VII Titanic Mini Mafia: I Have a Cunning Plan... - Page 197

On February 23 2015 03:25 LightningStrike wrote:
Btw SK feel free to kill me <3

On February 23 2015 03:24 Half the Sky wrote:
Also I can't remember if LS made his case BEFORE or AFTER Palmar voted prplhz. Knowing the vote count at that time would further soldify my feeling on this. If it was after, he needs to be lynched tomorrow unless town collectively agree to be SK hunting.

On February 23 2015 03:22 Half the Sky wrote:
Between Palmar's reads on him and his reaction? He's most likely one of the scummers we've been overlooking.

The fact that he's targetting "easy" lynches in prphlz doesn't help, especially with Palmar leaving his vote on prplhz. I don't know the vote count at the time Palmar voted, but it's really not looking good for him at all.

On February 23 2015 03:29 Half the Sky wrote:


No, not now. I am referring to the time (D3) we were all mostly taking a look at lynching him. Even when I was tracking scumreads early D3, nearly everyone had him on their lists. That's what I meant.

Now? I don't think prplhz is the lynch tomorrow. It's possible Palmar could have bussed him, but unlikely as SK was still alive. And a lot of people, like I said, had him on their lists.

Sorry I wasn't clear there.

On February 23 2015 03:36 rsoultin wrote:


I'm really torn on LS here, not gonna lie. Lots of little things that I associate with a town LS have been in his play throughout. And he's really hung in there and keeps trying to get his views out against a ton of opposition from some pretty strong players, not to mention several who just aren't giving him the time of day cause their minds are already made up. If he were scum I'd think he'd have given up by now?

EoD looks genuinely bad for him, though, and the prplhz case came out with the vote after thread sentiment was leaning that way more, which...if he'd just voted him before posting the case it would make me more comfortable :/ It definitely can be argued that the Slam metaread case was dropped because he couldn't get the wagon going.

LS, could you please explain to me why you stopped making a case against Slam? What specifically in his meta made you change your mind on him and switch to prplhz instead?

On February 23 2015 03:39 LightningStrike wrote:

BH told me that Slam play this game isn't exactly the same as Slytherin and swap to prplhz who I had a scumread in my PoE earlier. I made my case and just waiting for the SK to kill me but it feels like this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VDvgL58h_Y

On February 23 2015 03:44 rsoultin wrote:


I'm confused as to why you think you're a likely SK kill right now? I do remember that post from BH, but I think I got lost in it the first time I read it. hold on a sec.

On February 21 2015 08:36 Blazinghand wrote:


Hmm, I like where you're going here with slam, to an extent. I'm actually really interested in this, as I have a strong townread on slam this game! I naturally don't question your motivations much as you are conftown, but let's talk reasoning. I'm uh, not sure what exactly you're trying to point me at here in slytherin mafia. I do notice that in Slytherin mafia, slam isn't actually a huge pusher, but he does make some votes. In general though, yeah, his play in slytherin is definitely laconic. I'm not sure his play THIS game really matches up though, you know? Let me show you some of his stuff from this game that has no comparison from slytherin:

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewpost.php?post_id=23763674

in this post, Slam is actually pretty clear. He shred's TP's post with like, one lucid sentence. Not bad. Note that he also turns out to be right as there's double JK this game.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewpost.php?post_id=23773965

this and his two posts after it show some critical thought that I'd not have expected from scum slam.

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewpost.php?post_id=23778007

though he's wrong here it's a noble attempt.


I guess also part of it is that Slam acts like this as town, too, you know? Like yeah he's fooling around a lot but he IS making plays, compared with slytherin where he makes few.

On February 23 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
So I'm assuming you agreed with BH here? Did his points make sense to you based on what you saw in Slytherin, or were you just accepting his read?