there's any real reason for that other than "information" and he's more likely to wiggle out of it later
historically: he is a wiggler. But if we lynch H1 today I'm sure we're lynching GB tomorrow. It's slightly frustrating to almost-lynch him so many times without getting it done... but he's on almost everyone's lynch
yeah I'm down with lynching Hopeless first if that's what the collective masses decide, unless I see a particularly good reason to do one or the other first
On October 31 2015 08:32 GlowingBear wrote: I don't thibk hopeless is mafia...
gb stahp, just stahp please T_T hopeless would have just voted for onegu yesterday if he was town, why did he vote for you if not to save his buddy?
PRO TIP:
gb/h1/1gu scumteam
oh, actually, that doesn't explain it now that I think about it. H1 could reasonably vote either of them if he and gb are scum together. there might even be a reason to vote onegu since onegu was probably getting lynched no matter what, so get some cred.... hmmm
I think the lynch was looking like a GB lynch at that point right? ritoky said he was on GB and gumshoe was on GB at that point too so the votes looked like they were going to be 6-3 in favor of GB. Makes sense if it's a GB Hopeless team for Hopeless to pop in and vote on the mafia that seems like he's going to flip.
On October 31 2015 11:08 Chromatically wrote: I think the lynch was looking like a GB lynch at that point right? ritoky said he was on GB and gumshoe was on GB at that point too so the votes looked like they were going to be 6-3 in favor of GB. Makes sense if it's a GB Hopeless team for Hopeless to pop in and vote on the mafia that seems like he's going to flip.
ah... so he'd get some cred, and cause he's generally lurking confuse reads on him? An interesting thought. not that this changes my general idea of how we should play the next two days
Well assuming the lynch was two mafia and Hopeless was also mafia, he'd want to throw his vote on whichever one is most likely to get lynched so he gets credit for the mafia flip (which was inevitable if both wagons were mafia). At the time he voted, it looked like GB was getting lynched. So the situation is consistent with a GB Onegu Hopeless team.
From GB's perspective though, Hopeless should be like 100% mafia because he randomly came into the thread and voted on the town wagon instead of mafia, so that doesn't make any sense.
Cause if it was MvM there's 1 mafia riding hard on lynch cred and you don't want to have to start considering that at lylo in the really scary case that hopeless flips town.
On October 31 2015 20:23 Vivax wrote: Cause if it was MvM there's 1 mafia riding hard on lynch cred and you don't want to have to start considering that at lylo in the really scary case that hopeless flips town.
Kk ima be nice alright?
doesn't the exact same thing apply if gb flips town and hopeless flips scum? -_- from your perspective if gb isnt scum, someone on the Onegu wagon MUST be.
Course theres one other possibility, maybe mafia threw all their weight to save onegu?
Wouldn't that mean chrom could be scum too vivax?
also we should be lynching hopeless right now because hes more scummy than gb, whose actually put quite a bit of effort into this game / : we want to delay lylo as long as possible, because if the scummer is rayn tier than they'll have an easier time manipulating town if the stakes are higher.
You all are so set on lynching gb right now, you haven't considered that if the scummer is skilled he can use that potential mislynch to sow doubt amongst us and perhaps cause us to shift from da plan / : (if your certain you wont break, are you sure about your fellows? Ritoky has already been to finfoil land, hes for sures town, whose to say it cant happen again?)
tldr
We should lynch the person with the highest chance of flipping scum right now, to avoid giving the remaining scum more of a chance, as it will only take one of us having doubts about whether or not we should bank the game on killing a lurker to turn the tides for maf.
PS. If there's 2 scum among vivax, gb and hopeless, vivax and gb arent likely scum together (that would mean that gb, the only competent scummer on his team of hopeless and onegu, threw himself to the wolves day fucking 1.) That means between the three, hopeless is the only one that MUST be scum as he doesn't really clash with either of them.
On November 01 2015 01:53 Chromatically wrote: For some reason that felt like a scumclaim to me, but I guess he hasn't really been playing the game for a while now so nothing really new here.
yep : P he scum, now whats more likely? Is he trying to meta us into not lynching his scum buddy that he tried to lynch yesterday for "dat mad cred"?
Or perhaps, is gb just town XD
doesnt even matter though, we should lynch hopeless regardless : P
gumshoe, there's actually like a billion reasons in the thread for GB to be mafia from a whole bunch of people, and everyone has agreed with it... I don't know how you can still defend him, especially not from a random vote Hopeless threw down (lol).
I'm fine lynching Hopeless today though, that's probably the "correct" move given that he probably literally isn't going to post today now that he's voted. I do agree with Vivax's desire to see whether the wagons were M-T or T-T, but in either case we should lynch Hopeless so I don't think it actually matters that much. GB just has to be lynched tomorrow.
EPT
