[M][T] The New Personality Mafia - Page 2

On August 20 2015 16:26 Fidei86 wrote:


Okay I have a bunch of thoughts.

1. Damdred is a strong player, especially towards the later part of the game. However his reads early on are usually quite meh. In Holy Guardians he was 100% wrong on all of reads until like d4 when he solved the game and got insta-NK'd.

2. There is no point in even bothering to parse his posts so far - they are garbage. Clearly he is role playing. Fine. But exactly as I said viz Onegu in Holy Guardians - he's easy lynch bait later on if he doesn't stop messing around. I would be pushing him harder, but there are too many people who haven't been playing the game properly (as I think of it anyway.. Pushing, giving reads, interacting on meaningful stuff) for a policy lynch to make sense. I think I had what, nine people on my 'lurker' list? Pretty sure some are Mafia, but they can't all be.

3. Damdred and ritoky always claim that they have a super good read on each other. So far, from the games I've seen, their reads on each other are usually right. So honestly if I was going to listen to someone's opinion of Damdred, it would be ritoky (especially now ritoky seems to be engaged in the game a little more).

On August 20 2015 16:30 Fidei86 wrote:

A predetermined meta is literally the easiest thing to stick to. Well, perhaps it's slightly harder than just lurking, but not by much. My reads were all mostly on that sort of 'superficial' level too, so I don't think it's necessarily scummy from you, but I don't think your reasoning there is particularly sound.

Let me go and read some more filters before I answer you definitively. Off the top of my head, I'd probably say Tubesock. I'll go read his filter again now.

On August 20 2015 16:50 Fidei86 wrote:

I'm not saying it makes sense that he keeps getting NK'd, I'm just saying that is what has happened in previous games. And this isn't Kelsier being bat - from what I've seen its what he does every game.

And as to scumming you - that was my read at the time. I need to update it now but I've been stuck in this dialogue with TT. I will obviously update my reads. But I don't see that I should just refuse to give a read because I haven't played with you before? And if I caveated every read with "but I haven't played with him before" that would be tedious. And I don't need to if I'm not basing the read on meta.

On August 20 2015 23:53 Half the Sky wrote:




Alright, so Tube, you told me that your "you scum Damdred" was in response to Fecalfeast. Fine.

You explained why you thought Damdred was useful but where are you distinguishing he's town? Is there a quote? A reaction? A response?

There are several players that are saying (besides myself) that a) he could be roleplaying as either alignment, geript himself has said he can't get a read (or positive town/not town read either way), so taking that assumption and even if he's getting reactions, how do you know he's not doing it as scum?

Am I making sense here?

On August 21 2015 03:23 JudgeJudy wrote:


I just re-read Chezinu's filter and I'm satisfied enough to ##Vote Chezinu.

We really should start consolidating on a couple of targets so it's not a last minute thing that comes down to the three people who happen to be around at the deadline.

On August 21 2015 03:38 Half the Sky wrote:
On mobile, bear with me....



That's actually a really poor reason not to lynch a guy or even townread them. A mafia player can townread someone and sheep someone for bad reasons, those same points were being brought up I believe against Rels. The bias on Chez is understandable since I recall you have your ways with some of the harder players to read (generally) but someone being "fun" I don't value the same as being town, I realise it's a personality game and I can understand a tone read on someone being lighthearted (normally) associating with being town, but I don't see the way you've listed as a valid reason for being town.

Also why is your vote still on Fidei? The other two I realise have been afk for a bit, but...

On August 21 2015 03:39 Half the Sky wrote:
WHAT??????

Tube did you even read some of Fidei's latest posts? Maybe I'm biased because I know his play better but how the hell is he still a top scumread?

On August 21 2015 04:39 geript wrote:
It's not great wave. But it's big picture for me. Plus I'd rather lurker lynch. Off if I lose to people who post. Hell I don't give many fucks about this game but let's at least enjoy lynching the assholes who don't even play.

On August 21 2015 05:01 KelsierSC wrote:


perhaps but the brilliant minds taking this game too seriously have taken 44 pages to come up with "lynch lurkers" so i'm happy with my content.

On August 21 2015 05:49 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


Was talking about rux lol.

On August 21 2015 05:39 The Shining wrote:


i don't do D1 and neither does my personality hahaha. i hate it, always have, always will. big crapshoot. I found my d1 scum and i'm sticking with it. i've seen nothing Tube has done since then to dissuade me. soft blue claim, yuck. Rels case on tube is a good one because it's a case on my scum, ya? I especially like the bolded part. but the other parts are good too.






so ur saying the two wagons are both scum? that's a bit of a stretch for d1 in a game this big. and I see no shenanigans or any huge mass push to save either one of them. i think rux is town and taking the hit for my scum, tube.

i also think kelsier is scum because IM the towniest town to ever town and anyone trying to plynch or scum me is scum or bad. that's MY personality. he's trying to steal my identity, which means he's hiding his, which means he has something to hide. kill him.

I think that also answers your questions on who else i think is scum. i have tube, kelsier scum. damdred and geript and chezinu and Rels are my bros right now. especially damdred. i like cheznoes. HtS looks broish but she's a sneaky one, it could be deceiving. lines of questioning are good but i am iffy about being led to do reads on other ppl instead of coming to them myself. but u get a pass today cuz i like ur questions.

i don't like list posts and i thought i didn't like lords list post. but I reread it a few times. i don't wanna lynch him today, he left a lot of info and thoughts to track back to if necessary.

and fidei did good to fight off rng. looks towny to me.

this post way too long for me but i m too lazy to spam today