Town Puppy and Blazinghand are probably town. Someone pointed out that it fits the flavor for there to be two people and there is literally no reason for mafia to fakeclaim that on day 1 (if one of them is 4real mafia just shuts the fuck up and shoots the other in the night). I haven't really read their posts though.
I thought prplhz was town yesterday. He made the point about me not reading OPs but didn't seem to really jump to conclusions over it. Howerver I sorta feel like he's disappeared and not been much of a factor in the game since then but still. I actually used to pride myself on being basically a prplhz whisperer because I'd always know his alignment. So maybe I'm just shit.
prplhz could be town? I don't know, but I didn't get the feeling he was trying to call me mafia for reading the OP, he just pointed out that it was strange behavior for Palmar to do that.
He ended up bussing prplhz near the end, never really talked to Town Puppy but two mentions before he died.
If marv is town, rayn is probably town too, in fact, it's extremely likely that most of marv's reads are correct, no matter his own alignment, because he's usually not blatantly wrong when he's mafia, just wrong enough not to lynch his entire team.
(after Rayn died)
On November 30 2014 08:06 Palmar wrote: Oh, I guess I'm okay with people who are mafia getting themselves modkilled.
Also, I was literally just about to drop a mega analysis on why rayn was mafia, so I'm claiming credit for that. This is 100% true.
On November 27 2014 08:07 geript wrote: Was that supposed to be a joke Sn0?
This is the hardest post to figure out so far. It feels like a pretty aggressive post for so early in the game. Maybe it's just me but I basically imagine geript being super snarky when he wrote that, which is sort of a strange attitude for this early in the game. I haven't really read on so I don't know where geript was going with this, but still. Then again, forcing things in the early game can also be a town move.
On December 02 2014 00:47 Palmar wrote: Did geript explain what happened that made Sn0 go from "pls modkill" to "top town"?
Cause that statistical quote seems awful.
I am tempted to just randomly JK into the unclaimed players who could be mafia (geript, superbia, sent, obi, jat etc) to try to stop the night kill.
His next scumgame came from April 2014 so that doesn't really seem relevant anymore. Looking at it though he seems to never bus until the very last moment. He certainly finds reasons to call mafia town in the early phases so that exonerates Ritoky for me.
Then again, reading that Russia Today game, there was some drama postgame where Rayn said he never wanted to be in a scumteam with Palmar again so it's possible a bus erupted out of hate, but meh.
On March 27 2015 01:41 Artanis[Xp] wrote: Then again, reading that Russia Today game, there was some drama postgame where Rayn said he never wanted to be in a scumteam with Palmar again so it's possible a bus erupted out of hate, but meh.
I also think this is unlikely because Palmar doesn't really carry over frustration from other games. Each game is just a game to him. Rayn might bus palmar, but I don't think Palmar would bus Rayn.
In a world where fake mason claims run rampant... Where meta cases are hijoled without a second thought... Two arch enemies are forced to band together with a common goal.
To lynch the Slamfish.
Unlikely Alliance - Vivax & Artanis. Coming to a cinema near you.
On March 19 2015 20:38 raynpelikoneet wrote: Please Palmar explain this.
You call me probably mafia for "not being dick to you". I answer that i am never dick towards you when i am town, and that it's your job to do that to me if you are scum (yes, that's what my post says and don't you even dare to say you don't understand that). You respond with some smartass comment (which in fact IS being dick towards me) and proceed on calling me mafia.
So again, can you show me a game where i am being a dick towards you when i am town Palmar? A game where i start it. I know there are a lot of games where i lose my cool when YOU do this kinda stuff, but that's not relevant.
I vaguely suggested you may be mafia based on one parameter that by definition isn't even that good. My post didn't even imply that I actually think you are mafia.
The fact you've taken that way out of context and basically treat it as me considering you guaranteed scum is an overreaction of the highest order.
Emphasis mine.
Then, Holyflare and Artanis vote for raynpelikoneet. And Palmar reacts as follows:
On March 19 2015 22:46 Palmar wrote: Is it okay that I scumread rayn for being a dick to me when I previously scumread him for not being a dick to me?
And still doesn't vote for raynpelikoneet. Why does he change what he already stated was a joke into a scumread as soon as it picks up momentum? And still not actually vote with it?
I'll hold off on voting until I get some more feedback regarding lynches on Onegu and ritoky, but those are my preferred lynches. I suppose if neither of those are accepted, Fecalfeast or Alakaslam could do.
On March 19 2015 20:38 raynpelikoneet wrote: Please Palmar explain this.
You call me probably mafia for "not being dick to you". I answer that i am never dick towards you when i am town, and that it's your job to do that to me if you are scum (yes, that's what my post says and don't you even dare to say you don't understand that). You respond with some smartass comment (which in fact IS being dick towards me) and proceed on calling me mafia.
So again, can you show me a game where i am being a dick towards you when i am town Palmar? A game where i start it. I know there are a lot of games where i lose my cool when YOU do this kinda stuff, but that's not relevant.
I vaguely suggested you may be mafia based on one parameter that by definition isn't even that good. My post didn't even imply that I actually think you are mafia.
The fact you've taken that way out of context and basically treat it as me considering you guaranteed scum is an overreaction of the highest order.
Emphasis mine.
Then, Holyflare and Artanis vote for raynpelikoneet. And Palmar reacts as follows:
On March 19 2015 22:46 Palmar wrote: Is it okay that I scumread rayn for being a dick to me when I previously scumread him for not being a dick to me?
And still doesn't vote for raynpelikoneet. Why does he change what he already stated was a joke into a scumread as soon as it picks up momentum? And still not actually vote with it?
I don't see how this makes raynpelikoneet town.
Hm, fair point. I just saw him mention Rayn a couple of times as well as a vote but I didn't check to see if that made it to the vote thread. I guess it doesn't exonerate Ritoky yet.
I've read your reasons for wanting to lynch Onegu, but I've only heard you counter arguments to townread Ritoky. What makes you scumread him to the same level as you do on Onegu?
On March 27 2015 00:07 Toadesstern wrote: Palmar/rayn interactions make it somewhat more unlikely for rayn be town but he never put his vote where his mouth was, even when there were times when rayn looked like a possible lynch such as:
On March 27 2015 00:07 Toadesstern wrote: Palmar/rayn interactions make it somewhat more unlikely for rayn be town but he never put his vote where his mouth was, even when there were times when rayn looked like a possible lynch such as:
On March 20 2015 14:10 Half the Sky wrote: Day 1: Current Vote Count