On May 12 2015 12:17 Oatsmaster wrote: Voting BM. There's no way he takes this game so seriously as town.
Xata is scum. BH also might be scum..
I want to lynch you.
Very hard.
Your reason to vote BM is bad and you think BH might be scum, so you're assuming Mafia wasted 2 nukes and 2 anti nukes over nothing. Like lol
One nuke was fake and why not get cred?
Also bm basically killed someone at the start of the day. Does that sound townie to you? Nope. And all his reasoning is real sketchy but he's trying hard so he clearly cares. A townie that shoots someone at the start of the day does not care.
You sincerely believes Mafia wasted that much things just to try to gain a town cred they aren't getting at all?
On May 12 2015 13:05 Oatsmaster wrote: Like lynch.
BM didnt nuke to look townie, what are you talking about GB.
I would deffo lynch xata
This is what I'm talking, oats: You posted that you're voting BM but says that BH might be Mafia as well.
Which means you assume Mafia INTENTIONALLY nuked someone just for BH to anti nuke. Then Mafia AGAIN wasted a nuke so his Mafia partner AGAIN ANTI NUKES.
Then you say they are trying to get town cred. Now you say BM wasn't trying to get town cred.
On May 12 2015 13:05 Oatsmaster wrote: Like lynch.
BM didnt nuke to look townie, what are you talking about GB.
I would deffo lynch xata
This is what I'm talking, oats: You posted that you're voting BM but says that BH might be Mafia as well.
Which means you assume Mafia INTENTIONALLY nuked someone just for BH to anti nuke. Then Mafia AGAIN wasted a nuke so his Mafia partner AGAIN ANTI NUKES.
Then you say they are trying to get town cred. Now you say BM wasn't trying to get town cred.
I'm confused.
Wasnt the second nuke fake or something? I didnt see a host message.
I saw a host message for both nukes, if I saw it right.
The point is valid, anyway, and for your reaction it does seem that you thought about it and that you think it is plausible LOL
A day vigi is completely different from a nuke. How can you tell truffle is certainly town?
On May 11 2015 13:10 Bill Murray wrote: TalkingDead Oatsmaster HalftheSky
I've read all three of you pushing suspicions my way When I bag scum with this (Trfel was super active last game, and is literally just skimping by posting to not put his neck out there this game) I want you all to bow down to me. ##Nuke: Trfel
On May 11 2015 16:39 Hapahauli wrote:
Moderation Announcement:
Bill Murray's nuke has been shot down! It will no longer explode at the end of Day 1.
On May 12 2015 13:41 Damdred wrote: GB could you tell me what you think about
Xatalos, me and Palmar?
Nope because I still haven't read the thread properly
I'm just coming by and pinging out odd things I see
I must say that, for what I've read, I think Xatalos is very underwhelming and isn't caring for the game as he usually dies as town. But I haven't spotted any scummy things yet.
You started looking weird. I understood your post wrong as you stated night0 and I decided to ignore you because I thought you looked townie (active and fluid reads), so keeping a "suspended" scumread on you could keep you alive after night0 (I thought Mafia was going to shoot lol).
Palmar... I don't know, I haven't seen anything suspicions on him yet, but also nothing very townie. I need him to get playing the game properly to further analyse.
I will save another post to say my current Mafia list is
On May 12 2015 13:44 Oatsmaster wrote: meh ok fine
Nononono not fine.
1) Why truffle is town? (You compared BM's nuke to a certain ##shoot townie) 2) Why were you scumreading BH? 3) Why Xatalos was a better lynch than BH? 4) Did you not realise the nuke and anti nukes wasting thing before?
Damdy, you asked me questions, never followed up. You said my read on BH is good, but it didn't change your vote, nor created interest in you to pursue more information on him.
Can you give more inputs about this? Let's lynch BH? Would you lynch Oats? What did you make of my answer?
On May 12 2015 20:41 GlowingBear wrote: Damdy, you asked me questions, never followed up. You said my read on BH is good, but it didn't change your vote, nor created interest in you to pursue more information on him.
Can you give more inputs about this? Let's lynch BH? Would you lynch Oats? What did you make of my answer?
dude you arent fucking lynching me again day 1 for no reason.
Ok lets lynch Xata then.
100% scum. Im not even kidding
I'm not lynching Xata.
Let's lynch BH?
I don't remember lynching you on day one ever.
Also, care to answer my questions? Filter dive me, there is an ordered list of 4 directed to you
Sandro, your point is okay but you're evaluating it only through a mafia perspective when there is the possibility of a tunneled town there that is eager to focus only on the things that confirms his scumread, like any other tunneled townie. More than that, you can't decide he is mafia for that one single post when his overall gameplay fits a townie perspective much more.
You also said that
now BM is silly but I don't think this point you make makes him more or less mafia. I think a town would like to justify his actions when pressure is on him just as much as a mafia. I don't understand how you are so sure about this. I can understand and share the feeling of wanting to lynch him regardless just so he doesn't get away with this as mafia and I feel like a tard for letting it happen, but having seen BM's town play I deffinitely think it's just as much possible for him to be town in this spot, no matter how absurd his actions and reasons are.
This flip on his read felt very unnatural and opportunistic.
On May 12 2015 21:17 sandroba wrote: Except that he isn't tunneled. He was calling trfel town prior to that and made that post and flipped his read again. It look to me more that he was desperate and trying to get something to stick. I don't believe he was tunneled at all. He deliberately left out part of the first post and lied about the time between the 2 posts.
I've just filter dived him and never found a town read on truffle... Not even once... BM being mafia isn't outside the realm of possibilities. But for me he is looking much more townie than mafia + people I scumread voted him + your unnatural flip made me wary
On May 12 2015 13:44 Oatsmaster wrote: meh ok fine
Nononono not fine.
1) Why truffle is town? (You compared BM's nuke to a certain ##shoot townie) 2) Why were you scumreading BH? 3) Why Xatalos was a better lynch than BH? 4) Did you not realise the nuke and anti nukes wasting thing before?
Come on oats. You are quoted here, there are 4 ordered questions, and you couldn't find this? Lol
You know what the problem is with this day1? Everybody is talking but nobody is listening.
Read how some people blindly agree with voting BM without even having any further analysis regarding him, or presenting any attempt to solve the game. See how marv says Onegu is OTT and BM is mafia for acting crazy. Then see how useless he was the entire day1. He comes to the thread only to say "BH is not the lynch" when a lot of things happened. See how some people are conveniently ignoring oats.
And all you guys do is call people Mafia without looking closer to people's reaction, or call me bad because I have good reads but I have a hard time to convey my thought process.
Just please organise yourselves, take step back, and think.
Just see how easily people are switching to Xatalos
And I'm Cicero, the Pardoner. That pardon is legit.
On May 12 2015 23:47 Damdred wrote: Idk what's happening in the thread I just woke up and saw that pardon, and I kist want to say dumbest thing ever. Bm could be town but having town talk about him for another day is stupid
##kill bill murry
back to catching up
If this is legit, congratulations, damdy, you've just threw all the debate regarding Bill murray in the trash bin since he won't flip.
On May 12 2015 23:47 Damdred wrote: Idk what's happening in the thread I just woke up and saw that pardon, and I kist want to say dumbest thing ever. Bm could be town but having town talk about him for another day is stupid
##kill bill murry
back to catching up
If this is legit, congratulations, damdy, you've just threw all the debate regarding Bill murray in the trash bin since he won't flip.
This is the only reason why the shot is not just really really good.
The shot is horrible. Bill Murray dropped enough information in thread for us to work with. He was active, he was talking, he was fluid, he was batshit town. He could be dealt day2.
There are a lot of people I have no idea about. RoL, Batsnacks, Onegu, Stutters... People we have no information and we are carrying into day2. And day vig shoots BM.
I can't help but think Damdred is mafia for that. I may be biased because he shot my townread, so I will cool my head for a bit and come back later
On May 12 2015 23:47 Damdred wrote: Idk what's happening in the thread I just woke up and saw that pardon, and I kist want to say dumbest thing ever. Bm could be town but having town talk about him for another day is stupid
##kill bill murry
back to catching up
If this is legit, congratulations, damdy, you've just threw all the debate regarding Bill murray in the trash bin since he won't flip.
Would you like a mirror?
I would like a gun. To kill all of you who simply doesn't understand that we don't lynch active people day1.
We don't get to know his alignment with the shot. If you think this is similar to a pardon, I'll just fuck off
EPT![[image loading]](http://img.thesun.co.uk/aidemitlum/archive/01611/BOMB-620_1611903a.jpg)
