|
On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read.
Except when someone in front of you takes it you don't know who took it...
|
On January 25 2015 04:30 Onegu wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. Except when someone in front of you takes it you don't know who took it...
I was going to argue with this but I came up with a reason not to talk about it.
Nevermind.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read.
q1. do you get mislynched as town?
if yes, your assertion that you're easy to read seems misplaced
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On January 25 2015 04:24 Onegu wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:23 marvellosity wrote:
Quite common really. Some people like it, people argue about whether they'll do it or not, much fun is had.
The first PYP I played we caught a mafia by having an order and roles that should be picked etc, so good things can come of it Then why don't we try it?
we can, if people discuss it like the milkman. I'm not gonna be proactive with plans though
|
On January 25 2015 04:34 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. q1. do you get mislynched as town? if yes, your assertion that you're easy to read seems misplaced
Yeah, I'm prbs gonna rethink my strategy here.
|
On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read.
You see, it doesn't really matter if you are easy or hard to read, you plan on taking a good role - if you are easy to read and you turn out to be scum we still got denied a DT. From this point of view, your reasoning simply does not hold. Of course it is not like Mafia taking the DT makes us lose or makes winning unbelievably hard to do.
|
On January 25 2015 04:38 The Milkman wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. You see, it doesn't really matter if you are easy or hard to read, you plan on taking a good role - if you are easy to read and you turn out to be scum we still got denied a DT. From this point of view, your reasoning simply does not hold. Of course it is not like Mafia taking the DT makes us lose or makes winning unbelievably hard to do.
That's partly why I wanted to just up and claim DT at the start, since there are so many juicier roles out there for mafia to hunt down and a bunch of talented players around to warrant kp being sent elsewhere despite a claimed vig running around.
The problem I realized was that there are a bunch of other roles that don't/shouldn't want to be claimed right at the start that are still invisible, so my plan doesn't really work.
|
Well, I'd picked 6, 13. So I should probably change that. Tbh I looked at the roles and don't really have a preferred one, per se, so if we want a big strategy I'm game with whatever. I'm not a top nk but usually am shot before the game ends, and I'm not an easy mislynch, if that helps.
|
On January 25 2015 04:42 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:38 The Milkman wrote:On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. You see, it doesn't really matter if you are easy or hard to read, you plan on taking a good role - if you are easy to read and you turn out to be scum we still got denied a DT. From this point of view, your reasoning simply does not hold. Of course it is not like Mafia taking the DT makes us lose or makes winning unbelievably hard to do. That's partly why I wanted to just up and claim DT at the start, since there are so many juicier roles out there for mafia to hunt down and a bunch of talented players around to warrant kp being sent elsewhere despite a claimed vig running around. The problem I realized was that there are a bunch of other roles that don't/shouldn't want to be claimed right at the start that are still invisible, so my plan doesn't really work.
Did you post this in the mafia QT before you posted it here?
|
Also I'm picking something townie.
|
On January 25 2015 04:42 ObiWanShinobi wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:38 The Milkman wrote:On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. You see, it doesn't really matter if you are easy or hard to read, you plan on taking a good role - if you are easy to read and you turn out to be scum we still got denied a DT. From this point of view, your reasoning simply does not hold. Of course it is not like Mafia taking the DT makes us lose or makes winning unbelievably hard to do. That's partly why I wanted to just up and claim DT at the start, since there are so many juicier roles out there for mafia to hunt down and a bunch of talented players around to warrant kp being sent elsewhere despite a claimed vig running around. The problem I realized was that there are a bunch of other roles that don't/shouldn't want to be claimed right at the start that are still invisible, so my plan doesn't really work.
For role pickings I'd wait for the order really, most we can do right now is to analyse the roles. It's a lot better than an usual Normal setup, because there's some rattling of our bone-boxes thanks to PYP system and to add that we also have unique roles. Basically, there's no time to be bored.
Also, I misread 'DT', heh. I though of Detective instead of Dark Templar. I thought you meant Observer. So denying town DT is not an argument, since we just don't want DT.
|
On January 25 2015 04:48 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On January 25 2015 04:42 ObiWanShinobi wrote:On January 25 2015 04:38 The Milkman wrote:On January 25 2015 04:28 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'm taking DT.
Anybody that tries to take DT from me will be claiming scum, especially when I'm a relatively easy read. There is 0 reason to give an check-immune role to a hard to read player, and I don't think I'm that hard to read. You see, it doesn't really matter if you are easy or hard to read, you plan on taking a good role - if you are easy to read and you turn out to be scum we still got denied a DT. From this point of view, your reasoning simply does not hold. Of course it is not like Mafia taking the DT makes us lose or makes winning unbelievably hard to do. That's partly why I wanted to just up and claim DT at the start, since there are so many juicier roles out there for mafia to hunt down and a bunch of talented players around to warrant kp being sent elsewhere despite a claimed vig running around. The problem I realized was that there are a bunch of other roles that don't/shouldn't want to be claimed right at the start that are still invisible, so my plan doesn't really work. Did you post this in the mafia QT before you posted it here?
Ouch, my pride.
|
At the very least people need to say what numbers we pick and if anyone lies they get auto lynched.
|
On January 25 2015 04:56 Onegu wrote:
At the very least people need to say what numbers we pick and if anyone lies they get auto lynched.
Eh, it kind of works and doesn't. What is more important is if we decide to go for role pickings for people they pick what they are told. It is of course important to check the numbers after we get the draft queue. Anyway my numbers are [4],[7].
|
You have to finish sending in your draft numbers, or change your exising ones if you wish. Draft order will go live after that.
|
Okay, changing my numbers to 8, 13 to not conflict with Robik. I thought there was more time on the draft numbers, lol.
|
|
|
On January 25 2015 04:27 Onegu wrote:
We have
Palmar 1,1
Oats and superbia 2,1 (the edited post was him saying he was claiming 2,1)
Mderg 3'3
Me at 5,13
Robik at 6,9
Obiwan 7,9
rsoul 8,13
We have 4 and 9-13 left
|
wait are we really tryharding with are numbers? is this a thing?
|
On January 25 2015 06:14 sicklucker wrote:
wait are we really tryharding with are numbers? is this a thing?
Why not?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
