EPTWhy can't Shinin' be scum with Marv?
My problem, no matter how I run this, I end up with like 4-6 mafia vs the town. I realize the extras are just 'afk' but I am not sure how to split them.
I have a headache now t.t.
Student Mafia XV - Page 40
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
Why can't Shinin' be scum with Marv? My problem, no matter how I run this, I end up with like 4-6 mafia vs the town. I realize the extras are just 'afk' but I am not sure how to split them. I have a headache now t.t. | ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:00 -Celestial- wrote: I'm not exactly. Its not a read. I was running a thought experiment on it to try to work out the logic progression. My point is that if Shining is scum his voting on FF only really makes sense if marv is also scum, because its a ploy to keep an option open to save marv if he suddenly comes back. And I'm questioning why scum!Shining ever does that given that scum!marv has done literally nothing so far. It would seem to be a really bad mafia play to me. And borderline suicide to attempt. Why make such a risky move to maybe try to save someone who isn't even about? Just as a small elaboration to that bit highlighted: If Shining is scum then there are four possibilities for FF and marv - 1. town!FF + town!marv 2. scum!FF + scum!marv 3. scum!FF + town!marv 4. town!FF + scum!marv If 1 then why would he even bother opposing thread sentiment on marv? It doesn't matter overmuch to scum!Shining which of two townies get mislynched. If 2 then I'd expect him to be looking for an entirely different target. If 3 then...well that's just weird and hella risky given the gamestate. The situation is quite fluid, there's a very real risk of him successfully getting a scummate lynched. 4 would seem to be the only logical option. Right now I really MUST sleep. Night.  | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:00 -Celestial- wrote: I'm not exactly. Its not a read. I was running a thought experiment on it to try to work out the logic progression. My point is that if Shining is scum his voting on FF only really makes sense if marv is also scum, because its a ploy to keep an option open to save marv if he suddenly comes back. And I'm questioning why scum!Shining ever does that given that scum!marv has done literally nothing so far. It would seem to be a really bad mafia play to me. And borderline suicide to attempt. Why make such a risky move to maybe try to save someone who isn't even about? .because im just that bad apparently. OO is probably town or just pocketing me but why pocket prime lynch bait. He can't be scum bcuz the same logic applies to me as ff. He could just pile onto my mislynch but he's taking the analytical approach like he did with ff. Im pissed because if Moosy is actually town and tunneling, which I'm having trouble believing right now, and ES is town, it means i have 2 votes with ff considering a 3rd. If I'm right on ff and wrong on moosy, it means at least 2 more scum will pile on me for the mislynch, since town Is doing the work for them. That's a potential 5 on me and vivax, onegu, stoic, gum, marv, none of them have been around to comment on me at all. Good point about the ES antagonism, though, that's Something to look into if/when i flip | ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:17 Eversince wrote: Why can't Shinin' be scum with Marv? Oh, he can be. Sorry I didn't make that clear. Its just that if they ARE scumbuddies its an incredibly dangerous mafia play he's making to try to save someone who hasn't even been around and who everyone thinks is dirty as hell. It just doesn't make sense to me for him to take that risk. | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
| ||
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:22 The Shining wrote: .because im just that bad apparently. OO is probably town or just pocketing me but why pocket prime lynch bait. He can't be scum bcuz the same logic applies to me as ff. He could just pile onto my mislynch but he's taking the analytical approach like he did with ff. Im pissed because if Moosy is actually town and tunneling, which I'm having trouble believing right now, and ES is town, it means i have 2 votes with ff considering a 3rd. If I'm right on ff and wrong on moosy, it means at least 2 more scum will pile on me for the mislynch, since town Is doing the work for them. That's a potential 5 on me and vivax, onegu, stoic, gum, marv, none of them have been around to comment on me at all. Good point about the ES antagonism, though, that's Something to look into if/when i flip I have yet to antagonize you friend. Start doin' stuff and dun' try to toss banter because I encouraged it. | ||
|
sicklucker
Canada16987 Posts
| ||
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
| ||
|
-Celestial-
United Kingdom3867 Posts
Unfortunately I think marv will flip red. Which means an awful lot more thinking will be required to work out any assocations. I planned on going to sleep approaching an hour ago now. X-( Okay, I'm turning my computer off. Laters. | ||
|
sicklucker
Canada16987 Posts
| ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
How about you question somebody or something instead of making useless one liners and questions that lead nowhere? Actually the more I analyze this game, the more I realize I'm a shitty D1er and always have been and my reads are usually always wrong. Now my top townreads are the scummiest out of the bunch IRT me and my scumreads are looking pretty good. Funny how shit works out. | ||
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:33 sicklucker wrote: Like im pretty sure all of you are town. Make love not war who's the bad guys then? | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:34 The Shining wrote: lol I did do stuff. Stop telling everybody to do stuff in every fucking post and you do something yourself. Srsly. You've done nothing today but piss me off, tunnel me, throw random questions and pokes everywhere with no conclusion and make a pointless post about a dress, contradict yourself on "if I'm town" but "lynching 100%", so you're admitting you're 100% going to lynch town so I'll let town handle that when I flip. How about you question somebody or something instead of making useless one liners and questions that lead nowhere? Actually the more I analyze this game, the more I realize I'm a shitty D1er and always have been and my reads are usually always wrong. Now my top townreads are the scummiest out of the bunch IRT me and my scumreads are looking pretty good. Funny how shit works out. I agree D1 is usually hard. | ||
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
| ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On October 12 2015 13:38 Eversince wrote: Wells, a dead shot is as good as any other to me. But I hope to stumble the chance in talkin' bout' it tomorrow. Do you speak like that or are you just doing an accent for fun? | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
| ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
And I'm choosing to ignore ES for the rest of my time in this game. I find it really BM that she has the nerve to tell me to do shit when SHE'S the one that first put me into a position where I was forced to defend myself, then continues to hammer that nail in. That's really not a town mindset, just pushing my tilt even further. Yolo. | ||
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
I can't be bothered to backtrack, so I am sure you can paraphrase for me. | ||
|
Eversince
Philippines2297 Posts
No chance o' this feller flippin' town. Not one. | ||
|
The Shining
United States2406 Posts
| ||
| ||
