Newbie Student Mafia IX

On May 03 2015 11:23 Fecalfeast wrote:

I wanted him to make a direct conclusion rather than leave it to iinterpretation

On May 03 2015 13:05 sicklucker wrote:


So you would vote the guy that already said he would probably not play day 1 as either alignment? solid

On May 03 2015 12:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
gonna tone down on my spam, I forgot this is a newbie game. Nobody wants to read 20 pages of FF spam

On May 03 2015 14:06 sicklucker wrote:
The threat is understandable. Actually doing it on the other hand

On May 04 2015 02:03 ritoky wrote:


he made one of the highest quality observations in the thread in regard to shining and i had literally the exact same thought reading the exact same thing:





he is also giving definitive alignment reads instead of hedging. if i remember prp's play right he hedges a lot more as mafia.

On May 04 2015 02:20 ritoky wrote:


? we thinking of the same guy? prp is a low volume poster as both alignments. he is like a 9-11 page over course of an entire game kind of player from my experience.

On May 04 2015 03:21 -Celestial- wrote:


Jury still out. I still think he's looked pretty scummy but he's been getting better and he was, after all, my weakest scum read in the first place.

The reads lining up isn't alignment indicative. Could be collusion, could be two people of either side coming up with the same thing, could be sheeping influence from the thread.




I know you have no reason to believe my word on whether or not I'm on a team with scott but if I was on his team I wouldn't have bussed him so early and so quickly.




As I mentioned in my last game I've played this quite a lot with people I've been in plays with (its a common team building and warm up activity in rehearsals). Plus I've played the SC2 mod. So I'm pretty comfortable with the game in general, just not the forum format in particular.


On a side note unless we seriously get some solid reads out of Stutters695 soon I'm going to start scumming him just for completely ignoring my repeated requests for sets of reads.

On May 04 2015 03:39 prplhz wrote:

if you want to lynch me for low post count then you should do it now because i'm going to post a lot less this game. that game (like many other games) i tried to spam myself town. that's also why i have joined out of time mafia, because i want to stop spamming so much. anyway the reason i haven't posted a lot is because i haven't been around.

@superbia @ritoky what do you think about celestial? he is coming on as super tryhard, like nothing i've ever seen before. he stands out a lot compared to the general relaxed atmosphere in the thread. didn't filter him yet (dunno how much i can get out of that this early anyway) but it's just something that been sticking out a lot.

also @superbia happy birthday!

On May 04 2015 04:06 Tictock wrote:
Allright done with work for the day, so I can actually be active here for awhile.

A couple reads of the thread thus far have left me with the following read/feels.

-Celestial- A pretty clear town read. The initial reads are all very clear with good reasoning. While there is a bit of tunneling happening on scott celestial has given clear reasons why.

scott31337 Seems scummy for sure. I can looks past the initial voting stuff,to an extent, but the reactions to the pressure do not read as town to me at all.

Fecalfeast I was originally going to give FF a town read as he seems active and engadged, but looking at his filter I find nothing solid in his posts. That puts him neutral for me, with maybe just a hint of scum.

I'll have to dig through more filters to see if I can get more reads. I have a hard time putting much stock into my D1 reads with the level of fluff posts and pressure plays, but I'll keep posting about what is standing out to me.

On May 04 2015 04:26 Tictock wrote:


What makes him clearly town to you?

On May 05 2015 04:34 The Shining wrote:


I do. I thought I scummed him somewhere for it, I might not have posted it, though. He claimed to have read my past games but I'm not sure I believe him, unless it was "these posts look about the same size and posted the same, good enough." He claimed my filter here looked those town filters. If that were the case, he'd know I opened this game exactly like my last town game. Name 3 random ppl who have alrdy posted, call them scumteam, gg. He'd also know literally any time I've been scummed, I defend myself tooth and nail. So scumming me for being bitter and sardonic when he's the reason I'm bitter(scumming me over an HtS slip that was clearly in her filter) instead of looking at it objectively just looks like trying to push me.

It felt more to me like he asked for those games, skimmed 1 or 2, claimed to read them for town cred(what scum would read games to figure out meta? they know alignments) and then let it go.

On May 05 2015 05:01 The Shining wrote:


So after eod? =/

On May 05 2015 06:33 Stutters695 wrote:
##vote: Scott31337

Just in case I'm not here closer to the deadline.

On May 05 2015 08:42 Half the Sky wrote:


I see where you're coming from with this and it would make sense in a world where Superbia is town. Right now with the rest of his behaviour at EoD, though, I'm not seeing it. As for me, I had my vote on where I felt it was mafia and I felt no need to change, and Superbia was only looking bad to one other person. I also had Celestial as town, so between that and my additional observation on Scott (not townreading Superbia prior to sheeping him on me early game) I honestly felt my vote was in a good place.

On May 05 2015 23:33 Superbia wrote:
Stutters, you were obviously around at EoD. You responded to my ninja ping out within seconds. You were lurking. Why the fuck would you lurk at EoD if you were town?

On May 05 2015 23:53 prplhz wrote:
i actually think stutters is best lynch tomorrow just for that single thing

On May 05 2015 23:52 disformation wrote:
also inb4: Frustration is a sign for scum.

@Stutters:
Any other reads so far? Besides me and prplhz? Only other thing in your filter is talking about Superbia's ninja ping.

On May 06 2015 02:30 Half the Sky wrote:


I have yet to play a game with ritoky as town tbh. I've played 2-3 games with him where he was scum, and one where he was third party serial killer.

On May 06 2015 02:40 ritoky wrote:


your opinion is not very high on my list. and no i haven't been all over the place like this in a very long time. i also haven't rolled VT in over 10 games.

how is it wtf. she is posting giant posts about other people and really pushing them for info. i just don't see the conviction behind her push on prp. like she says lynch him with fire, but i don't get that sense. if someone votes on me EoD then fks off, i become a legit wagon, and he comes back makes 0 comment and moves onto a new target; i would be on him like white on rice. i was expecting more of a response.

On May 06 2015 03:40 Superbia wrote:
HtS how in the hell are you reading stutters as town?

On May 06 2015 03:46 Superbia wrote:
Actually that's kind of unfair because you literally posted 10m ago, but it holds for EoD1 and probably d1 in its entirety.

On May 06 2015 03:57 ritoky wrote:


phrase it in a manner that says "hey asshole, when you get back respond to this or i will lynch you" rather than "hey....so how was your day? by the way, y'know if you notice or have time, could you like please answer this question that i left? if not, okay i guess i understand"

there's a difference between inquiring about something cuz your interested and want to see where it goes and demanding an answer cuz that asshole is probably scum. she should be doing the latter, but seems to be doing the former.

On May 06 2015 03:51 Superbia wrote:
Also Stutters, HtS, what do you think of your d1 performance?

On May 06 2015 05:53 Fecalfeast wrote:
current scummers: sl, shining, maybe super, maybe ritoky

maybes based on tonereads recently.

town: HtS, disambiguation, -c-

Playing video games til daypost

On May 06 2015 04:28 ritoky wrote:


You're getting this wrong. The manner in which the question is posed doesn't say anything about prp. It says something about HtS.

On May 06 2015 06:56 Fecalfeast wrote:
dystopian future is posting more freely than I think a new scum would. So toneread I guess

sl rubbing me the wrong way seems more concerned with calling himself town than with finding scum,
shining should actually be stutters for only entering the tthread when talked about

y0su doesn't bring anything up in my brain when I think about him do you have something on him?

On May 06 2015 08:15 Superbia wrote:
Like I believe that there was a divide between team Superbia and team Celestial yesterday, and I think both teams are town at this point in time, which kind of explains the lack of activity at EoD1.

That leaves me with towns:
- Superbia
- Ritoky
- Celestial
- Half the Sky

I am fine with throwing prp in there as well. My town read on y0su is pretty much gone. I am expecting huge things from The Shining, as his pre-game excuse has vanished.

On May 06 2015 08:28 Superbia wrote:


He has echoed my thoughts on multiple occasions. Why do you have him as scum?

On May 06 2015 08:32 Superbia wrote:


This is not how you solve the game. If you're town you need to re-think right now. Let's assume prp is scum. Who is scum other than prp? What's his team?

On May 06 2015 08:09 prplhz wrote:
eh i'm at reconsidering things. i had FF sort of townish so that doesn't really give me much new. trying not to tunnel anybody like i tunneled bourneq last game.

like, the reason i think hts is scum is because she called me scum for doing X without considering that a lot of people agreed with me on X. she's treating me different for some reason but then i just remembered that in last student mini she did kind of the same thing, she metad onegu (and on false meta but she didn't know that) but refused to meta me. i'm just trying not to tunnel.

gonna read some stutters games and see if he really play like this d1 because then i'm really nowhere.

i have you as pretty firm town though. same with ritoky. guess i'm susceptible to town read people who think roughly the same things as me.

On May 06 2015 08:53 Superbia wrote:
How many times did you edit that post before you posted it?

On May 06 2015 09:00 Superbia wrote:
Hmm okay. Can you give some thoughts on the people you have not mentioned yet on the list above? Apologies if you have mentioned them somewhere before. I always prefer to get your current reads and I don't really want to filter dive every time before I interact.

On May 06 2015 09:46 Superbia wrote:
If you have a red check on prp you should just claim tbh.

On May 07 2015 01:36 sicklucker wrote:


50% chance theres a veteran in the game. Mafia will always roleblock ff last night incase hes a veteran so they dont lose a kp. This is just standard mafia play and the correct play. Maybe I should lower it a bit because it is a newbie game but I know super 100% makes this play.

0-25% added because super might claim rb as mafia even if theres not a veteran because he has won games doing it before (meta)

thats how I got 50-75%

On May 07 2015 01:56 sicklucker wrote:


Hts just linked it. Its not me to say if you should lynch me if im wrong or not. But making mathematical mechanical game decisions is kind of my town play style and im right more then im wrong

On May 07 2015 02:01 sicklucker wrote:
It can also be said you know im wrong and are setting me up for a mislynch. Anything is possible keep your eyes open make the best judgement youb can and prepare to be wrong alot

On May 07 2015 02:10 sicklucker wrote:


Im offering you a really good lynch math does not lie! This preflip blame is hella scummy

On May 07 2015 02:24 ritoky wrote:


am assuming you mean prpl? if he was such a good lynch, why did you do nothing to get him lynched?

On May 07 2015 02:25 ritoky wrote:
EBWOP: why did you do nothing d1

On May 07 2015 02:45 ritoky wrote:


i did read your filter,








here are all of your posts before the flip on prpl. this is not him "being a good target since d1" or you pushing a lynch on him. yes you had a scum read, but for him to be a "good target" that means you have to push him as the lynch candidate and really make the case for him being scum. you made no cases, never called for his lynch, and instead did a lot of this:



so sorry if i am not buying your revisionist history.

On May 07 2015 02:58 ritoky wrote:


the only difference btwn d1 and n1 is scott flipped town. why does scott flipping town make prpl more likely mafia?

On May 07 2015 03:37 -Celestial- wrote:
Like...right now I don't know what to think on Superbia. I think sicklucker has got a point but I'm all over the place on the guy.

But prplhz is just...bright crimson right now. He's done nothing but lurk and try to pretend to contribute. And yet Superbia has been hard town reading him literally the entire game because "he's thinking the same as me, making the same reads" despite the fact he's made virtually no reads at all.

Seriously just wtf. prplhz looks terrible and Superbia's constant defending is honestly weirding me out. I almost think it would be worth lynching Superbia right now because of that one thing.

On May 07 2015 04:49 Half the Sky wrote:
Stutters, I think I asked you this question before, but I don't recall an answer earlier and I cannot find it in your filter.

If prplhz disappeared from the game, for whom would you vote?

On May 07 2015 05:13 Superbia wrote:
K nvm, prp's filter is way different than his VT filter (way more active as VT, more jokey, more one-liners). This wagon is okay-ish. Pressure definitely needed.

On May 07 2015 07:32 prplhz wrote:

what the fuck is this even

On May 07 2015 07:50 ritoky wrote:
am gone until later. cross your fingers for no more preg complications.

On May 07 2015 21:49 Half the Sky wrote:
If prplhz does flip scum I think ritoky and Superbia should be revisited as both hard towned prplhz for mindmeld or something.

On May 08 2015 23:36 Half the Sky wrote:
I also find it amusing that Stutters has gone completely dead silent since his last post. Probably threw in the towel.

On May 09 2015 01:35 Tictock wrote:
Oh Stutters is around!

So Stutters, if you were Vig. Who would you shoot tonight?

On May 09 2015 03:54 Half the Sky wrote:


prplhz was lynched. He flipped RB. That's why we're asking the next scum....

On May 09 2015 06:15 -Celestial- wrote:
Except its directly pertinent to the night kills because if I'm right Superbia could be shooting the wrong person.

Explain why you outright believe ritoky's claim that disfo was claiming for him despite the fact that disfo has NOT confirmed this yet.