Eh, if I'm wrong about you LS, I'm just wrong. Your filter looks town to me ^^ So congrats if you tricked me, but lol, I doubt rereading it a third time is going to make me feel any different.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

February 23 2015 04:07 GMT

#3942

Okay, I need to get this up since I'm still working on schoolwork, and I don't want to find myself rushing my reads 5 mins before deadline.

SOLID TOWN:
BH - obv
Superbia - obv
Lightningstrike - I can't shake the toneread, or the fact that he's so easy to target. He keeps making cases and pushing people to read them/improve on them. He's responsive to new information, but willing to stand by convictions. And I see no reason for him to behave as he did during Palmar's lynch if he's actually scum.

TOWNISH:
Alakaslam - I actually like BH's assessment of you, and think that you've contributed enough interesting things this game - while being generally light in tone - to remove you from immediate lynch consideration. I also have the same feeling on your reaction to Palmar's lynch as I do LS,' if to a slightly lesser extent because I don't think you were in the same danger he was in if he actually managed to convince us to switch to prplhz (or at least not kill Palmar)

FecalFeast - I'm getting a pro-town feel from you. That huge filter is just insane compared to the other games I've played with you. There are some moments where you've said precisely what I was thinking, and that's something I normally associate with town. There's still an inkling of a doubt that you may be the SK, but only if other options are exhausted.

prplhz - Lightest "townish" read. Not a huge fan of your early play before you went largely inactive, and in the back of my mind I'm wondering if perhaps the wagon switched to Palmar so quickly because it was actually scum-favored, which would suggest you or LS is scum...and I'd bet you over LS. That vote on Breshke that VA pointed out, however, is a strong point in your favor. So is Palmar's read on you, and you were also actively trying to find not just an alternative lynch, but the right one (as it appeared to me) at EoD yesterday. I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt for now for these reasons.

SCUMREADS:
Half the Sky - <3 you, lovely, but you've had a lot of really underwhelming plays this game. Kudos on the case-building. However, the miller claim was blah and your reasoning to do so (marv) was either a misunderstanding or flat-out lie. The BH tunnel isn't cute anymore, and your initial scumread on him was contrived. Just because people are handing out townreads for paranoia doesn't excuse an outright refusal to see reason. This "all players who switched to Palmar are town, all who didn't, especially protesters, are scum" is so over-simplified, it's disgusting, and feels like nothing more than an obvious excuse to flip your read on LS.

Ritoky - You're hot and cold, man. Almost 100% convinced you're the SK, simply by taking a good look at just when you're cold, but the spurts of activity followed by lack of interest could easily make you scum as well. LS I'm pretty sure is town, and as prplhz is likely town, too, AFKing yesterday when the lynch seemed set on LS and wasn't showing signs of hitting Palmar at all until maybe 5 minutes before deadline could just as easily be a sign of over-confident mafia. Certainly Palmar fell into that category.

VayneAuthority - Maybe I'm misunderstanding, but with two scum dead you should be on fire. Your few posts may seem townie, but anyone can write townie posts with that short a filter. The "prplhz wouldn't buss Breshke" point is interesting, but it was just a reason to townread him, and to a paranoid mind...secure the LS lynch while deflecting suspicions off yourself. I have yet to see any active scumhunting going on from you. To be fair, this is mostly PoE, too, and I'm not as sure on you as others.

FF*** - special mention...I really don't think you're the SK anymore, but if ritoky isn't, the likelihood is high based on several of your comments during EoD yesterday, and a general sense that you're much more excited to play this game than I've seen from you in the past.

VayneAuthority

United States8983 Posts

February 23 2015 04:24 GMT

#3943

just going to point out that it makes no sense to think my point on prphlz is good and not give me the same benefit when i STARTED the wagon, lol.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

February 23 2015 04:30 GMT

#3944

On February 23 2015 13:24 VayneAuthority wrote:
just going to point out that it makes no sense to think my point on prphlz is good and not give me the same benefit when i STARTED the wagon, lol.

You underestimate my paranoia, VA. The wagon never got more than two votes, and you bringing it up to "clear" prplhz also clears you be extension. Don't think I missed that xP

Prplhz is also my least certain townread...and you my least certain scumread. So it's not like I'm treating y'all much differently. He's just not the one who brought the defense up, and Palmar's read on him does seem to suggest he may be town.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

February 23 2015 04:32 GMT

#3945

Note the "deflecting suspicious off yourself" portion of my post?

VayneAuthority

United States8983 Posts

February 23 2015 04:56 GMT

#3946

I see. Well I think your reads are in general pretty terrible but I read you as town for whatever reason.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

February 23 2015 04:58 GMT

#3947

http://img.pandawhale.com/post-15765-7ZVQ.gif

Blazinghand

United States25559 Posts

February 23 2015 04:58 GMT

#3948

Well I'm probably dead so I'll be free of this place. Sadly, without my leadership, I'm not sure what you will do. Follow my guidelines for victory.

LS - Scum
VA - I've said it once, I'll say it again. VA is scum. RNG 5 Eva.

Don't trust Superbia. he's the SK.

lynch scum. don't be distracted.

I JKed Superbia.

rsoultin

Netherlands15308 Posts

February 23 2015 04:58 GMT

#3949

Lol I fail at gifs, apparently :/

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

February 23 2015 04:58 GMT

#3950

So I may very well die tonight, and it does not implicate BH. Scum probably still has the one-shot RB left from the JoaT.

So here are the people that are confirmed not mafia if neither LS or prplhz is the JoaT:
- FF
- RSO
- HtS

The fact that neither prplhz or LS wanted to switch to Palmar implies that at least one of them is scum. I honestly believe it's prplhz, but it may very well be LS (#1 helpful insights). I really hope the SK shoots LS tonight, since a lot of the game revolves around his alignment. I think he probably is town though.

Let's move on to scum.

So 1 between prplhz and LS seems likely.
4th scum is probably slam.

SK is probably ritoky, small possibility of FF.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

February 23 2015 04:59 GMT

#3951

Short but sweet.

Superbia

Netherlands8889 Posts

February 23 2015 04:59 GMT

#3952

Wait if BH is reading VA scum take a look at him as well.

Blazinghand

United States25559 Posts

February 23 2015 04:59 GMT

#3953

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

February 23 2015 05:00 GMT

#3954

DAY the FOURTH

Rsoultin Mrs. Miggins(Godfather) was shot!
Superbia Prince George(Veteran) was shot!

It is now Day 4. You have to find a lynch target. There are 8 players remaining.