EPTOn March 02 2015 09:27 Snickers wrote:
Why are we not lynching kelsier.
Also ff knows about this.
Why are we not lynching kelsier.
Also ff knows about this.
Yup, this post here.
Mini Mafia Down Under 2 - Page 7
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Yup, this post here. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
but I haven't reread filters yet, oats | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Secondly, I think the key to this game right now is getting reads on the lynchbait (lurkers, policy lynches) because we’ve got too many: To that end, Oatsmaster is town precisely because he was AFK during the Slam almost-lynch. A profile check shows that this lack of activity was thread-specific. If he’s mafia he should be bussing or jumping on another wagon. That he didn’t care means he’s likely not scum here. The Robik push was actually pretty good, too, with the way Robik has been playing this game, and he’s been in the thread scumhunting both nights. I’m comfortable putting him as solid town. That leaves the more difficult trifecta of MM/Onegu/Snickers. MM has a super clean filter. It’s kind of startling how clean it is, even. Clear thought process with prp’s overreaction to a joke, the pressure vote on oats followed by consolidation on to previously stated scumread prp, not having a good read on slam…lol it’s not like slam’s easy to read really especially if you haven’t played with him much, and regardless of alignment that AFK excuse isn’t one you make up. Too unusual xP So. I’m going to put him at a town lean here. Not as solid as Oats, but he feels townie to me. Snickers…okay, I’m just gonna say it. I have no good specific reason to think he’s town here and yet I still do. Call it a soul read or a mindmeld or something…but he and oats both have been saying things I’ve been thinking (him more than oats) throughout the game. Long-ass filter, interesting comments sprinkled in with the trolling, a case tonight when there was no need for him to put that work in. This doesn’t make him 100% town but I can’t shake the feeling that he’s not scum here. That leaves Onegu. I had a townread on him earlier that I think was preemptive. I still find it strange that his entire filter Day 1 was on Slam if he’s scum. Like, the only thing that makes sense to me then is that scum was bussing Slam from the beginning, or that the wagon took off too quickly and he didn’t feel he could move his vote without looking suspicious. Simplest answer is scum bussed slam or Onegu is town. Classic low-hanging fruit approach to Day 2, though. MM, Oats and Snickers…lol. Note how I mentioned trying to get reads on the lynchbait? The vote onto Super was bad, too, when he had MM as a stronger scumread, but I’m not sure how that makes sense as a scum move unless Robik is scum. Null leaning scum. Would lynch, and the scummiest of the four. TLDR; Town Oats – vote Day 1, follow-up on Robik Snickers – mindmeld, night work Town Lean MM1 – clear thought progression Scum lean Onegu – lynchbait scumreads, EoD2 vote | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
I'm just gonna remove ritoky from consideration right now. His voting has looked bad, between piling on Slam last second and not moving EoD2, but I just can't get past all the work he's put in in between. I go into his filter looking for scum and can't find anything but an awkward start. You're town to me, ritoky. And if you end up being scum, this was an excellent game of yours and I'm not sure why you'd try so hard when getting mislynches should be pretty easy here for scum lol. Robik On March 03 2015 05:29 IAmRobik wrote: Signup List 5 Trfel 6 prplhz 7 Onegu 8 Alakaslam 10 MysteryMeat1 11 Oatsmaster People I could lynch today. Trfel - weird content. I was able to clear in previous game. not able to this game Prplhz - why me? fry me Onegu - not sure why but would maybe lynch Slam - not sure why but would maybe lynch MM1 - don't want to lynch but lack of content is disturbing Oats - i might just be bitter cause he was a meanie to me last game and tried tunneling me Low-hanging fruit + maybe would lynch Onegu(scummiest lurker)/Slam(scum) for...no reason? Weird as shit. His read on Snickers seems like TMI (objectively Snickers has looked more townie recently, and I never like the too scummy to be scum argument). The argument that he always NKs Snickers is not only WIFOM, but stupid if he's scum and gone on record saying Snickers is a PR. Palmar was scumreading him (along with ritoky, and I'm town and probably ritoky is) and looking like shit himself. I'm just not seeing any real scumhunting in his filter. He comes in when people start scumreading him, gives reads when asked, but where is the pressure? Also, lol at the pushing prp wagon claim. The hell he did. That's almost as funny as Onegu claiming he was the main force behind the slam lynch. Yup. His filter is like 60% defensive posts...80% by Day 2. I'm really happy with a Robik lynch. Sidenote: Damdred I'm having trouble reading. Gut says town. Filter says town. Little things bug me. The last minute switch, for one, and that it came after Onegu voted Super. Also having one scum on Slam and one on Prp seems strange to me. I mean, it probably happens, and could be explained by Onegu not being in-thread near EoD I guess, just seems like a general lack of commitment from the scum team. Damdred also falls in the category of doing an awful lot of work for a game where scum can easily coast, though. TLDR; I really think Robik and Onegu are the scum here. Questions about anything...I've got two posts left before EoN. So I probably will hold off until closer to the flip and address them all in one post, if there are any. Feel free to ask though ^^ | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
5 on Super 3 on robik 2 on MM The people potentially available to switch were: me (had already said I'd only switch to MM), ritoky (Super, MM or me were the people he was looking into Day 2), onegu (mm, oats, snickers, super)... So yes, if all three of us decided to switch to you in that last minute and a half when you were exposed, robik, you would have died. But it's a bit of a stretch to say that there was any reasonable expectation that this would actually happen. In fact, you switching back last second at all is a crazy level of paranoia, imo. Possibly even indicative of a guilty conscience. Meanwhile, you get the credit for being "willing" to lynch someone other than a mislynch, as demonstrated by your vote which you announced in thread...though you didn't seem terribly interested in broadcasting the fact that you were switching back to Super. There is certainly scum motivation for making a switch that minimally exposes you for a grand total of 90 seconds, especially when it detaches you from culpability of a mislynch. More to the point, you are still not trying to solve the game. If your innocence is supposedly so "obvious" now...where is the analysis to help town? - Onegu, oats asked you a question. Unlike me you actually have plenty of posts to engage. - Reserving last post for EoN | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
well, why would he claim doc at night, snickers? I mean...what exactly are you trying to say? o.0 why were you protecting robik, onegu? robik actually has a high chance of being scum -_- do you have a metaread on him or something? | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
your "selfless" act isn't very selfless in the context of that lynch, now is it? how is it impossible for scum to switch from super to mm even if they're both town? switching back doesn't really mean anything other than just generally being odd to me, cause why would you switch back anyway if it was 6 seconds before EoD? actually...please explain your thought process there, cause if no one was switching to MM or switching at all I don't understand why you had to move your vote also, are you ever going to pick a scumread and actually push them? | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
I keep going eeeeeh at his EoD play, but his filter actually looks decent :/ | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
I am quite happy to lynch robik. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
i'm not great at meta but if rit can do this as scum...and robik usually just screams at ppl scumreading him and otherwise sits around with his thumb up his ass as town...then i'm on the wrong track | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
not that my opinion matters since i'm only confirmed town to myself xP | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
But I would like your reads in general. Yes, that would be nice. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On March 08 2015 14:07 Snickers wrote: So from glancing at robiks meta in that game and from what I remember this game. HE IS SCUM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol in what way? xP I at least gave my admittedly superficial reason on ritoky ^^ | ||
| ||
