Battle of the Drams Mafia - Page 153

On October 02 2015 12:02 rsoultin wrote:


look, seriously...the guy is already being railroaded

let him talk freely and don't ping him like this. rayn's approach where he throws zingers and sarcasm is both demoralizing and tilting at once, and if cool is town, this is not the way to help him show that to us

On October 02 2015 21:30 sicklucker wrote:


thats pretty townie

On October 02 2015 21:29 raynpelikoneet wrote:
rsoultin i have one simple yes/no question to you.

Do you think it's reasonable that you have been flip-flopping about my alignment for the whole game when you yourself repeatedly say you need to re-read me (and do nothing about it -- but STILL change your read on me from time to time?!?!?), say you are gonna do that re-read now (or as the next thing -- yes i can prove that), and you are supposed to be the "best player in this game (besides marv)" in reading me, as you yourself claim?

On October 02 2015 12:12 rsoultin wrote:
i'll have questions after my read-through

:/ still depressing y'all want to scumread me for my methods without being curious what they actually are lol

so i'll just lay them out for you guys and maybe that'll help you understand why i fluctuated as much as i did and am being really neutral right now

day ones i try to get townreads off general personality (tone/meta) type reads...if i can get a scumread off that (i.e. someone is behaving really outside the norm) i'll latch onto it like a bulldog but that doesn't always happen. sometimes it's just little doubts here and there and a collection of people i don't want to lynch

night one is usually the time for vca...i do mine differently than others on the site do. it works to some extent even with town flips. essentially i go through everyone's filters and see their read progressions and how they line up with their voting, add that in to context and what i know of them and shake out a reads list, but more importantly a ranking from there

^ this is what i haven't been able to do yet and i don't think a bunch of reads based on personality from d1 and general impressions/faulty memory 147 pages in will really do anyone any good. it will come tomorrow evening and i'm hoping to find some yummy things there ^^

On October 02 2015 12:15 coolTLname wrote:
i still think GB is maf , same reasons as before.

i honestly havent had the energy or time (defending myself) to read other people.

i believe trfels story

i dont agree with this guy

i suspect shining. shouldnt u think the opposite? or at least 50-50

Im gnona find whoever posted the role hunting 101 thing and anaylze him,

And the voting thread, i suppose it was odd the votes were tied 4-4 and that makes my hard claim of rsoultin look bad but i had many reasons , like rsoultin not voting trfel , being very actively reading , and even looked up her past 2 games where she was just flirty and not useful as mafia.

and the ppl i suspected, GB and rayn were voting AND they were just very silent, like they felt very relaxed and didn't care. Anyway like i said i eliminated rayn so that leaves GB. I read that GB usually posts like a crack addict, but he doesnt done anything, YET hes clearly been .. here the whole time. the way he voted and his poor conclusions and reads make me suspect him. And shortly after he received 3 votes a HUGE train came upon me of like 7 ppl.

On October 02 2015 21:33 raynpelikoneet wrote:
And btw i was being really fucking reasonable at least during N1 towards that guy.
I tried, he threw it out of the window. So yeah, there is that.

On October 02 2015 12:18 coolTLname wrote:
he even claimed roleblocker night 1 , btw. And damdred is roleblocked all of a sudden.

so i guess my onnly real read is GB right now. And whoever said i was role hunting 101 with the "can medics heal themselves" question is my #2 suspect

On October 02 2015 21:32 rsoultin wrote:


yes

i can see why it bugs you, but if you can't see that i was townreading you before your blind tunnel on me and that that tunnel when you'd been pushing scott might have an effect on how i was reading you, i'm not really sure how to make you see it

you saw how i struggled with palmar's alignment in gaiden 2 even though i originally thought he was pretty town, when he decided just to tunnel me -shrugs-

On October 02 2015 21:37 rsoultin wrote:


eh it's your approach i think, rayn, tbh, not specifically what you're saying

On October 02 2015 12:34 coolTLname wrote:
Wait it jsut occured to me that Marv would have been killed for a reason. I think u all assume .. well fuck it marvs rly good but he might have said something that really incriminated mafia so they killed him off. Regardless there must be a reason they thought he was so smart to kill n1, he proved it somehow

On October 02 2015 12:44 rsoultin wrote:


marvellosity is hands down one of the best players on the site. he was universally townread...and i don't really recall him pushing anything in particular? though this is back to murky memory here

assuming that this is correct, what his night kill suggests if anything is that scum is very comfortable with the atmosphere of the thread right now. which suggests to me that either you're town or scum is happy to buss the living shit out of you and has given you up for dead

nk analysis isn't terribly strong this early in the game, tbh

On October 02 2015 21:40 sicklucker wrote:


lol you dont remember him pushing you super hard? now your posting scummy again

On October 02 2015 21:39 raynpelikoneet wrote:

yeah obviously, when rayn tries to be reasonable let's take all the things he has said and call it an "approach" but when someone else does the same thing "give him some room".

And then people call this townie.
You are good at saying what people want to hear, i admit that.

On October 02 2015 21:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
why exactly would you suspect shining, sl?

On October 02 2015 21:43 rsoultin wrote:


at the time of his death he clearly thought i was town, sicklucker. please keep context in mind

On October 02 2015 21:50 sicklucker wrote:


his vote on scott. like i said mafia was probably pushing that and I dont think your mafia. There has to be mafia in there

On October 02 2015 21:51 sicklucker wrote:
rstoul i just read your posts. and I learned nothing about your reads on this game. they are absolutely filler. Like you are the filler posting champion. Like you are the god