EPTOn one hand you would expect town!rsoultin to stop making weak attacks like "your vote is still on milo, HA, I caught you" but on the other hand you'd expect town!HF to stop writing paragraphs defending himself against every little thing if he thinks rsoultin is scum.
TL Mafia LXXI: Gaiden - Page 208
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On one hand you would expect town!rsoultin to stop making weak attacks like "your vote is still on milo, HA, I caught you" but on the other hand you'd expect town!HF to stop writing paragraphs defending himself against every little thing if he thinks rsoultin is scum. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
Anyway I'm down for a damdred lynch today. I'd be fine with milo tomorrow obviously but I also think we should be considering wave/vivax/scott who have all pulled the disappearing act which would make sense if their scum buddies are currently under scrutiny and they don't want to be forced to comment on it. | ||
|
scott31337
United States2979 Posts
On July 10 2015 03:30 Clarity_nl wrote: I'm really struggling to see how both rsoultin and HF can be town with the way they're shitting up the thread every time they're both around. On one hand you would expect town!rsoultin to stop making weak attacks like "your vote is still on milo, HA, I caught you" but on the other hand you'd expect town!HF to stop writing paragraphs defending himself against every little thing if he thinks rsoultin is scum. My instinct is telling me this as well, but they could just be two townies with their ego's in a pissing contest. In a couple days when one of them is still alive we just lynch the other right?  | ||
|
scott31337
United States2979 Posts
On July 10 2015 03:47 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: lool marv you just can't let it go. Anyway I'm down for a damdred lynch today. I'd be fine with milo tomorrow obviously but I also think we should be considering wave/vivax/scott who have all pulled the disappearing act which would make sense if their scum buddies are currently under scrutiny and they don't want to be forced to comment on it. Lynch Damdred Lynch Milo tomorrow unless something magic happens and then probably you the next day? You misspelled "my" BTW. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
On July 10 2015 03:49 scott31337 wrote: Lynch Damdred Lynch Milo tomorrow unless something magic happens and then probably you the next day? You misspelled "my" BTW. lol you literally only show up in the thread when someone says your name which means a) you're reading and b) you're probably scum for active lurking | ||
|
scott31337
United States2979 Posts
Inb4 MZ's magic bus theory scum tries to pull on me every game as town even though I've been going after Milo since the beginning of time. Who would you like to lynch tomorrow? Which of us three are the most scummy in your opinion? | ||
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On July 10 2015 03:54 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: lol you literally only show up in the thread when someone says your name which means a) you're reading and b) you're probably scum for active lurking Who said his name? :S | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On July 07 2015 07:09 geript wrote: Scott31337 Clarity_nl Vivax Bill Murray ritoky Meapak_Ziphh Trfel LightningStrike ObiWanShinobi milo109 Oatsmaster Damdred rsoultin XEliteBlueHunter69X People not currently in my town circle I keep coming back to this list, because I feel really, really strongly about it. I kinda have all game. I don't know if it has all 5 mafia on it. And I really struggle to verbalize my reads sometimes. Either way, I'm going to presume that Damdred and Milo are both mafia. I think MZ is likely mafia in that case too. I think I'm ok with Clarity because he makes on making posts that I look at and skim and feel ok about while being like I really don't want to read this. I get Oat's line of thinking but I really fucking hate it; and Oats usually has an odd way of working things out late in the game for some reason. Scott31337 Vivax ritoky Trfel LightningStrike ObiWanShinobi rsoultin XEliteBlueHunter69X Ritoky is an odd situation for me. Damdred being RB makes sense, but so does framer. I kinda hope that he dies with me and solves it. Like mechanically, it makes the most sense for ritoky to be town, but there's just something about his play that keeps on bugging me when he posts. Of these though, OWS has gotten a wide range of townreads that I really struggle to understand. I don't read him well as a player at all because I find him a bit insane/nuts/whatever. But I just don't really in any way understand why people are townreading him. It bothers me because I can't quite place my finger on why. But I feel like more people would be wanting to kill him in combination with just the odd (or lack of) reasons for townreads on him. I can't really explain the rsoultin read, but I kinda think she's town. I think I read her wrong last game or something. I don't know, but I do know that I'm oddly comfortable when she posts. I even liked her odd shitfight with HF. It's nothing specific but I get the sense that she's town. It's kinda weird, because I think she's a mason with someone. Maybe like trfel. Vivax is one that really bugs me. Part of my issue with him is that I feel like he's divorced from reality. For me though, that's not something I find easy to think even he's town as. Like he has crazy ideas and throughts, but he's struggling to even follow the reality of the threat while at the same time picking at people who are both easy to pick at AND live in different worlds for me. Let me try to explain that better, I don't try and do associative reads; however, there's always a thought in the back of my head of "a team could be like XYZ or ABC" or whatever. But when I read the combined sense of Vivax's pushes, it seems to X and A. He seems to think people that don't make much (if any sense) together are scum together. He also has an odd way of completely ignoring talking about active subjects to propose wanting to talk about like Me and Damdred or Me and Trfel. Or Wave. He's also a player that despite being exceptionally out of touch in many ways with what's going on, somebody really seems to care about. Plus there's an odd combination of bitching about things while equally remaining behind the scenes. I could probably go on on him for a while. The rest of them I'm really meh about. EBH too. He's odd. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
I said it in my previous post | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On July 10 2015 03:47 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: lool marv you just can't let it go. Anyway I'm down for a damdred lynch today. I'd be fine with milo tomorrow obviously but I also think we should be considering wave/vivax/scott who have all pulled the disappearing act which would make sense if their scum buddies are currently under scrutiny and they don't want to be forced to comment on it. can't hold it back anymore | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
NEVER FUCKING LYNCH WAVEOFSHADOW!!!!!! Seriously. IDK what it is and I can't explain it at all quite yet. But I will hate you forever if you lynch him. And I didn't feel super safe about him last game at all. Maybe never lynch Holyflare. At best, I'd only consider him in Mylo (given milo/damdred/MZ). And even then I'm not sure I would. I'd have to think about a lot of things. But I had a strong townread on him early and I'm really struggling with a reason to exchange that in any way right now. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
I know it may be hard for you to entertain a world where you're wrong about something, however you have already flipped sides on ritoky/milo but it's ok for you because you did it for the "natural reasons" whereas my read based on their attitudes to the game was "wrong." Anyway if you could pull your head out for a minute and look at wave/vivax/scott that'd be great | ||
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:08 geript wrote: Either way I'm going to say this right now because I feel really strong about this. NEVER FUCKING LYNCH WAVEOFSHADOW!!!!!! Seriously. IDK what it is and I can't explain it at all quite yet. But I will hate you forever if you lynch him. And I didn't feel super safe about him last game at all. Maybe never lynch Holyflare. At best, I'd only consider him in Mylo (given milo/damdred/MZ). And even then I'm not sure I would. I'd have to think about a lot of things. But I had a strong townread on him early and I'm really struggling with a reason to exchange that in any way right now. That's like really surprising to me. WoS doesn't even seem interested in the game at all, how on earth could you feel so strongly one way or the other about his lynch? :s I hope you find a way to explain before the end of n2. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:08 geript wrote: Either way I'm going to say this right now because I feel really strong about this. NEVER FUCKING LYNCH WAVEOFSHADOW!!!!!! Seriously. IDK what it is and I can't explain it at all quite yet. But I will hate you forever if you lynch him. And I didn't feel super safe about him last game at all. Maybe never lynch Holyflare. At best, I'd only consider him in Mylo (given milo/damdred/MZ). And even then I'm not sure I would. I'd have to think about a lot of things. But I had a strong townread on him early and I'm really struggling with a reason to exchange that in any way right now. wave has literally all the trappings of an apathetic who's had a couple team members caught in the last day. Also Palmar had him on a scum list and I'm always inclined to give weight to dead Palmar's reads. I agree lynching HF is a terrible idea though. | ||
|
Harkon
569 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:08 geript wrote: Either way I'm going to say this right now because I feel really strong about this. NEVER FUCKING LYNCH WAVEOFSHADOW!!!!!! Seriously. IDK what it is and I can't explain it at all quite yet. But I will hate you forever if you lynch him. And I didn't feel super safe about him last game at all. Maybe never lynch Holyflare. At best, I'd only consider him in Mylo (given milo/damdred/MZ). And even then I'm not sure I would. I'd have to think about a lot of things. But I had a strong townread on him early and I'm really struggling with a reason to exchange that in any way right now. I can tell you now already that I will not follow this at all and I also won't advise town to do so. I will give some credit to your Waveread even though he is basically not playing this game, fair enough. But you can't read HF and I will ignore you and your early day1 read on him. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:10 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: I know it may be hard for you to entertain a world where you're wrong about something, however you have already flipped sides on ritoky/milo but it's ok for you because you did it for the "natural reasons" whereas my read based on their attitudes to the game was "wrong." Anyway if you could pull your head out for a minute and look at wave/vivax/scott that'd be great i love your digs, they're hilarious i'm one of the least tunnelly players on TL Mafia, and i am literally always entertaining the idea i'm wrong. Ask anyone. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:11 Clarity_nl wrote: That's like really surprising to me. WoS doesn't even seem interested in the game at all, how on earth could you feel so strongly one way or the other about his lynch? :s I hope you find a way to explain before the end of n2. I just got out of a game with scumWave and I've played half a billion games with him. It's a lot of little things. Our interactions. How he jokes with me. And his first post. I put a lot of stock in early posts especially for townreads. Plus, I think he would've said a little more. Like Wave learned to play mafia with me when there was more of a 'thread sentiment' focus imo. And he has a really unique and interesting way of looking at how to approach why and when to post as mafia. And I'm pretty sure he'd post a bit more. Maybe not much but a bit more. I'd also like to point out that what MZ is saying is wrong. I don't think Wave or Vivax has posted since the day began. I'm quite sure Vivax hasn't since I just filtered him. That gives me a little pause but meh. Either way, it's really, really stupid to make an apathetic argument for either of them imo. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:18 marvellosity wrote: i love your digs, they're hilarious i'm one of the least tunnelly players on TL Mafia, and i am literally always entertaining the idea i'm wrong. Ask anyone. You need to revisit your "not listening to geript's crazy reads" thing. They always turn out to create more information in the least and I'm right quite often. In the least, I find a way of working it out usually in a way that reveals my alignment. | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:18 marvellosity wrote: i love your digs, they're hilarious i'm one of the least tunnelly players on TL Mafia, and i am literally always entertaining the idea i'm wrong. Ask anyone. Well I'm glad I'm keeping you entertained. So since you've caught the damdred/milo/MZ scum team talk to me about the final two scum? | ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6788 Posts
On July 10 2015 04:20 geript wrote: I just got out of a game with scumWave and I've played half a billion games with him. It's a lot of little things. Our interactions. How he jokes with me. And his first post. I put a lot of stock in early posts especially for townreads. Plus, I think he would've said a little more. Like Wave learned to play mafia with me when there was more of a 'thread sentiment' focus imo. And he has a really unique and interesting way of looking at how to approach why and when to post as mafia. And I'm pretty sure he'd post a bit more. Maybe not much but a bit more. I'd also like to point out that what MZ is saying is wrong. I don't think Wave or Vivax has posted since the day began. I'm quite sure Vivax hasn't since I just filtered him. That gives me a little pause but meh. Either way, it's really, really stupid to make an apathetic argument for either of them imo. No you're partially wrong. Wave has posted this: On July 09 2015 10:02 WaveofShadow wrote: I remember thinking Trfel is town purely because he is playing nothing like the last game where I was scum with him, but I feel like that on its own is kinda silly. Most of all he's likely town simply because he doesn't act/play this terribly as scum. brb On July 09 2015 10:31 WaveofShadow wrote: I mean I've been skating (u gotta sk8) but for him to assume he's done anything but is silly. There's some odd stuff in his filter to be sure (open 'bluehunting,' trying to steer active and useful conversation, his most recent 'KP-carrying' post) but I can't be certain it's mafia indicative necessarily. The worst thing about what you mentioned Breshke is that he asks for opinions without giving any concrete thoughts himself which reeks of fishing for thread sentiment. Could be scum I suppose. On July 09 2015 10:33 WaveofShadow wrote: Oh also I remember not feeling rsoul this game for whatever reason. Doesn't feel like same rsoul who I pocketed via arguments in whatever game that as. Also maybe HF 'cause HF On July 09 2015 10:38 WaveofShadow wrote: Totally would have won that game if I didn't let yamato convince me to shoot you I don't wanna get into another semantics argument like I did with marv but this seems pretty apathetic to me. He's in the thread but he's barely talking about the game. | ||
| ||
