[M][T] The New Personality Mafia

On August 19 2015 16:54 Rels wrote:
Summary of the game:
- people being stupid
- RNG shit with hidden variable not being RNG
- people being stupid
- HTS not being stupid

agreeing with her on ruxx.
##Vote ruxxar

On August 19 2015 16:54 Rels wrote:
Summary of the game:
- people being stupid
- RNG shit with hidden variable not being RNG
- people being stupid
- HTS not being stupid

agreeing with her on ruxx.
##Vote ruxxar

On August 19 2015 12:33 Half the Sky wrote:






Scum.

ruXxar is totes scum.

On August 19 2015 12:34 Half the Sky wrote:
I mean what is that shit. Even LS says/does more than that shit as town.

##vote ruXxar

On August 19 2015 18:19 Rels wrote:

You know you are supposed to roleplay someone else than yourself

On August 19 2015 10:18 ritoky wrote:
We should lynch Fidei

After reviewing the game, I have arrived at the same place. Fidei is the best candidate for lynch both objectively and subjectively.

The Objective Case:

RNG has selected fidei, he is mafia. If you need an explanation of how he was selected please reference my filter. Outside of that RNG is PARTICULARLY suited for this game. This is a closed setup, and historically in closed setups there is an incredibly strong likelihood that there are more anti-town players than are normally in an open setup. So with that alone our probability of hitting mafia from RNG has already increased by a significant margin. However, there is more. We are playing a game in which people are attempting to act like other people and mask their own play as someone else's. This means that day 1 reads and particularly day 1 meta reads have a diminished rate of accuracy. Meaning RNG is the optimal line of play. A situation with increased odds of hitting mafia and diminished validity of meta reads clearly points to RNG being the objective best line of play.

The Subjective Case:

Outside of RNG declaring fidei mafia, he is actually mafia. Consider his posting thus far:



There are 3 aspects to this post that I would like to highlight:

1) The most classic mafia play ever: "Notice me senpai -> excuse about activity". His final sentence has no point other than to say hi I am here and fade away.

2) He is drunk or at least partially. This is important because drunk people are more prone to letting slip things or not being careful with their wording. Will be revisited later.

3) His immediate entrance response into the thread is to seek out me and essentially claim a personality to me in a very half-assed manner. First and foremost there is not point to this because he knows who I am and once RNG has declared him mafia, appeals to emotion are pointless only hard logic can deter me. Secondly, it may be coincidence but singling out the only person calling him mafia and appealing to them directly reads as an over-response to pressure. And finally the half-assed imitation. This will require some explanation.

I think people who are committing heavily to trying to act the part of the player they got rolled into and are sticking to it for a decent portion of time are very likely to be town. I feel that it is a risky play to play in a manner unlike yourself and in one that could potentially draw lynch attention to you for not playing "serious". Mafia are averse to both risk and lynch pressure on day 1, and thus would be less apt to fully commit to acting the part of someone else. I do not necessarily read legitimate frustration with the game type or completely ignoring who you rolled as scum though, I don't think the converse works. However, the half-ass attempts read as scum to me because it seems as if it is a mere "LOL"/attention grab for a few moments for them or a tool to further their agenda. This is the area fidei falls into in my mind.

Continuing on, and credit to Tubesock on the find here:







This goes hand in hand with point #2 from above, that fidei is drunk. He made an obvious error that speaks for itself. I can elaborate further, but I feel these consecutive quotes are very self explanatory. Not only did tubesock find it important but so did others:





And what was fidei's response to this important question?



Ignoring it and complaining. I hate to break it to you, but this is a regular mafia game already, and this is a real accusation; and you really are mafia.

Fidei is objectively and subjectively the best lynch in the game, anyone not voting for him is taking a sub-optimal line of play and is bad.

On August 20 2015 17:30 Rels wrote:

wow
that's stupid
you can't possibly think that

On August 20 2015 17:48 Rels wrote:

Yes new (stupid) scum does just that.

Yes new (stupid) scum does just that.

No. Doing that if you're mafia and tubesock is town is super stupid. Hence why I think you're a team.

But contrary to all those lurkers, you are a lynch candidate today. It's garanteed that if you didn't post for 24 hours you would be the lynch.

On August 20 2015 00:24 VayneAuthority wrote:


What is this? How is she trying to start a conversation by posting asinine walls of text that have nothing to do with the game? you are bad.

On August 20 2015 17:59 Rels wrote:
I think you're scummy. Didn't like the fact that you attacked ritoky when drunk (so you read the thread) but didn't know Damdred was Chezinu (so you didn't read the thread).
read the thread + didn't read the thread = someone told you you were attacked = guy with a QT = probably mafia

I think tubesock is mafia though
##Unvote
##Vote Tubesock

On August 21 2015 06:53 Rels wrote:
OK with that ruxx switch

On August 21 2015 17:00 Rels wrote:
OK WOS' EOD was good actually
stating ruxxar was likely town 'cause mafia shows up and defend themselves at deadline
pushing for tubesock
hope tubesock is shot actually so we have infos

On August 22 2015 03:14 Rels wrote:
Hts
I switched because I townread you and I followed you
And because of the soft blue claim
In retrospect he was roleplaying ls fakeclaiming

On August 24 2015 01:35 Rels wrote:

No ?

On August 21 2015 02:39 Half the Sky wrote:
Another point I want to bring up I believe geript and WoS in their filters brought up competing points on Lord Tolkien at some point.

WoS townread him for meta, wasn't really specific if I recall right. geript scumread him for being below expectations (paraphrasing, correct if wrong) - personally without playing with him I didn't like certain points. geript, what changed about him, and why should/shouldn't we lynch him?

On August 22 2015 07:53 geript wrote:
This game has a guy who claims he has to vote randomly
This game has a guy who nuked someone for funsies
This game has a guy who refuses to play but people didn't want to lynch instead of the person with the longest filter
This game has 2 replacements who are currently still just as bad as the previous players
This game has a claimed 3P

Half the fucking game is playing trying to be fucking mafia. This game is cancer. Fuck this game

On August 24 2015 03:01 Rels wrote:
So this is false ?

It's like the only reason I'm not pushing hard for your lynch.

On August 24 2015 03:06 Rels wrote:

What ?

On August 24 2015 02:59 Rels wrote:
Plus, I'm not a fan of his constant "I'll re evaluate later" and doing almost nothing this phase.

On August 24 2015 04:58 Rels wrote:
Shining

Your original point was that I was not aware KSC had a greencheck
I proved it was false
Move on

On August 24 2015 05:13 Rels wrote:

Talking about fidei read ? Was convinced by HTS' post + WOS post which said tube was scummier than fidei

don't like how he came back to the thread though, waiting for his big post

and WOW i'm really the leading wagon p: geript I thought you didn't want to lynch me

On August 24 2015 05:26 Rels wrote:

Yes. Why are you voting me ?

On August 21 2015 07:38 geript wrote:

There were 4 good lynches yesterday and 5 people who voted for any of those four. At very most, there's on mafia in those 4. That means it's better to look at the main wagon and the straggler votes.

On August 24 2015 05:56 Rels wrote:
OK that is super true
rayn scumread geript when he came into the thread by just reading 30 posts


After the night he still scumread him

And now he's sheeping him.
Makes no sense.

On August 24 2015 06:45 Rels wrote:

What is your rule already ? So you can have a check

On August 24 2015 06:47 Rels wrote:

??

On August 24 2015 07:22 Rels wrote:



LOLOLOL

On August 24 2015 07:24 Rels wrote:

Not true.

Fuck what is this fucking broken nuke.

Funny how you start giving a shit about the game now that you're not dead anymore. (=

On August 24 2015 07:25 The Shining wrote:
Oh NOW you wanna play after a ninja vote to try and save rayn and avoiding a failed nuke? No.

Lol if you think I'm only scumming you for scumming Fidei, yur silly. I just came off him as scum for his EoD actions.

Where were you at eod? Where were you all d2? YOU HAVE NO POWER HERE, SCUM

On August 24 2015 02:49 Rels wrote:
@geript a read on tubesock ?

On August 24 2015 01:00 Rels wrote:

@geript could you answer that ?

On August 23 2015 11:08 Fecalfeast wrote:

would kill:
BM
KelsierSC
Ritoky
Chezinu
yamato77

would kill but probably shouldn't:
Damdred
fidei86

town reads:
fuck it

On August 24 2015 16:56 Rels wrote:
@geript

Can I have a answer to his now ?



And will you answer this fucking question you dodged 3 fucking times ?

On August 24 2015 22:16 geript wrote:

He was nuked an I didn't expect him to live.

On August 24 2015 23:14 Rels wrote:

Your point being ?

On August 25 2015 07:40 ritoky wrote:


at least say who it was and why you checked.

On August 25 2015 16:50 Rels wrote:

Yeah. It is also more plausible that he didn't.

On August 25 2015 17:57 Rels wrote:

lol think about it more then

Checks
FF: WOS green N1, geript green N2, LT no result N2.
Bill Muray: Breshke green D2.
KSC: geript green N1, LT red N2.

On August 25 2015 19:33 Fecalfeast wrote:
1 i did not believe KSC had an alignment check in the first place.