Linux Mini Mafia - Page 23

On January 31 2015 18:29 sicklucker wrote:
Can you at least explain your policy lynch? Thats way too convenient.

On January 31 2015 15:44 Eden1892 wrote:
I see no issue with my reasoning. If it's your shtick as town to criticize quick role claims, and you know it is, then you're going to do it as mafia even if you're actually happy about it, because you're going to try to emulate your perception of your town behavior. You're going to do it, and because you're doing it artificially instead of naturally, it might not be a perfect facsimile of your town behavior. You might be underselling it, like you don't really care... or you might be overselling it, and become unreasonably upset about it, and unreasonably defensive when people call you on it.

In other words, exactly what I was worried about with you. Your statement that this is what "your meta says," as I'm interpreting it, seems to reinforce this idea, because it indicates that you were deliberately trying to interpret your own meta on the subject, when as town you presumably wouldn't be bothered about it.

I think you need to answer my question now. Am I misinterpreting your statement I quoted, and if so, how? If I'm not, how else am I supposed to interpret your behavior other than "you oversold your town proclivity to hate on blue claims because you aren't actually town"?

Work with me here. I'm entertaining the idea of your innocence, but if you don't cooperate with me when I ask a basic and important question, you give me very little recourse to assuming your guilt.

Its a really really bad play and my meta says I always try to stop people from doing it.

On January 31 2015 18:29 sicklucker wrote:
Can you at least explain your policy lynch? Thats way too convenient.

On January 31 2015 17:06 Trfel wrote:
Ok, sorry, I've been really distracted with IEM and stuff. I read through the thread twice, but not particularly in depth.

Surprised that rsoultin wasn't willing to read Eden1892's entire post. I guess it's late, and she wasn't expecting to need to play mafia, but rsoultin seems like the player who is willing to read every word of every post.

I understand why Eden1892 says he doesn't want to play as mafia, and his town games are always so short. And posting that isn't just a rant, it's a really good way to seem scummy and not get nightkilled (unless the mafia team is full of complete jerks and they nightkill him in pure cruelty).

I agreed with Holyflare a lot this game. The early pressure on Damdred, the pressure on sicklucker, and telling the other VTs not to claim.

Sicklucker has been acting suspiciously this game, and I'm inclined to scumread him. But I've always had a ton of trouble reading sicklucker. Our playstyles are basically complete opposites, so I have a lot of trouble understanding what he is trying to do, and I often can't understand his logic. Basically, I don't expect town!sicklucker or mafia!sicklucker would be able to answer all of the questions asked to him in ways that would satisfy me. Hopefully sicklucker will get some time to talk about other parts of the thread more, so we can get a better read on him.

I still don't like Robik's claim, and I don't think it makes him confirmed town. I asked a few times for an explanation, and no one really gave one, so I'll just ignore this for now. If it comes down to this in later stages of the game, I'll take another look. Roles, setup, and claims really aren't something I understand.

I'll try to be much more active and helpful tomorrow.

Player List
1) Trfel (Filter)
2) LightningStrike (Filter)
3) Chezitwo (Filter)
4) Damdred (Filter)
5) IAmRobik (Filter)
6) rsoultin (Filter)
7) sicklucker (Filter)
8) Half the Sky (Filter)
9) Eden1892 (Filter)
10) Palmar (Filter)
11) MARVELLOSITY (Filter)
12) HolyFlare (Filter)
13) FecalFeast (Filter)

On January 31 2015 12:28 sicklucker wrote:


Oh this post. You were not in the game but marvs scum strategy last game was the not post. So just him posting holds alot of value.

Last time I pressured marv he ragequit or something. I dont really want to do that again hes a good player

On January 31 2015 13:16 Damdred wrote:
People Who I would Lynch:

SL
Eden
Trfel

LS also I disagree that it is the same as New Years with how SL reacted. Anyway I gotta go for a little bit