VI Titanic Mini Mafia: The Return of MSPaint - Page 86

On November 24 2014 08:15 GlowingBear wrote:


Ok.

Motives I have scumread Templar
1) He is too passive, he is not really pushing the game forward
2) He says he hates meta reads but posts a meta read and says it was on purpose (lol?)
3) He wasn't hesitating to town read me (or at least to be suspicious of me) when he knows I'm capable of look townie when I'm scum.
4) He is parroting some people at some times (parroted me on VE, parroted damdred on sick lucker)

Motives I am now townreading Templar:

1) He is putting effort in the game (he has one of the biggest filters, he is interacting and giving reads)
2) He is taking genuine stances (he parroted people, yes, but he posted reads trying to push town to a different direction when he felt someone is scum)
3) I'm an easy lynch for mafia. He is not trying to lynch me. Period.

On November 24 2014 08:15 GlowingBear wrote:


Ok.

Motives I have scumread Templar
1) He is too passive, he is not really pushing the game forward
2) He says he hates meta reads but posts a meta read and says it was on purpose (lol?)
3) He wasn't hesitating to town read me (or at least to be suspicious of me) when he knows I'm capable of look townie when I'm scum.
4) He is parroting some people at some times (parroted me on VE, parroted damdred on sick lucker)

Motives I am now townreading Templar:

1) He is putting effort in the game (he has one of the biggest filters, he is interacting and giving reads)
2) He is taking genuine stances (he parroted people, yes, but he posted reads trying to push town to a different direction when he felt someone is scum)
3) I'm an easy lynch for mafia. He is not trying to lynch me. Period.

On November 24 2014 07:47 Fecalfeast wrote:


I think there was at least 1 mafia on SOS. HF was wrong and VE is probably actually vig.
I could see ritoky hanging on that counterwagon in case people from killerSoS start switching.
I have lian and rayn as town and they are doing many more things than I so there's a little sheeping here too.
Sicklucker's vote was a throw away vote, not saying that's very alignment indicative but last game when he was a possible lynch target he hopped on the other bandwagon just to not die and he was town. No, he probably wasn't going to get lynched over hopeless or SOS but it feels more like trying to stay away from the wagons to avoid suspicion to me.

Vote logic and sheeping list:
probably mafia:
templar
ritoky

possibly mafia
GB
slam
sicklucker

probably town
lian
rayn
ve

everyone else meh

On November 24 2014 08:36 GlowingBear wrote:
People, I'm not trying to defend myself anymore.
Maybe it's even better that town mislynches me so people don't waste day3 still debating me.

So you guys that decided your votes on me, let's talk about the others. I'm afraid we are still too much disorganised.

On November 24 2014 08:29 GlowingBear wrote:
Why don't you give a "deep" read then ritoky?
All you have done is scumreading me for the hopeless thing.

I'm mafia just for that?
And if yes, who are my partners?

On November 24 2014 08:37 liancourt wrote:


This is a pros and cons list. I didnt ask for this.

I want you to tell me your thought process on how your read EVOLVED from when temp posted his case on SL and when you voted him scum because of it and what you were thinking when you were "pushing" him. Also on what you were thinking when you wanted validation on your being town by asking temp reasons on why you were town. And then your final thoughts upon making that list post calling temp town.

On November 24 2014 08:38 Damdred wrote:


id like to talk about this post.

Tell me how this makes temp town. Reason three is bad because mafia will townread people a good bit of the time yea? Why are you an easy lynch? Why should you town read someone on that?

I think you said in another post that you think actives are mafia, why is this a town tell for temp in this case?

I'm partial to SL being scum but what other read or push has temp done today that causes you to say this?

On November 24 2014 08:43 Damdred wrote:



This isn't protown GB and you know it martyring never saved town anything and if we lynch you to not debate you tommorow what would we be stuck on then? Temp? Chez? Slam?

Optimum play is to scum hunt defend yourself when necessary and push your lynch so stop it

On November 24 2014 08:44 ritoky wrote:


can't right now, watching sounders and seahawks game simultaneously, maybe later i will show you

On November 24 2014 08:47 GlowingBear wrote:


My read on him evolved while I started pressuring him. The question about me being town was important because if he said I was scum, it means he was keeping his options open. He read me as null, which is not good but it's not a scumread. Then I started thinking about these town traits he has.

What I'm saying with that pros and cons is that I started reevaluating those traits

On November 24 2014 08:47 sicklucker wrote:
Ya you should never let yourself get mislynched in this game. I dont care what people told me in the other game its just stupid. If you know your town, leading people to vote anyone else besides you increases chance to catch scum.

On November 24 2014 09:00 liancourt wrote:


you know you're re evaluating him for the same reasons as you saw him as scum

and mafia can just as well say someone is town/null so easily and you take that action as him being townie

and he made a "bait" case on SL which is like saying "guys this isn't a real case I just wanted to see if someone would take the bait, don't berate me for having bad logic". WTF is this? And now he has no scum reads. HIjole~

I just can't understand how you can call him scum and then revert back.

It's like you wanted to prove to town that you could call him scum, but was afraid that it might get traction. And later when temp flips scum you can say you read him scum at one point.

On November 24 2014 08:57 GlowingBear wrote:


This is why I want to lynch you. You're forcing this lynch on me or at least drawing suspicions to me. But when asked to give other reads, you refuse. I'm almost sure you're scum.