[M][T] Crossfire Mafia - Page 27

On October 14 2015 22:06 Tictock wrote:
Ok I promised this, but I'm already rethinking some stuff. I'll be keeping up with the thread as I can at work, though I wont be able to post much till near EoD.

Probably Town
Rels - I should point out that Rels is a very strong scum player so people shouldn't give him an easy pass just because he's active. Still I have a hard time seeing him rolling scum 3 games in a row, and I'm not having any sneaking suspicions of him like I did in SoW2.
GlowingBear - I've agreed with most of his posts, he's not all over the place and causing confusion like I've seen him do as scum. Even the post where he suggested blues claim if they need to didn't feel like role hunting to me.

Town Lean
Koshi - Poked his head out way early, pretty active though most of it is complaining about the balance
deconduo - Joined the game late, made a decent reads post and was pretty much the first person to seriously push Cake. Probably would be a straight town read besides the fact he's been fairly inactive.
Sylencia - I'm actually not sure why I'm leaning town on Syl over straight null, something about his tone feels townie

Null
Onegu
CopCake
Superbia - I agree with GB, a couple of his posts felt towny. Continueing to throw out the "brb" thing after getting called out on it seems townie to me as well.
Alakaslam - Really not sure how to read Slam, he's low null right now because I don't have time to filter dive him and I don't recall anything he's done this game

Scum/Scum Lean
gobbledydook
MoosyDoosy
Xatalos


I didn't leave a note next to the people I've been discussing recently anyways.

On October 14 2015 17:27 Tictock wrote:


Humm, This is actually interesting. To consider the CPR role like a town Vigi.

I think that's the correct approach early in the game, the chances of CPR hitting a KP target and saving them out of a large pool of players is really low, even with 2 KP floating around. So using their power like a Vigi is legit.

However, Koshi, I don't get why you don't value the potential ability for CPR to offer a save as well as town KP.

On October 14 2015 17:31 Rels wrote:

Koshi. Once again what you're saying seems to make sense but is totally false.
1 - that's partly the case in every mafia game. If mafia members could just appear town, scumhunt, don't care about each other, mafias would be unlynchable. What makes the game playable is that mafias always plays differently because they (1) know they are mafias, and (2) because they have TMI. You're right that the (2) TMI component is mostly removed in this game; the (1) part is not though. Playing a role is exhausting, and not-town will slip roleplaying as town sooner or later. We have to catch that.
2 - you again forget we have potentially 2 medic or 1 medic 1 vig if the CPR dude is good. So even if we have 4 people 2 KP against us, we also have a lot of role power. For example in the worst scenario where we mislynch D1 and have 3 town killed N1: we are at 5/2/2. If none of these 4 dead were roles, we're still in a pretty good shape.

On October 14 2015 20:33 gobbledydook wrote:



Played with him before
He's far from useless at all
Terrible P Lynch

On October 14 2015 21:16 Xatalos wrote:
I think it's very unlikely that the anti-town factions would push members of their own faction in this setup D1, especially when the setup is so "swingy" and the lynch is everything but decided yet. It's not totally impossible, but I doubt they would want to immediately crash their chances of victory for a little town cred. I think these anti-town factions are quite unlikely:

Sylencia/CopCake
MoosyDoosy/Superbia
Onegu/MoosyDoosy
gobbledydook/CopCake
deconduo/CopCake

On October 14 2015 21:16 Xatalos wrote:


There's 0% logic there. The reads themselves are ridiculous, but the worst part is not pushing Rels if just "thinking Rels is town" is the reason to scumread someone (with that reasoning most players in the game would be scum btw). It's just hard to grasp she could be genuinely making these reads at all.

##Vote CopCake

On October 14 2015 20:33 gobbledydook wrote:



Played with him before
He's far from useless at all
Terrible P Lynch

On October 14 2015 23:01 Superbia wrote:
[Town]
Superbia
Glowingbear
Slam
TT
[Lean town cutoff point]
Rels
Deconduo
Xatalos


[Lean-Mafia]
Koshi

[Mafia]
Moosy
Copcake