Busy IRL and this game is hard to keep up with. I wake up to 10 pages everyday. Takes two hours to go through everything.

If I didn't replace out would you not have killed me/Holyflare? Judging from the qt it sounds like it.

Bourneq

Sweden800 Posts

April 17 2015 21:22 GMT

#2387

Good game well played all. Holy fuck this game is hard. I dont fucking know how to make reads. Everybody stop lying and just speak the truth like me. So easy win that way.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

April 17 2015 21:24 GMT

#2388

lol all the obs qt warriors ^^

yeah i have no clue how to react naturally to being scumread when i'm scum? my first response is usually...well lol yeah you're right, hts

...

obviously can't post that xP

and jjb and i even talked about staging a fight but our schedules never converged and we forgot lol ><

truffle dude you handed us one with bourneq...scum isn't pushing him that was a gem xP and tube wasn't playing to survive. he was our buss strategy so lol course he looked scummy

that was the point

really good play by tube in the end for his first scumgame

bourneq your game was great man for your first game...i think you got discouraged later because of the scumreads all game but you really did do a good job lol >< prp townreading the other two for basically nothing but giving you flak was unfortunate, cause i would have said you were the most clearly town of the 3 ^^

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

April 17 2015 21:24 GMT

#2389

On April 18 2015 06:22 Soren333 wrote:

Show nested quote +

ya I know what you mean, coming back from work and seeing like 10 pages to read really sucks lol

I've heard there's some games where they limit # of posts and post length?

plotspot

800 Posts

April 17 2015 21:25 GMT

#2390

Sorry for bad play.^^ As the game went on I actually understood how detrimental bad town play is to the whole town constitution. It's like you're making it really easy for mafia to push things, for mafia to appear that it's not their own idea they are pushing, but just pushing things that town was already in for.
And also reaching a certain state, explanations wouldn't help anymore. Especially the kind of helpless explanation provided by clueless newbie players, basically just defending themselves, forgetting the actual scumhunt, which makes it easy for mafia to convince other townies that these guys don't do townish things.
I think towards the end I kind of thought Tube was mafia for his dispute with Breshke who is by that time obvioulsy VET. rsoultin was kinda in my scope es well, but she defended herself really well. JJB? Looks very townish and towards the end of game kinda AFKed away, maybe because he didn't see the need to interfere anymore.
The Bourneq thing is kind of unfortunate, it was a 50:50 situation. I think the remaining people were more willing to lose like this than Bourneq really being mafia in the end with his unresolving way, uncommitted way. I can feel for him and TBD, they are basically in the same shoe as me. We don't have the experience to make the RIGHT effort and detail out what is commonly regarded as good standard town play under pressure.
I must admit you guys are really committed to this, especially Trfel, who really reread everything and made the right case on Tube. All in all the effort of reading, arguing and counterarguing cannot be replaced. The mafia team put much effort into this, imo makes them the deserved winner. Well played.

Blazinghand

United States25558 Posts

April 17 2015 21:28 GMT

#2391

Good job playing this game, everyone! The next Student Mafia is open for signups here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/483087-newbie-student-mafia-viii

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

April 17 2015 21:28 GMT

#2392

On April 18 2015 06:21 Bourneq wrote:
lmfao you guys are such fools

. HOW ARE YOU NOT SCUM PRPLHZ OMG LEAVE ME ALONE WTH

lol right?

prp totes got the scrub sibs thing right tho lol

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

April 17 2015 21:29 GMT

#2393

pls pls pls don't scumread me in future games for being wrong though lol >< i do that all the time i'm not marv/hf lol ><

hey plot! <3

i'm glad you and bourneq plan on playing again in the next newbie!

Bourneq

Sweden800 Posts

April 17 2015 21:30 GMT

#2394

On April 18 2015 06:24 rsoultin wrote:

bourneq your game was great man for your first game...i think you got discouraged later because of the scumreads all game but you really did do a good job lol >< prp townreading the other two for basically nothing but giving you flak was unfortunate, cause i would have said you were the most clearly town of the 3 ^^

Lol! I was about to write I feel really discouraged in one of my last posts but I didnt. Thanks for the kind words :D. I really struggled putting together cases against people and D3 I was sure that whatever I said scum would be able to pick apart and make me look bad. I bet I could of defended me quite nicely but the more I defend myself the more guilty I look.

I have learned SO MUCH this game so I think I can confidently sign up for another one with a little more experiance.

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

April 17 2015 21:35 GMT

#2395

On April 18 2015 06:29 rsoultin wrote:
pls pls pls don't scumread me in future games for being wrong though lol >< i do that all the time i'm not marv/hf lol ><

hey plot! <3

i'm glad you and bourneq plan on playing again in the next newbie!

Bah I had that as part of your town meta so idk. Now it's nai for you =P

Yeah I'm happy you guys are playing again. Next newbie seems to be filling up fast.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

April 17 2015 21:38 GMT

#2396

On April 18 2015 06:35 The Shining wrote:

Show nested quote +

Bah I had that as part of your town meta so idk. Now it's nai for you =P

Yeah I'm happy you guys are playing again. Next newbie seems to be filling up fast.

o.0 what's part of my town meta?

lol generally any meta argument for me is bad lol >< it's why i go GRRRR at people trying

tone you can catch me on lol

and forgetting to post legacies that too >> nice one bresh...had to really dig through my games to find examples where i didn't do it as town lol ><

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

April 17 2015 21:41 GMT

#2397

I'm gonna be honest with you guys. I might not play again. I don't think I have thick enough skin for this game and I'm really struggling with the time commitment. I really the people in the game though! Some of you guys had some pretty good jokes lol

Trfel

7015 Posts

April 17 2015 22:10 GMT

#2398

You're kidding me. I was sure Bourneq was a free lynch. I wasn't caring about anything else.

Why would scum not push Bourneq there?!?!!?!? Not even at all? Scum pushed basically everyone else, everyone but Bourneq.

I'm so sorry, I just thought that there was no way Bourneq would be town when he was completely ignored like that. And I thought that that fact alone outweighed any analysis I could possibly do. Loss is on me, I stopped playing when I thought the lynch was guaranteed to work.

Tubesock was obvious enough, and rsoultin and jarjarbinks were definitely on the table. There were good reasons to townread prplhz, and I could have made myself unlynchable once the next day started. We would have actually been in a good spot if I had just townread Bourneq.

Trfel

7015 Posts

April 17 2015 22:12 GMT

#2399

On April 18 2015 06:38 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

What? You never make legacies (or only make bad ones) in games I play with you....

Ugh, I guess there goes my strategy of not reading you and hoping you get night killed first.

Anyway, I figured Tubesock was the godfather.

Anyway, I'm sorry for replacing in. I had the time to catch up on the thread, I didn't have the time to truly play the game at a high level after catching up.

Trfel

7015 Posts

April 17 2015 22:19 GMT

#2400

I guess I probably spoke up about Bourneq too early. Scum just kept him as reserve in case, and didn't bother pushing him throught the day (it wasn't really necessary). And I got excited and jumped too soon.

Ugh. I guess you learn as you go.